PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   German Chancellor's A-340 Diverts to CGN enroute G-20 (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/615902-german-chancellors-340-diverts-cgn-enroute-g-20-a.html)

Airbubba 29th Nov 2018 20:20

German Chancellor's A-340 Diverts to CGN enroute G-20
 
From Deutsche Welle:


Angela Merkel's plane experiences technical defect en route to G20 summit

German Chancellor Angela Merkel's plane had to turn around and land in Cologne after only an hour in the air due to a defect. The plane has experienced several issues in the past few months. German Chancellor Angela Merkel's journey to Buenos Aires for this weekend's G20 summit was interrupted on Thursday after the government's "Konrad Adenauer" Airbus experienced technological difficulties in the air.

Issues with the government's A340 jets also caused travel problems for German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier during several of his diplomatic trips this year.

Shortly after departing from Berlin on Thursday evening, the plane circled over the Netherlands and landed at the Cologne/Bonn airport in western Germany — which is also home base for the German government's aircraft.

Merkel, who is also traveling with Finance Minister Olaf Scholz and a pool of journalists, hoped to switch into a replacement plane at the airport, but it is unclear how the travel interruption will affect the chancellor's attendance at the G20 summit — which is due to start tomorrow.

The pilot informed the chancellor and other passengers that a technical defect had caused several electronic systems on the Airbus A340-300 to fail, reported news agency DPA.



https://www.dw.com/en/angela-merkels-plane-experiences-technical-defect-en-route-to-g20-summit/a-46514663

She normally travels on A340 16+01 Konrad Adenauer.

tubby linton 29th Nov 2018 20:24

Very old A340 operated by a military that she has starved of funding. A shame that it didn’t happen somwhere very remote

Airbubba 29th Nov 2018 20:31

The plane departed TXL and indeed turned around near AMS.

From adsbexchange.com:

https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....a41a2ed3a1.jpg

DaveReidUK 29th Nov 2018 20:38

Not a Bonn voyage, then ?

Airbubba 29th Nov 2018 20:41

A social media update:


#Merkel’s plane stranded in Cologne on the way to #G20 due to a technical issue with the “German Air Force One”. She’ll fly commercial on Friday morning via Madrid, but miss part of the first summit day, according to journalists who accompanied her

gearlever 29th Nov 2018 20:52

This incident is characteristic for German Military and Government.

ShotOne 29th Nov 2018 23:32

I understand there was some embarrassment last year when the same aircraft was grounded at an IMF meeting because mice had damaged the wiring.

CargoOne 29th Nov 2018 23:58

Be real - airplanes are having problems every now and then. We may question why Luftwaffe do not have a spare aircraft for her immediately available but otherwise there is no drama. It is not a combat mission, it is a largely civil aircraft which (I believe) operated to the same manuals as Air France or Lufthansa - what is the fuzz about?

Starbear 30th Nov 2018 00:11


Originally Posted by CargoOne (Post 10324124)
Be real - airplanes are having problems every now and then. We may question why Luftwaffe do not have a spare aircraft for her immediately available but otherwise there is no drama. It is not a combat mission, it is a largely civil aircraft which (I believe) operated to the same manuals as Air France or Lufthansa - what is the fuzz about?

it could have been a close shave. Nein? Sorry I’ll get my coat.

CargoOne 30th Nov 2018 01:09


Originally Posted by Starbear (Post 10324127)


it could have been a close shave. Nein? Sorry I’ll get my coat.

i haven’t searched internet so I have no idea what has happened - do you know? Could be engine problem, hydraulics, pressurisation, avionics or galley smoke - while not nice, it happens every day will all kind of aircraft and nobody treats it as close shave. Unless there was something really serious - please share.

AndiKunzi 30th Nov 2018 02:55


Originally Posted by tubby linton (Post 10323952)
Very old A340 operated by a military that she has starved of funding. A shame that it didn’t happen somwhere very remote


Originally Posted by gearlever (Post 10323981)
This incident is characteristic for German Military and Government.

And since this is PPRuNe here, some experts not only do already know what happened, but those experts also know the root cause (maintenance and age) and who was responsible for that in the QMS.

Bull at a Gate 30th Nov 2018 03:00

Dear Cargo,

The reference to "close shave" was clearly prompted by your reference to "fuzz". Starbear was trying to amuse us all, and in my case he succeeded.

Bull at a Gate

Airbubba 30th Nov 2018 04:13


Originally Posted by AndiKunzi (Post 10324178)
And since this is PPRuNe here, some experts not only do already know what happened, but those experts also know the root cause (maintenance and age) and who was responsible for that in the QMS.



