Originally Posted by A0283
(Post 9176436)
. . . . To this day pilot incapacitation has not been an item. |
RYFQB Revisiting the satellite images of 01 november for some speculation... I'm pretty sure the piece at the top is the tail section. Cone at the center or left, HS (grey, no shadow) at the bottom, perhaps? "Tail", "left cone" and "HS" objects sit approximately 900, 750 and 1050 meters ENE (perpendicular) of the recorded path, respectively. The "tail" object ~200 m after recorded vertical speed went negative, and the "left cone" object ~200 m before same point, in the direction of travel. If 11:25 is EET/Moscow time, then this was 08:25 UTC, at which point the sun would be at 160 degrees azimuth (SSE) and 43 degrees above the horizon, according to WolframAlpha. https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?m...Vw&usp=sharing |
A0283, yes, but "overpowering" the AP would be unvoluntary disconnection as well, i.e. not a normal way to disconnect the AP. But I guess it should not take more than 2-3 sec (I don't know the exact force required, it might be in some maintenance manual, but I don't think its more than 3 or 5 kg or so...). But as others have said I think it highly impropable that some sort of incapacitation caused this event (the aircraft is protected,in normal law the only way to overload the aircraft would be through massive rudder inputs...)
|
|
Kulverstukas, you have the sides wrong paired, left/right right/left.
|
Originally Posted by Kulverstukas
(Post 9176542)
pics above
Also - looking just above the slot on the left side of the APU cone (where the top attachment of the HS pivot mounting would have been) is that just normal muck, or does that look like an area of sooting on an otherwise apparently fire-free tail cone? |
Kulverstukas, you have the sides wrong paired, left/right right/left. It means that HS leading edge travels down much more than allowed. |
The lower end of the HS pivot mounting let go on both sides and swang backward on the top attachment, breaking the frame of the separation ring and prising the APU cone away at the bottom?
Otherwise - the HS pivot somehow spontaneously let go both sides (appears totally implausible), dropped below the slot and the attaching lugs of the HS centre punched into the APU separation ring, to the same effect? |
Originally Posted by Kulverstukas
(Post 9176575)
Low panels bears marks of hit from lower pinions.
|
Flo
"I noted that they landed with 17 tons of fuel remaining on on flight"
Can you point us to where you see 17t ? That doesn't make any sense to me. |
HS issues
#2036 (permalink)
Just a guess- since we have not seen any HS "wing box " structure- it may well be that that structure along with jackscrew attach points and surrounding ' skin' has been removed from wreckage after cutting out the CVR and FDR to show what was found almost immediately. That would include some of the attach lugs/points of the VS- which are missing. Some of the 'damage' to surrounding parts as seen may be the result of on the ground dissassembly to load on truck(s) As to the obvious bending -breaking off of HS near simultaneous- IMO that could be caused by simply breaking the jackscrew or its follower or its mounting points allowing the HS to move towards being a flat plate to the airstream. - evidenced by the pulling down of the fuselage ret he tension unzipping of upper half forward of the AFT door. What caused the breaking or slippage is yet to be determined Until either the HS ' wing box ' is found or revealed- we have probably reached the practical end of a reasonable analysis- Explosive residue is another issue re initiation and where in aircraft :ugh: |
Oldchina, On the extracts from the Flightlog - its on Flightlog page 26916...it says remained 17000kgs, Uplift 3930kgs giving a total of 20930...it seems to be a case of rather extreme tankering as the rotation was DME-LED-SSH...
|
JDD1 the CVR and FDR are located in the cabin above the rear lavatory not under the HS.
|
|
Vnav path, thats one with 7 tons (the accident flight), but there is also a previous one with 17t, page 26916...
|
Looking back at photos of the Hudson plane, it's possible to see pins connecting the two plates of the HS pivot hanger above and below. So once the HS goes down beyond a certain angle, the bottom edges of its attaching lugs will collide with the lower pins, twisting the hangers backward at the lower end and pushing onto the APU separation ring.
Between the twisting of the hangers and the sudden downforce/drag, you suddenly have a whole lot of forces at work on the tail of the aircraft. |
|
other than a bomb...
barring a bomb, what structural failure (if any possible) would be required to cause an instantaneous catastrophic failure and departure of the tail. |
@mudman
I started a Google map to chart the debris field. Based on the satellite images and images from the ground this is what i have so far... https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?m...Vw&usp=sharing - i think that you last reliable location position could be added to, the flight radar 24 S data indicates that at 04:13:15 the data starts going nuts, at 30.149689 34.178521, this is just to the west of the debris field and could indicate the start of 'event'. - based in photos i think that the most east wreckage (30.168889, 34.171111) is an engine. This is determined from emergency vehicles and other wreckage in the background of photos. |
Until either the HS ' wing box ' is found or revealed. The desert is hardly a hostile topography for finding such pieces. |
All times are GMT. The time now is 03:07. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.