PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   Arrow Air DC-10 loses part of engine on t/o Manaus (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/367516-arrow-air-dc-10-loses-part-engine-t-o-manaus.html)

aerotransport.org 26th Mar 2009 18:15

Arrow Air DC-10 loses part of engine on t/o Manaus
 
G1 > Brasil - NOTÍCIAS - Parte da turbina de avião cai e danifica casas em Manaus

The Aviation Herald

continues to Bogota on 2 engines :\

GrandPrix 26th Mar 2009 18:18

Say it ain't so. Arrow air having mechanical irregularities.:eek: Who would have thunk it?:rolleyes:

Charles. 26th Mar 2009 19:18

Easy to understand why they didn't want to be stuck in Manaus with an engine to replace...

Is that such a big fault not to resume the flight on two engines, particularly on a freighter ?

Machaca 26th Mar 2009 19:21

http://i337.photobucket.com/albums/n...g/Arrow301.jpg


http://i337.photobucket.com/albums/n...g/Arrow338.jpg


http://i337.photobucket.com/albums/n...g/Arrow212.jpg


http://i337.photobucket.com/albums/n...g/Arrow140.jpg


http://i337.photobucket.com/albums/n...g/Arrow056.jpg

JW411 26th Mar 2009 19:24

Well, British Airways can manage LAX to Manchester with an engine shut down, so what's the problem?

golfyankeesierra 26th Mar 2009 20:04

The problem is that Bogota is at elevation of about 8500' and that is actually the bottom of the valley.
It's in the middle of the Andes while Manaus is probably as flat as a pancake; don't they have cold beer there?

earlyNFF 26th Mar 2009 20:50

maybe it was a round trip, suitcase in BOG;)

MarkerInbound 26th Mar 2009 21:13

Since the crew was informed that parts hit the ground and Brazil has been know to jail crew involved in accidents, they may have thought getting out of the country was the best thing to.

Paradise Lost 26th Mar 2009 21:18

When they say "it lost part of an engine", which bit was actually left on the aircraft?

gas path 26th Mar 2009 22:26

Looking at the blade hanging on that ladies wall I'd hazard a guess at a turbine disc letting go...not unusual if it's a GE CF6:\:8.

golfyankeesierra 26th Mar 2009 22:38

BTW looking at the foggy windshield of the car in Machaca's photo's, I wonder what that guy was doing when it was hit by the engine:}:}:}

ReverseFlight 26th Mar 2009 22:39

I appreciate an aircraft can fly on just 2 engines but what about the change in C of G with such a large piece missing ?

It must have been trimming at the limit.

hellsbrink 26th Mar 2009 22:41

GYS

No idea what he was doing BEFORE the engine came down (good point, Paradise Lost, which part is left on the aircraft) but I bet ya I can guess what he did when the engine landed beside him.

lomapaseo 26th Mar 2009 23:21


Looking at the blade hanging on that ladies wall I'd hazard a guess at a turbine disc letting go...not unusual if it's a GE CF6.
Turbine disk failures have been very rare even in that machine

Turbine blade failures not nearly as rare in most machines.

The CF6 has had a number of events that look just like this (about 1 every two years)

ankh 26th Mar 2009 23:40

there's one more picture
 
G1 - O Portal de Notícias da Globo - GALERIA DE FOTOS - Veja fotos de parte da turbina que caiu em Manaus

#4 in the set of 6 pictures isn't copied above

Look at the chunk out of the roof and wall of the house, you can see the engine was still moving sideways when it hit the ground.

muduckace 26th Mar 2009 23:43

Nice pictures, sort of looks like a shuttle "pod". Been through Manaus and Bogota many times. I want to say rwy 33L/R faces mountains and is usually landing / take off direction. Heavy engine out would suck, I don't see why they can't get a ferry permit back to KMIA, should not be a problem empty.

Never seen a CF-6 shear off a turbine section/tailcone. Must have been last few stages. They are known for spitting blades "coreing out".

Diver-BR 27th Mar 2009 00:01

According to an official statement, the tower contacted the crew after hearing a loud bang during the take-off. The crew denied any anormality. After being informed that parts of the engine from the plane were found, ACC contacted the crew once more. Only then they informed that they had shut down one engine.

:: FAB - Força Aérea Brasileira ::

Willoz269 27th Mar 2009 00:17

If that is what the crew did, you don't get surprised at how some American airlines and their operators are considered in certain parts of the world...this is truly appalling!

Machaca 27th Mar 2009 00:38

http://i337.photobucket.com/albums/n...g/Arrow461.jpg


http://i337.photobucket.com/albums/n...g/Arrow444.jpg


http://i337.photobucket.com/albums/n...g/CF-6-50z.jpg


http://i337.photobucket.com/albums/n...g/Arrow477.jpg


http://i337.photobucket.com/albums/n...g/Arrow485.jpg

SouthpawSLF 27th Mar 2009 00:44

Considering the distance, the high altitude landing at Bogota, and the alt landing spots (nil) in between, I would think it takes quite a pair to make the decision to continue after losing one out of Manaus...


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:51.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.