From the article linked above:


The pilot informed the chancellor and other passengers that a technical defect had caused the "malfunction of several electronic systems" on the Airbus A340-300.

According to multiple German media outlets, the aircraft experienced problems with its radio equipment, but the pilot said there had been no safety risks. German news magazine Der Spiegel reported the crew had to use an onboard satellite phone in order to plan the landing.
They were squawking 7600 inbound to Cologne according to ADS-B tracking logs. Latest reports seem to indicate that they had a massive failure in their comm radios.

According to Der Spiegel there was a backup plane in Berlin but it was decided to be too risky to fly all the way to TXL lost comm and the decision was made to land overweight in CGN on 14L. Fire trucks were rolled to spray the hot brakes.

The Chancellor and her entourage were bussed to an official residence in Bonn to spend the night. Another Luftwaffe plane is scheduled to fly out in the morning to MAD to put the VIP's on Iberia 6849 MAD-EZE. Perhaps the backup plane has its own problems and they trust a scheduled airline more for the long trip.

The Luftwaffe's problems with aircraft readiness even in the VIP fleet are nothing new as others have observed here.

Esabee 30th Nov 2018 04:15

Complete failure of comms with ground
 
Gernan magazine Der Spiegel report the a/c lost the ability to communicate with the ground and the crew had to use satellite telephones to effect the diversion. On landing at CGN they were given a very short rwy, the a/c was full of fuel, and the effort required to come to a stop then stuffed up the brake systems.

judebrad 30th Nov 2018 08:13

Not exactly the greenest of airliners, you would have thought they would have had some A330's in the fleet.

Less Hair 30th Nov 2018 08:35

Interestingly they took the shorter runway for their overweight landing to keep the longer one open for the UPS night hub. That's german pragmatism.

PENKO 30th Nov 2018 08:46

Less Hair,
Do you know for sure if they were landing overweight? And if so do you even remotely think there was a performance issue in relation to the chosen runway?
Or do you always land on the longest available runway, never do intersection, flex or derated takeoffs?
No need to answer the question.

Less Hair 30th Nov 2018 08:56

They were fueled up for Buenos Aires and landed after one hour - without any problems. Fire brigade was in place to cool those hot brakes.

oliver2002 30th Nov 2018 09:26


Originally Posted by judebrad (Post 10324290)
Not exactly the greenest of airliners, you would have thought they would have had some A330's in the fleet.

This aircraft is a former Lufthansa A343 which was completely overhauled by LHT in Hamburg. I don't see where it's age plays any role. This aircraft is maintained by Lufthansa Technik so the usual comments about German military comments probably shouldn't apply.

gearlever 30th Nov 2018 09:36

2nd A340 also in EDDK, but no crew.....
Kanzlerin gestrandet trotz Ersatzmaschine

Less Hair 30th Nov 2018 10:48

The crew of No. 2 had been kept at readiness but got released right after takeoff of No. 1. Afterwards their legal duty time left was not enough to go to Argentina anymore.

mfeldt 30th Nov 2018 10:59


Originally Posted by gearlever (Post 10324358)
2nd A340 also in EDDK, but no crew.....

Interestingly the linked article claims that the affected system also prevented the discharging of fuel so the AC had to land fully loaded...

Joe_K 30th Nov 2018 11:03


Originally Posted by mfeldt (Post 10324425)
Interestingly the linked article claims that the affected system also prevented the discharging of fuel so the AC had to land fully loaded...

Yes, Die Zeit is also reporting : "It is currently assumed that a fault in an electronic distribution box, which control both the radio system and the system for discharging the kerosene", see https://www.zeit.de/politik/deutschl...el-g-20-gipfel

Joe_K 30th Nov 2018 11:13


Originally Posted by judebrad (Post 10324290)
Not exactly the greenest of airliners, you would have thought they would have had some A330's in the fleet.

Nope, apart from the two A340 they only have six A310 (five of which are MRTT and the other is inherited from Interflug), a couple a A319 and an A321.

Less Hair 30th Nov 2018 11:22

Right after takeoff, around the Wolfsburg/Hannover area. Satcom did the job.

BRE 30th Nov 2018 11:26


Originally Posted by gearlever (Post 10324446)
According several media via SAT COM.

Then why continue out to the sea? Were they hoping to dump only to discover that the pumps were also done in?

Less Hair 30th Nov 2018 11:28

They called Merkel up front first from some talk in the back and she agreed to turn around. That is not much flighttime.

tubby linton 30th Nov 2018 11:59

Aircraft Comm systems are powered by seperate parts of the electrical system . The fact that other components also failed points to major problems in the electrical system.
This aircraft was grounded on a previous mission due to rodents eating the wiring looms according to news reports.

