PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   Drones threatening commercial a/c? (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/550269-drones-threatening-commercial-c.html)

unmanned_droid 20th Dec 2018 14:05


Originally Posted by Tetsuo (Post 10340480)
Only photo I could find is below. Eddie Mitchell is a journalist for BBC and also a drone pilot.

https://twitter.com/brightonsnapper/...61518933499904

This pic is of the npas helo searching? Not the troublemaker drone?

Mechta 20th Dec 2018 14:09

Sometimes I wonder if I should change my name to Mystic Meg?

8th Dec 2014 Post #55 https://www.pprune.org/jet-blast/552...ml#post8774881



If they were flying to a pre-programmed destination then the up and down link wouldn't be required. This would make RF jamming on up and downlinks pointless. Jamming GPS frequencies would have so many implications for all the other users that I would doubt it would be considered.

As for anti-aircraft use of drones, only two would be needed to take out the majority of airliners. Jamming of up and downlink frequencies would be worth doing in this case, as the video would be necessary to home in on the target.

The intentional nuisance value of drones should not be underestimated. A number of them flying a GPS racetrack course could close an airport for an hour or so, whilst attempts to down them would be likely to create a FOD hazard.

Speedloafer 20th Dec 2018 15:12

Military now deployed.

Piper_Driver 20th Dec 2018 15:39

It seems tto me the safest alternative is to shoot it down from above using a shotgun in a police helicopter. At close range it would be hard to miss. You could see where the overspray was going to wind up, thereby minimizing any collateral damage. If you approach from above the drone camera will never see you coming.

Fostex 20th Dec 2018 16:00

Most drones (e.g. DJI) are fitted with a mix of GPS, solid-state accelerometers and gyros, barometric altimeters and multiple cameras for object avoidance and visual odometry. They really are quite sophisticated and relatively inexpensive.

Quite shocking that it is possible to purchase technology like this without regulation or licence.

Nige321 20th Dec 2018 16:09

Daily Mail has a video. Make of that what you will....

Asturias56 20th Dec 2018 17:01


Originally Posted by londonman (Post 10340646)
And what would you do if you were in charge...just curious. They're not amateurs.

Having been through LGW today it seems that the initial incursions were overnight - it cannot be beyond the wit of man, even Surrey Police, to follow any drone observed for some part of the way. If there are no flights a police helicopter should be able to follow them (again part of the way). Then ground patrols in the area.

All I hear is hand wringing and buck passing and suggestions of "studies"

DroneDog 20th Dec 2018 17:02

Looking at the latest footage taken from a mobile phone, to my eye, it looks like a quad, for me, it has the distinctive shape of a Phantom bit it must be an early machine the later beats are geo-fenced.

Its become surreal now, these things have limited control range, nobody with a spectrum analyser and a directional antenna.

Council Van 20th Dec 2018 17:12

After 20 hours the police have asked for the support of the military.

I wonder at what point this evening the Minister for Aviation will be handing in her resignation?

DaveReidUK 20th Dec 2018 17:14


Originally Posted by Asturias56 (Post 10340644)
Maybe one thing they can do when the place reopens is to lift the flight curfew until say the 25 th to maximize use - and to make the train and bus companies run 24/7......

BBC currently reporting that the Government has temporarily lifted the night flight restrictions at the other London airports.

Shandy52 20th Dec 2018 17:24

Various possible defences against drones have been put forward; may I add my twopence worth?
In my infosec days, there was concern expressed about the ability of "HERF" (High Energy Radio Frequency) guns to damage electronic equipment in data centres. Now, I know such things have been built using magnetrons such as those from microwave ovens; but I'm unsure whether anything exists that could fry a drone's electronics at a range of (say) 150 metres or so. Attacking the drone's electronics directly would make it unnecessary for the drone to be under direct control to be vulnerable - also avoiding the problem of flying metal.
FWIW Wikipedia has an article on "directed energy weapons".

First.officer 20th Dec 2018 17:28

Rain forecast overnight should curtail any activity for a period....might allow LGW to re-establish a little "normality"?

DroneDog 20th Dec 2018 17:42

Apparently, they are trying to track the op

This kit has been seen in Gatwick https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....da0d3b25f0.jpg


The gear has capabilities...

https://www.coptrz.com/dji-aeroscope/

EDMJ 20th Dec 2018 17:47

So what if these drones had been carrying explosives, and/or had been flown directly into the path of aircraft full of passengers taxying, taking off or landing?

Gatwick Airport is currently implicitly sending the message to come and try this out, as they obviously have no means whatsoever to deal with this situation. And this probably applies to many, many other airports too.

Airbubba 20th Dec 2018 17:57

Airport Notam'ed closed until 22Z:


A4116/18 NOTAMR A4111/18
Q) EGTT/QFALC/IV/NBO/A /000/999/5109N00011W005
A) EGKK B) 1812201835 C) 1812202200
E) AIRPORT UNAVAILABLE DUE TO DRONE ACTIVITY IN THE GATWICK ATZ

Dct_Mopas 20th Dec 2018 18:33

LGW was closed earlier until 1600z. No sitings of drones for a few hours, low and behold at 1600z the drone made an appearance. This group/ individual is having a right laugh at us all, just useless. This could go on for days!

Airbubba 20th Dec 2018 19:04


Originally Posted by 750XL (Post 10340765)
They're now saying the airport is closed until 0600z tomorrow....

Correct, from Eurocontrol:


EGKK( Gatwick)
Airfield unavailable extended until 0600 21st Dec.
Intended reopening is at 06oo UTC 21st Dec 2018.
Not sure but I would think if this happened at JFK or LGA ops would continue with a line added to the ATIS like 'Birds and unauthorized drone activity in vicinity of airport, advise controller on initial contact that you have information ZULU.'

Dct_Mopas 20th Dec 2018 19:08

Ryanair flights for tomorrow (Friday 21st) all moved to operate out of Stansted instead of Gatwick.

Gatwick airport saying passengers should not travel to the airport for the foreseeable future, including tomorrow. (Sky news)

Going well then...

unmanned_droid 20th Dec 2018 19:16


Originally Posted by DroneDog (Post 10340710)
Apparently, they are trying to track the op

This kit has been seen in Gatwick https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....da0d3b25f0.jpg


The gear has capabilities...

https://www.coptrz.com/dji-aeroscope/

My research and contacts suggests there are a very varied set of opinions on this kit. I wish them luck.

PPRuNe Towers 20th Dec 2018 20:10

No news. Closed till 0600z. Jetblast for the hopeless and opinionated.

Rob


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:12.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.