PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   TunisAir tailstrike video (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/307703-tunisair-tailstrike-video.html)

kontrolor 4th Sep 2007 20:33

TunisAir tailstrike video
 
Youtube

any idea what happened? this dosen't seem to be normal landing (maybe windshear?)

sleeper 4th Sep 2007 20:51

By the looks of it (by no means conclusive) a late flare, touch and bounce during the flare and then the pitch up rate is checked too late. The pitch up rate is possibly caused by the (late) rapid flare as the ground is rushing up.

Mrs-rodge-bless-her 4th Sep 2007 21:13

Hmmmmmmm

Tailstrike alright. Happens a lot with new crews that switch from 320 - 321 as 321 is longer.

But never seen it happening like that... on the Tunisair 320.

Nice vid.

Hand Solo 5th Sep 2007 01:14

Didn't look all that late! Looks to me like he bounced it then tried to hold it off for a smooth landing. What he should have done was hold the pitch attitude and accept it thumping down on the main gear. Done the thumper several times myself.:(

Dream Land 5th Sep 2007 01:19

I looked at the video several times, I don't believe this is a tail strike, close but no cigar, the pitch up was caused by a "hold it off, landing technique that leaves you in a nose high attitude and low airspeed, as soon as the mains touch, ground spoilers deploy and because of the CG, pitch the nose up further, all covered in the FCOM.

Dani 5th Sep 2007 03:17

Agree, Dream Land. If there would be a (hard) tailstrike you would see smoke and/or sparks, which I couldn't see even after several attemps.

HotDog 5th Sep 2007 03:28

Very close but the tail did not strike the ground. Very lucky!

Yacov 5th Sep 2007 03:34

I theenk there eess a leetle streak of brown on the tail though eef you look closely:)

HotDog 5th Sep 2007 03:36

Well, if it's a night stop, they'll have time to wash it off.:E

underread east 5th Sep 2007 08:48

Think I'd have a little brown streak on my tail if I'd done one like that too!!

5150 5th Sep 2007 08:54

Probably some kind of software error. . .

tightcircuit 5th Sep 2007 10:47

The spoilers don't come up on the first touchdown. After the bounce he holds the attitude at first, as you should, but then the spoilers deploy fairly slowly and it is then that the pitch increases. I am a boeing man so I don't know what effect (if any) spoiler deployment has on pitch on an A320. Come to think of it since it is probably full ground spoiler deployment rather than just flight spoiler not many airbus chaps will have experienced it either.

naceur 5th Sep 2007 21:37

tailstike
 
i fly a 320 321 as captain
some pilots sometimes keep the nose up as long as possible after touchdown hoping a better aerodynamical deceleration :ugh:
jet fighters use this technic
i dont know if this was a tail stike or not

Bus Junkie 7th Sep 2007 04:16

The nose goes up with ground spoiler deployment. He felt the sink with the spoilers deploying in the air, the nose went up, he pulled back more to try to save the landing. There was a thread a while back about pitch attitudes for tailstrikes in the 320, I don't remember the number for struts extended - about 12 degrees? anyone? A average 320 touch down is about 6 to 8 if flared.

Edited for:
The FCOM does not recommend the nose being held off for aerodynamic braking. I don't think any transport aircraft would recommend it. If you get in this habit it will bite you when you experience a strong crosswind.

barit1 7th Sep 2007 17:41

Boeing (and McD-D before that) strongly discourages aero braking. It's an old military tactic that resulted in too many overruns. :uhoh:

calypso 8th Sep 2007 21:06

Keeping the nose in the air during the ground run increases the lift from the wing and although this gives a higher aerodinamic drag it also reduces the weight on the wheels. As a result the antiskid will prevent the full brake pressure being applied and the landing distance will be longer. Not a recomended technique.

It looks cool though.

topgun b737 9th Jan 2008 00:56

it was not a tail strike, very lucky just passing near. i meet the pilot of this a/c. and he told me that he pulled back more to try to save the landing after bouncing due to excessive speed and a late flare.

mrcabbage 9th Jan 2008 09:52

You can clearly see it's the strobe light flashing NOT a tail strike!

ACMS 9th Jan 2008 12:57

So basically he admitted to stuffing it up ....

luck lucky.

RatherBeFlying 9th Jan 2008 13:38

On the first touchdown, I see smoke from both mains one after the other, then a bounce.

Then the ground spoilers deploy with the a/c in the air:uhoh:

My guess without specific AB knowledge is that wheelspin and/or WOW was detected on both wheels which initiated ground spoilers which continued to full deployment in the air even though WOW came off.


All times are GMT. The time now is 01:59.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.