PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   Lionair- the third pilot (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/628767-lionair-third-pilot.html)

retired guy 11th Jan 2020 21:47

Lionair- the third pilot
 
At the time just after the Lionair accident, there was much in the press about the jump seat guy who “saved” the same plane the previous day by advising the crew what to do- I.e. turn STAB OFF. The flight had identical issues as the fatal crash but flew for two hours to Mindanao I think.
Does anyone have references to that event because it seems to be very hard to find online?
It seems remarkable to me that the circumstances of the previous day are very relevant, yet they are omitted from the official report I believe.
Many thanks
ps this is not reopening the locked threads on the actual crashes. It’s about the one that got away!
R Guy

OldnGrounded 11th Jan 2020 22:13


Originally Posted by retired guy (Post 10660480)
At the time just after the Lionair accident, there was much in the press about the jump seat guy who “saved” the same plane the previous day by advising the crew what to do- I.e. turn STAB OFF. The flight had identical issues as the fatal crash but flew for two hours to Mindanao I think.
Does anyone have references to that event because it seems to be very hard to find online?
It seems remarkable to me that the circumstances of the previous day are very relevant, yet they are omitted from the official report I believe.
Many thanks
ps this is not reopening the locked threads on the actual crashes. It’s about the one that got away!
R Guy

I think this is the original story about Jump Seat Guy: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/artic...-later-crashed

Most of the MSM coverage started with references to this one (unless I missed something).

Peter H 11th Jan 2020 23:22


Originally Posted by OldnGrounded (Post 10660500)
I think this is the original story about Jump Seat Guy: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/artic...-later-crashed

Most of the MSM coverage started with references to this one (unless I missed something).

I think that you are right that that is were the story started, but the pilot seems to have been kept incommunicado,
so the story didn't develop.

However the final report contains several references the the deadheading pilot, and is the fullest account I've seen.

Search for references in http://knkt.dephub.go.id/knkt/ntsc_a...l%20Report.pdf

NB Search for dead as sometimes deadheading is used, and sometimes dead heading.

OldnGrounded 12th Jan 2020 00:35


Originally Posted by Peter H (Post 10660540)
I think that you are right that that is were the story started, but the pilot seems to have been kept incommunicado,
so the story didn't develop.

However the final report contains several references the the deadheading pilot, and is the fullest account I've seen.

Search for references in http://knkt.dephub.go.id/knkt/ntsc_a...l%20Report.pdf

NB Search for dead as sometimes deadheading is used, and sometimes dead heading.

Thanks for that. I inadvertently opened the preliminary report -- I have both saved -- and didn't find the references I wanted, so I thought maybe they just weren't there. Fingers and eyes moving faster than brain.

Pretty much as I remembered, the report indicates that the pilot in the jump seat was a helpful addition to the crew as observer and advisor, but there doesn't seem to be any confirmation of the MSM reports that he was responsible for diagnosing the trim problem.

Loose rivets 12th Jan 2020 22:36

There was a mention of him leaving his seat??? to get some notes. It all sounded oddly calm - ignoring the description of the stick shaker.


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:49.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.