PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   Icelandair 757 Gear collapse at BIKF (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/629523-icelandair-757-gear-collapse-bikf.html)

Zeffy 7th Feb 2020 16:53

Icelandair 757 Gear collapse at BIKF
 
METAR BIKF 071530Z 13042G56KT

​​​​​​https://www.ruv.is/frett/hvilir-a-od...abunadur-brast

​​​​​​JACDEC
@JacdecNew
Icelandair Boeing 757-200 (TF-FIA, built 2000) experienced right main gear collapse on landing runway 10 at Keflavik (BIKF) in very stormy weather. (up to 56 kts) None on board flight #FI529 from Berlin-Tegel were hurt. METAR BIKF 071530Z 13042G56KT

750XL 7th Feb 2020 17:38

Oops

https://scontent-lht6-1.xx.fbcdn.net...d8&oe=5ECA9C5E

Modular Halil 7th Feb 2020 17:41


Originally Posted by 750XL (Post 10682034)

Pilot monitoring: "Set her down gentlyyy gentlyyyy gent--- bast@$d"

Airbubba 7th Feb 2020 17:54

More pictures from social media.

https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....1c08a3e3f5.jpg

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....178a464593.jpg

Ranger One 7th Feb 2020 19:46

Video of landing shot by pax:


OntimeexceptACARS 7th Feb 2020 21:41

To be fair gear collapses on 757s are very rare, that must have been a pretty severe downdraught, I'd wager.

ACMS 8th Feb 2020 06:56

Looked pretty smooth in that video........are we sure it suffered a downdraft hard landing?

Rocade 8th Feb 2020 07:39

Second part of the video shows the landing from the collapsed side https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ILdwSl...ature=youtu.be
It looks like the gear collapses at touchdown (which appears to be relatively smooth) and the spoilers restow almost immediately, either by pilot action or failed air-ground sensor of the collapsed gear. It also appears the pilots pick the right wing up until the airplane slows down and then it drops again.
Rumors are the the collapsed gear was recently overhauled and fitted less than 3 weeks ago...

ATC Watcher 8th Feb 2020 07:47

Great work by the PF .. looks like the wind is unrelated to this but that said when you are in 57 Gusty winds if there is an airline I want to be in is Icelandair .. .its breakfast for them ..

jmmoric 8th Feb 2020 09:54


Originally Posted by ATC Watcher (Post 10682407)
Great work by the PF .. looks like the wind is unrelated to this but that said when you are in 57 Gusty winds if there is an airline I want to be in is Icelandair .. .its breakfast for them ..

Agree, good work by the pilot.

The wind condition could favour a case like this, the groundspeed would be way less when the wing finally settles.

And Keflavik has crossing runways, and is located on flat land, so they often operate in quite strong winds. Problem comes with the air gates, and deboarding passengers when the wind picks up.

procede 8th Feb 2020 11:04

What seems weird to me is that the gear collapsed to the outboard, so opposite from the direction of retraction.

dixi188 8th Feb 2020 11:33

Side stay failure?

DaveReidUK 8th Feb 2020 11:46


Originally Posted by dixi188 (Post 10682563)
Side stay failure?

Hard to see what else might have caused it - the comment about it possibly being recently fitted may be significant.

I'd be surprised if there isn't some collateral damaged caused by the leg going in a direction it's not supposed to go.

Bergerie1 8th Feb 2020 12:09

"Late on the round-out Hoskins."

zerograv 8th Feb 2020 12:26


Originally Posted by dixi188 (Post 10682563)
Side stay failure?

Probably !

From the first picture, looks like that the collapsed gear did not move rearward, it only moved outward, so as you rightly say, the Side Stay might have been the weakest link.

What is also peculiar from the first picture, is that because the right side of the aircraft is actually sitting on the engine, therefore something that is more forward than the gear itself, that in turn results in some weight being added to the rear, behind of the point of support. It is quite noticeable that the Nose Gear is very extended, indicating that it is not much weight is sitting on it. Still, that is a lot better than if it would be sitting on the tail.

Rwy 10, Wind form 130º, therefore half of the wind intensity is Crosswind.

As mentioned above, this is a very windy place. Went there a few times during a summer years ago. On one occasion after landing, taxing to the gate, parking brake On, even completing the after flight paperwork proved to be a bit difficult as the aircraft was constantly oscilating due to the wind.

Airbubba 8th Feb 2020 12:54


Originally Posted by ATC Watcher (Post 10682407)
Great work by the PF ..


Originally Posted by Bergerie1 (Post 10682583)
"Late on the round-out Hoskins."

I'm sure if they had it to do over they would have gone around. :)

oceancrosser 8th Feb 2020 15:17


Originally Posted by Airbubba (Post 10682612)
I'm sure if they had it to do over they would have gone around. :)

Which would probably have given a much worse outcome, this happened at very low speed just before the runway turnoff.

N707ZS 8th Feb 2020 15:22

As there are no scrape marks behind the engine did the undercarriage collapse as the aircraft was turning off at the end.

capngrog 8th Feb 2020 16:13

That right main gear door hanging down indicates to me that a problem occurred during the L.G. extension sequence and was not related to touchdown forces at all.

Just my opinion.

Cheers,
Grog


DaveReidUK 8th Feb 2020 16:45


Originally Posted by N707ZS (Post 10682698)
As there are no scrape marks behind the engine did the undercarriage collapse as the aircraft was turning off at the end.

Looking at photos on the Net, the aircraft appears to be resting on the runway just before the 90° left turn onto Twy E-4 (runs parallel to Rwy 01/19), which could well have been its intended route to the gate.



Originally Posted by capngrog (Post 10682729)
That right main gear door hanging down indicates to me that a problem occurred during the L.G. extension sequence and was not related to touchdown forces at all.

I suspect that when the gear gave way, the engine would have impacted the runway with a pretty substantial thump, which could well have been sufficient to dislodge the gear door.


All times are GMT. The time now is 10:11.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.