PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   Southern Air 777 stall and recovery after takeoff, Nov 15th (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/636908-southern-air-777-stall-recovery-after-takeoff-nov-15th.html)

QNH1013 20th Nov 2020 09:05

Southern Air 777 stall and recovery after takeoff, Nov 15th
 

flightradar24

Departure out of JFK, audio reveals airspeed low warning and also the config warning (overspeed?) likely during recovery.

DaveReidUK 20th Nov 2020 09:57

Avherald quotes about 200' height loss during the event; ADS-B (via FR24) suggests more like 750'.

RoyHudd 20th Nov 2020 12:20

Hand-flying?

DaveReidUK 20th Nov 2020 12:38

https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....621f2c76db.jpg

3wheels 20th Nov 2020 13:05

First Officer handling?

RoyHudd 20th Nov 2020 13:15

Strange response. Many FO's handle manually better than CP's.

I was thinking that the a/c was not being flown using automatics. Employing automation relatively quickly is good practice in a busy TMA like that of JFK. It reduces the workload on the non-handling pilot. And at night, it removes the risk of somatogravic illusions and the like, which have caused accidents on jets not so long back.(Gulf Air 320, Flash B737, etc)

Broomstick Flier 20th Nov 2020 13:24

Hand-flying should have no influence, it is expected that both sides of the flight deck are competent in hand-flying at this point in their careers.
Maybe inadvertently retracting from flaps 5 to flaps up, instead of flaps 1?

Less Hair 20th Nov 2020 13:29

Why would they request a fast climb afterwards then?

Broomstick Flier 20th Nov 2020 13:40

To increase the margin on low-speed buffer due to high gross weight? Vref+80 on the Boeing type I currently fly is over 250kt at Max TOW.
Take a turbulent departure and keep normal speed (250 below 10000), you are in for a nasty surprise.

Whas the load and balance sheet accurate, is the first question here.

Less Hair 20th Nov 2020 14:03

That's the point.

Speed_Alive_V1 20th Nov 2020 14:52

Yikes - not a nice thing to hear on frequency. Handled well.

I wonder was it a sudden tail wind mixed with heavy laden aircraft? 250kias could be surprisingly close to the buffer zone I imagine

deltahotel 20th Nov 2020 15:38

If min speed (Vref+80) is greater than 250kts, you can fly at the higher speed. Max TOW, our 763 has +80 of 256kts, so that’s what we’d fly.

8driver 20th Nov 2020 15:52

The Kennedy 5 departure doesn't contain a published 250 knot restriction. Therefore only the FAR is applicable, and that states you can go to clean speed. I don't know why anyone wouldn't. Possibly an increasing tailwind, but 22s are generally in use with southerly or westerly wind. Wouldn't expect it until the turn.

White Knight 20th Nov 2020 17:14

Couple of things stand out:

Firstly that the stall warning sounds like it worked like it says on the tin. And the recovery was initiated.
Secondly there was a radio frequency distraction possibly increasing the PM's time head down.

Glad the piloting came back to save the situation!


nike 20th Nov 2020 20:25

Possible early ALT capture with the autopilot engaged...need to watch your speed as the autopilot will fly the capture profile without speed protection. Heavy weight and/or wind shift are equally possible but even low level if you have a high rate of climb as it goes into ALT or VNAV ALT watch out for the speed decay.

Capt Fathom 20th Nov 2020 20:55

The PM sounded sleepy on the radio. Then the stall woke him up! :eek:

Contact Approach 20th Nov 2020 21:37

So much utter nonsense being written here. Those that currently fly heavy Boeing types here have probably answered the question. Had it not been caught on the RT no one would have been any of the wiser. Well handled but nothing any competent crew couldn’t handle.

Capt Scribble 20th Nov 2020 22:01

"No one would have been the wiser", maybe not, until the operational data dump flagged up a stall on climb out. Not exactly an everyday event.

wheels_down 20th Nov 2020 23:02

Contact Approach

Regardless, still earns them tea and biscuits with the CP soon thereafter. Not normally pleasant conversations.

Dropp the Pilot 21st Nov 2020 00:21

All utter nonsense indeed.

Except nike.

Who is 100% correct.


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:28.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.