PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   Aircraft parts found Reunion,Mosambique, and SA (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/575988-aircraft-parts-found-reunion-mosambique-sa.html)

Accomplice 22nd Mar 2016 20:15

Some more pictures showing the scale of the debris.

Imgur: The most awesome images on the Internet

etudiant 22nd Mar 2016 20:40

That is a seriously fractured structure. It suggests a disintegrated aircraft.

2EggOmelette 22nd Mar 2016 21:08

Daft question I know, but what material is it constructed from?

porterhouse 22nd Mar 2016 21:35


It suggests a disintegrated aircraft.
this alone suggest nothing.

etudiant 22nd Mar 2016 22:02


Originally Posted by porterhouse (Post 9319405)
this alone suggest nothing.

I'll defer to structural experts, but so shredded a piece of cowling suggests a pretty violent event.
What is missing is floatable debris from inside the hull. There should be some if the airplane was as violently smashed as the debris to date suggest.

Benjane 22nd Mar 2016 22:04

According to a recent article in National Post, it was found by a SA archaeologist named Neels Kruger "On South Africa’s southern coast, Neels Kruger was walking along a lagoon on Monday afternoon, near the town of Mossel Bay when he spotted something that did not seem to suit the natural surroundings."
That's 212 miles almost due east of Cape Town (-34.116009, 22.124018), close to the very tip of Africa.

beamender99 22nd Mar 2016 22:09


That's 212 miles almost due west of Cape Town (-34.116009, 22.124018), close to the very tip of Africa
.

A typo? Four and a half hours by car East from Cape Town, for those who know the area, along the Garden Route.

Benjane 22nd Mar 2016 22:13


shredded a piece of cowling suggests a pretty violent event.
I'll concur with porterhouse: this suggest nothing for the hull. Engine may slam first in the water and even get torn away without necessarily rupturing the hull. (as in US Air 1549)

Benjane 22nd Mar 2016 23:12


showing the scale of the debris
And showing yet another type of core. Spirit AeroSystem inc supplies struts and nacelles to Boeing and nothing else according to their website. Another supplier must deals with fairings (Lotter part displays rectangular sections), flaperon looks with aramid core too and No Step aluminium. Makes sense since all those part are subjected to different and specific stresses.

invaders 23rd Mar 2016 15:17

Could this be a MH370 toilet found on a South African beach?
 
A Dutchman claims to have just found this toilet on Dolphin Beach in South Africa. Could this possibly be from a 777?

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CePYHiGWIAE2_7e.jpg

Trackmaster 24th Mar 2016 01:43

Latest on Australian investigation of debris. Most likely from the missing aircraft.

https://t.co/kCNES87upq

mickjoebill 24th Mar 2016 02:08


Originally Posted by Trackmaster (Post 9320796)
Latest on Australian investigation of debris. Most likely from the missing aircraft.

https://t.co/kCNES87upq

To be pedantic,
report on ABC says it is definitely from a 777. Investigation team have not forensically linked it directly to MH370. The assumption is that since no other 777 jets have crashed it is "highly likely " to be from MH370.

The Australian transport minister is still upbeat that crash site will be found.

Mickjoebill

_Phoenix 24th Mar 2016 02:24

Great news. Among with RR piece of nacelle found in South Africa (quite clear it's origin), we count 4 debris from MH370.
But, no extra news/results from French investigators about detailed investigation/analysis of flaperon?

deanm 24th Mar 2016 02:46

'No Step' debris = MH370
 
Looks like the real deal:

MH370: Debris found in Mozambique 'almost certainly' from missing Malaysia Airlines plane - ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation)

The 'Rolls Royce' engine cowling fragment will likely be next...

Dean

Passenger 389 24th Mar 2016 03:50

With information known so far, is it possible to determine whether that RR fragment (if it is valid) would be from the cowling on the port or on the starboard engine?

I ask because the two confirmed 777 pieces (flaperon found on Reunion, and flap support fairing found in Mozambique) reportedly were both from starboard - and as some have noted, from the same general area on the plane.

deanm 24th Mar 2016 04:17

P389: your curiosity is valid & something I share.

Given the previously-announced indication that the right-hand engine was likely the first to flame-out (with 12-15 minutes fuel remaining for the left-hand), one might expect the aircraft (if uncontrolled) to have entered the water right-wing down.

If the right-hand flaperon was fully down so as to compensate for this bank (and the flaperon would have been largely ineffective with a dead engine ahead), it is likely to have been promptly detached on contact.

So far, the bits we have are from the right...

It may be tricky to assign the RR logo debris to left or right side, given that the fragment appears to be relatively small.

Dean

susier 24th Mar 2016 16:07

Report of yet another piece found on a beach in Wilderness, S.A. not too far from Mossel Bay.


Piece of Air Malaysia plane found in Wilderness? | George Herald | Garden Route


No images as yet. According to (only) source it's been handed in to the CAA already.

beamender99 24th Mar 2016 16:19

See images @ #61 above

beamender99 24th Mar 2016 16:22

Susier.
Sorry. My mistake. Yet another part found ?
We need a numbering system .

NorthernChappie 24th Mar 2016 16:40

Is a sweep of the surface points east from these locations not worth considering?


All times are GMT. The time now is 12:01.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.