Less Hair 30th Nov 2018 12:14

No. 2 is on it's way to pick her up afterwards.

BRE 30th Nov 2018 12:34

Apparently, the failed box is called "transformer rectifier unit". A number of flight displays and some hydraulics were also affected.

So why was there independent power for all the other stuff, but the three radios were all routed through this TRU?

oliver2002 30th Nov 2018 12:36


Originally Posted by mfeldt (Post 10324455)
I'm not sure, but I guess the delegations going to BA are pretty large, so you don't just book a full bird onto another one. Of course you could take the chancellor there alone, but I guess that would violate a number of protocols.

The press corps and various mandarins distributed themselves on any possible commercial flight still available today, mostly in economy. Iberia ex MAD was the only option left for the Chancellor and her team. Other G20 heads of state were already on their way. She will miss her date with Trump too... this creates major protocol head aches.

oliver2002 30th Nov 2018 12:41


Originally Posted by Joe_K (Post 10324438)
Nope, apart from the two A340 they only have six A310 (five of which are MRTT and the other is inherited from Interflug), a couple a A319 and an A321.

The A310 used to be the transport mode before the two A343 were purchased from Lufthansa in 2010. The A319 are configured as CJs but don't have the range to get to EZE. The A321 (also used LH) has just joined the fleet after a 2 year retrofit.

Less Hair 30th Nov 2018 12:43

A fuelstop is no big deal. Better than spending another night in Germany before starting to move.

Less Hair 30th Nov 2018 12:49

With the support of your foreign office and the military you can certainly get some diplo clearance. What's the problem? We are not talking about overflying North Korea.
This is the only point about owning a fleet like this. Short notice VVIP-travel.

Nemrytter 30th Nov 2018 13:32

God, it's amazing how many experts are on here. Merkel should hire this lot in future, then she'd not only get there on time, she'd probably arrive before she left.

tubby linton 30th Nov 2018 13:36

A single TR failure should not lead to loss of all comms.There are four TR-1,2, ESS and the Apu TR fitted.

Airbubba 30th Nov 2018 17:10


Originally Posted by gearlever (Post 10324358)
2nd A340 also in EDDK, but no crew.....




Originally Posted by Less Hair (Post 10324413)
The crew of No. 2 had been kept at readiness but got released right after takeoff of No. 1. Afterwards their legal duty time left was not enough to go to Argentina anymore.

16+02 Theodor Heuss was originally positioned to TXL for backup landing at 1613Z and flew back to CGN at 1826Z, landing at 1918Z. 16+01 Konrad Adenauer started its turn back to CGN at 1914Z. It looks like even if a swap could be organized, as the reports say, no duty time left for either crew.


Originally Posted by ShotOne (Post 10324115)
I understand there was some embarrassment last year when the same aircraft was grounded at an IMF meeting because mice had damaged the wiring.

Don't know if it also happened earlier but rodents grounded 16+01 in Indonesia last month:

German minster's plane grounded after rodents gnaw through cabling

Oct 14, 2018

Nusa Dua, Indonesia (dpa) - Members of German Finance Minister Olaf Scholz's delegation remained stranded in Indonesia on Sunday after rodents gnawed through the cables of a government plane during the annual meetings of the International Monetary Fund (IMF).

Scholz himself landed in Berlin on Sunday after a 22-hour flight from Bali, with changes in Hong Kong and Zurich.

The Social Democrat (SPD) politician had to be back in Germany as soon as possible because of state elections in Bavaria and the need for consultations with his party.

Rodents - probably mice - had nibbled through the electrical cables of the "Konrad Adenauer," sources at the IMF meeting told dpa.

Scholz was told on Saturday that he should choose a few of his closest aides to return with him, and was initially asked not to report the incident, the sources said.




16+02 left CGN for EZE at 1257Z this afternoon. Will they book some return tickets just in case?

offa 30th Nov 2018 17:38

I thought Airbus fitted a RAT in order to solve the electrics / rodent problem?

Jhieminga 30th Nov 2018 19:00

... should have fitted a CAT....

zerograv 30th Nov 2018 23:44


16+02 Theodor Heuss was originally positioned to TXL for backup landing at 1613Z and flew back to CGN at 1826Z, landing at 1918Z. 16+01
Konrad Adenauer started its turn back to CGN at 1914Z. It looks like even if a swap could be organized, as the reports say, no duty time left for either crew.

2 Crews, or 1 Augmented Crew, could probably push the Duty Time "envelop" a few hours, if the aircraft swapping at CGN would not take very long ...


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:09.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.