PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   Heavy casualties reported in Algerian IL78 crash (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/607655-heavy-casualties-reported-algerian-il78-crash.html)

captplaystation 11th Apr 2018 08:39

Heavy casualties reported in Algerian IL78 crash
 
According to initial report (from the Sun mind you ) as many as 200.

https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/602311...h-toll-latest/


https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2018/...081014559.html


Just googling it seems the 78 is mainly a tanker, and that it is likely a 76 (which is what Algerian military operate ) but, of no consequence in this tragedy.

DaveReidUK 11th Apr 2018 09:04


Originally Posted by captplaystation (Post 10114254)
According to initial report (from the Sun mind you ) as many as 200.

Just googling it seems the 78 is mainly a tanker, and that it is likely a 76 (which is what Algerian military operate ) but, of no consequence in this tragedy.

The Al Jazeera link correctly identifies it as an Il-76. The narrative and photos of the crash site in open farmland don't really square with the "as many as 200 dead" report in the Sun, though clearly all on board perished.

StormyKnight 11th Apr 2018 10:29

Video Grab: Scene outside Boufarik airport after Algerian military plane crash
Shows tail of aircraft with left horizontal stabilizer in the vertical position.

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Dafc_V8XcAI4K28.jpg

Video can be seen on this page
BREAKING Algerian Military plane with about 100 people onboard crashed near Boufarik airbase | AIRLIVE.net

Officer Kite 11th Apr 2018 10:53

Algerian Ennahar tv reporting 300 onboard with 247 confirmed dead so far.

Edit to add just gone up to 257

rcsa 11th Apr 2018 11:22

Il-76 payload = 17,500Kg. 300 pax + bags = 30,000kgs.

Plane crashed just after take-off.

Oops.

StormyKnight 11th Apr 2018 11:41


Originally Posted by rcsa (Post 10114436)
Il-76 payload = 17,500Kg. 300 pax + bags = 30,000kgs.

Plane crashed just after take-off.

Oops.

I hope it's not the error of using the average person weight for the load calculation instead of the real weight of serviceman & kit.

If so it's not the first time this has happened.

StopStart 11th Apr 2018 11:48

IL76MD, a variant the Algerians have, can lift approx 40T of payload.

CargoOne 11th Apr 2018 11:51


Originally Posted by rcsa (Post 10114436)
Il-76 payload = 17,500Kg. 300 pax + bags = 30,000kgs.

Plane crashed just after take-off.

Oops.

Il76 payload depending of a model is 40 to 50 tons. Nevertheless the normal troops capacity is around 150 or so...

atakacs 11th Apr 2018 12:31

At least 257 on board... That sounds like a fairly significant overload!

andrasz 11th Apr 2018 12:45

Al Watan (the most reliable Algerian news source) also reports 257 casualties, 10 crew the rest military personnel and their families.

Weight wise not an issue (some Il-76 variants can take as much as 60 tons payload) but how on earth did they manage to cram that many into that space (perhaps some fold-down double-decker config, like it was in the C-124 ?)

Karel_x 11th Apr 2018 12:50


Originally Posted by andrasz (Post 10114516)
Weight wise not an issue (some Il-76 variants can take as much as 60 tons payload) but how on earth did they manage to cram that many into that space

Balance issue?

Carbon Bootprint 11th Apr 2018 13:00

According to the BBC, the 257 aboard consisted of not only troops but also their families, so conceivably there may be many small children among them. There are also 10 crew believed killed, presumably included in the number being cited. A massive tragedy for the Algerians.

TylerMonkey 11th Apr 2018 13:11

https://i62.servimg.com/u/f62/11/94/64/62/bcc42b10.jpg

Hold size 728x135” = 682 sq ft

For 250 passengers each would have 2.73 sq ft or a 1.6x1.6 ft space on the floor.

Tight !

CargoOne 11th Apr 2018 13:18

There is a double-decker config for IL76 making it aprox 250 troops capacity but I am not sure how often/widely it used these days...

http://milaremina.ru/wp-content/uplo...aya-paluba.jpg

flash8 11th Apr 2018 13:23

Possible Engine failure with MTOW exceeded... nightmare scenario.

CargoOne 11th Apr 2018 13:26


Originally Posted by flash8 (Post 10114550)
Possible Engine failure with MTOW exceeded... nightmare scenario.

You cant exceed MTOW on IL76 with just 250 pax and fuelled for Algerian domestic flight

andrasz 11th Apr 2018 13:41


Originally Posted by CargoOne (Post 10114546)
There is a double-decker config for IL76

That's the one I was thinking of, thanks. Read about it somewhere but could not find a photo anywhere.


Originally Posted by CargoOne (Post 10114553)
You cant exceed MTOW on IL76 with just 250 pax and fuelled for Algerian domestic flight

Completely agree, the load while unusual is well within aircraft capabilities, and may be easily accommodated with the kit shown above. Any number of things (or more likely their combination) could have gone wrong here (bird strike, incorrect flaps/slats, thrust, W/B just to name a few), at this stage there is nothing to go on. El Watan reports that the accident happened right on the airport perimeter (and is also confirmed by the released photos & videos, there are built up areas further along the extended centreline in both directions) so whatever happened occurred just around liftoff.

Gilles Hudicourt 11th Apr 2018 14:13


Originally Posted by rcsa (Post 10114436)
Il-76 payload = 17,500Kg. 300 pax + bags = 30,000kgs.

Plane crashed just after take-off.

Oops.

The Algerian Air Force operates both Il-76 and Il-78. This could be either. There are different models with different weights, but on average, their empty weight is about 92 tonnes and their Zero Fuel Weights are 139.5. So on average, they can haul a payload of about 47 tonnes, although I find that on the internet, most indicate a payload of 42 tonnes.

andrasz 11th Apr 2018 14:37

Accident location
 
https://www.google.com/maps/@36.5305.../data=!3m1!1e3

Clearly identifiable from videos/photos posted on news sites and social media, in fields between A1 highway and the end of RWY 22. The airport perimeter guard towers appear clearly in some photos.

Rob Bamber 11th Apr 2018 15:01


(bird strike, incorrect flaps/slats, thrust, W/B just to name a few)
Fairly intact tail section resting close to engines and fuel tanks, together with the proximity to the end of runway suggest a stall to me.

Condolences to all involved.


All times are GMT. The time now is 20:47.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.