PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   Comair Boeing 737 suffers wheel collapse at Johannesburg (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/569663-comair-boeing-737-suffers-wheel-collapse-johannesburg.html)

oleostrut 27th Oct 2015 13:31

MLG is very high wear and high maintenance equipment. So much so that many airlines have complete overhaul shops dedicated to just the gear.

Not only the movable pieces, but the trunnions take a beating as well. On an otherwise pristine appearing aircraft it is amazing to see how worn and beat up the gear can be.

Inspectors will quickly determine the cause.

travelmaneurope 27th Oct 2015 13:56

Aircraft retirement
 
I guess this is one way to retire your old classics

They could have done it without pax on board

Gerald_D 27th Oct 2015 15:12

4 days ago in Peru:
2015-10-23 Peruvian Boeing 737-300 gear collapse at Cuzco » JACDEC


2 months ago in Indonesia:
Accident: Cardig B733 at Wamena on Aug 28th 2015, main gear collapse on landing short of runway


6 months ago in India:
Jet Airways plane's landing gear collapsed at airport in India | Daily Mail Online


last year, Solomon Islands:
Airwork (Toll) Boeing 737-300F right main gear collapses today in the Solomon Islands | World Airline News


etc....

thcrozier 27th Oct 2015 15:27

Regarding the Cuzco Incident
 
"The aircraft was unable to taxi on under its own power.."

fc101 27th Oct 2015 15:44

Given enough thrust I'm sure you could taxi, gear or not :-)

oleostrut 27th Oct 2015 16:26

Accident: Cardig B733 at Wamena on Aug 28th 2015, main gear collapse on landing short of runway


The gear collapse in this one appears to be trunnion failure.

CaptainSandL 31st Oct 2015 10:46

Yes, but the Cardig trunion failure was caused by the 3.68G landing which was in turn caused by not going around from an unstable approach.

I don't think that the problem is that the 737s landing gear is weak but the beatings they are occaisionally given in some parts of the world is immense.

Any aircraft's MLG will fail if you land hard enough on it.

Super VC-10 15th Mar 2017 17:19

Report released, flare started too high.
Accident: Comair B734 at Johannesburg on Oct 26th 2015, left main gear collapse on landing

The Ancient Geek 15th Mar 2017 17:44

Reading the report, the high flare was a contributing factor.
The root cause was an internal oil leak in the shimmy damper, after which the holes in the swiss cheese lined up. The MLG detached as designed to prevent wing penetration, spar damage and a serious consequent fire risk.

Full marks to all involved for the good outcome, it seems that trying to grease it on is a bad idea on the 737.

DaveReidUK 15th Mar 2017 18:39

Full text here, including FDR readouts and Comair's response to the investigation report:

South African CAA - Aircraft Accident Report and Executive Summary

widgeon 15th Mar 2017 20:05

what sort of animals would be on a 737 , glad to see they were not injured.

OD100 16th Mar 2017 00:41

Agreed. Here in the US, SWA and a few others and doing a MASSIVE amount of 73x landings every day. I'd imagine SWA is king of the cycles...

Gear seems to be staying on....

cooperplace 17th Mar 2017 14:17

plainly not a wheel issue but rather a landing gear issue.


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:41.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.