PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   RAF announces Puma Replacement plan (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/638863-raf-announces-puma-replacement-plan.html)

Evalu8ter 20th May 2023 22:49

Chinook 240. Indeed! I think NMH is now highly likely to be cancelled. Any delay to a 2025 ISD (which, as a fully operational and certified military platform only the UH-60 has a hope of making….) will nudge it closer to the window for the already delayed, for near term cash reasons, the much more important MH-4…..errr….sorry ‘H-47ER’ acquisition. That, and Chinook CSP, are the army’s aviation priorities now they’ve secured AH-64E. I doubt Army HQ’s / JHC’s budget runs to doing both at the same time. Furthermore, if Puma is extended to 2028 then the ‘gap’ between NMH entering service and the need to start scoping Merlin/Wildcat replacements shrinks to a handful of years - and MoD has ‘form’ with cancelling the likes of SABR and FRC, then combining programs, and announcing it as ‘new money’ (and the NMH money effectively disappears). MoD seem to think that, if it survives, NMH could be the ML backstop while Merlin is replaced - but without any ship compatibility requirements, that’s a bit of a non-starter. The only ‘interim’ that makes any sense continues to be Black Hawk, and the US Army is committed to the aircraft until the 2070s. Give Yeovil some cash to design the MUAS part of Wildcat replacement, and an assurance they will either licence build the V-280 with UK avionics/DAS (which I predict Leo will also do for the Italians….) or produce the Euro NGR (likely to be aligned with Franco-German needs to support Airbus), and buy 20-30 UH-60s would be my suggestion…..

Evalu8ter 20th May 2023 22:54

HiLife - not strictly true that all 3 are ‘OTS options’. H175M doesn’t exist; it’s not certified as a military aircraft, has zero military provenance and it will take years to design, fit and qualify the necessary military equipment. The ‘H175M’ demonstrator is simply a H175 painted black, and still has its Chinese DNA. AW149 is better placed, but I don’t doubt that MoD would not be satisfied with the mission equipment choices or TTPs of such stellar reference customers as the Thai Police and Egyptian Navy. Black Hawk has an ‘out of the box’ capability, literally dozens of certified options and several high quality users to crib TTPs etc from.

Stratofreighter 19th June 2023 10:40

Bidders likely to wait until September for next stage of UK New Medium Helicopter tender | News | Flight Global

Procurement of a replacement for the Royal Air Force’s Puma HC2 rotorcraft under the UK’s New Medium Helicopter (NMH) programme appears to be further delayed, with no clarity on when the next stage of the tender will begin.

Shortlisted candidates for the £1.2 billion ($1.5 billion) contract for up to 44 helicopters were identified last October 2022, but the process has not advanced since then.



At that point, Ministry of Defence (MoD) officials were intending to issue an Invitation to Tender – detailing the precise requirements for the contest – to the selected bidders by the first quarter of 2023.

That deadline subsequently slipped to mid-year and now, FlightGlobal understands, the document will not be released before September 2023 at the earliest.

Further delays to the acquisition increase the likelihood that the MoD will fail to meet its target of introducing the NMH by 2025.

However, the MoD declines to comment on the timeline for the procurement. “Responses to a questionnaire have been evaluated to determine a shortlist of suppliers for the New Medium Helicopter competition,” it says.

“Suppliers were notified of the outcome in October 2022 and successful candidates will be invited to participate in the second half of the competition, due to be launched later this year.”



n addition to the RAF’s Pumas, the NMH is intended to replace three other types: Bell 212s and 412s, and Airbus Helicopters AS365 Dauphins used by the Army Air Corps for special forces missions.

The two Bell types, operated in Cyprus and Brunei, have already been retired and replaced by Pumas, seeing that helicopter’s life extended to at least 2025, if not beyond.

At recent House of Commons Defence Select Committee hearing, Air Marshal Sir Richard Knighton said a further extension, to 2027 or 2028, would be “feasible”.

Airbus Helicopters provides support for the Puma fleet through an ongoing sustainment contract that currently runs through 2025.

Lucifer Morningstar 23rd June 2023 15:44

Unfortunately I am not permitted to post links yet, but the Aviation Press is publishing a statement today from Sikorsky, stating that if they win NMH then they would 'assemble' the aircraft in the UK and possibly use that facility to build export variants for other nations as well. This clearly makes their bid stronger in terms of UK social and economic benefit. Now, the term 'assemble' could mean many things and does not neccessarily imply a full production facility, but the fact that this is being mentioned at all is very promising in my view as the Blackhawk is clearly the only NMH contender that is fit for the role.

Let us hope this program survives and is awarded sooner rather than later. As things stand, it could potentially be put off into a new Government and then all bets would be off.

minigundiplomat 23rd June 2023 17:07

https://www.flightglobal.com/helicop...153864.article

Link for the article.

This significantly alters the dynamic and puts AH and Leonardo on the back foot.

Non-Driver 19th July 2023 08:58

Numbers being scaled back:

https://www.flightglobal.com/helicop...154164.article

Very political that "up to 44" now sits in the range 25-35......

Lucifer Morningstar 24th August 2023 13:05

Looks as though NMH is now on an indefinite delay. The longer the legacy aircraft are kept going, the closer we get to the advent of FLRAA and FVL being viable options. I suspect that the winner of the NMH program may end up being none of the current bidders.

https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/uk-he...d/?trackingId=


SimonPaddo 24th August 2023 13:18


Originally Posted by Lucifer Morningstar (Post 11490701)
Looks as though NMH is now on an indefinite delay. The longer the legacy aircraft are kept going, the closer we get to the advent of FLRAA and FVL being viable options. I suspect that the winner of the NMH program may end up being none of the current bidders.

https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/uk-he...d/?trackingId=

Looks like the Puma is replacing itself at the moment :oh:

[email protected] 24th August 2023 13:29

Well Leonardo were hosting an event this week very much aimed at promoting the 149 as heavily as possible - it looked very nice close up:ok:

It would mean jobs kept at Yeovil which we know historically plays well with the politicians.

domperry76 25th August 2023 10:53


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 11490720)
Well Leonardo were hosting an event this week very much aimed at promoting the 149 as heavily as possible - it looked very nice close up:ok:

It would mean jobs kept at Yeovil which we know historically plays well with the politicians.

You mean I was in the presence of forum royalty and never knew?

[email protected] 25th August 2023 11:03


You mean I was in the presence of forum royalty and never knew?
:) Who do you think flew the Sea King in:ok:​​​​​​​

domperry76 25th August 2023 11:05


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 11491243)
:) Who do you think flew the Sea King in:ok:

My compliments on a fine showing then. Whither the promised Wessex though?

[email protected] 25th August 2023 12:35

A knackered starboard engine which has been hot starting for a while and is now toast and due a replacement:)
Fortunately we have a few spares.

Northernstar 25th August 2023 14:51


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 11490720)
Well Leonardo were hosting an event this week very much aimed at promoting the 149 as heavily as possible - it looked very nice close up:ok:

It would mean jobs kept at Yeovil which we know historically plays well with the politicians.


Are jobs really at risk given this week's news? Or is it the usual Yeovil grab of everything with associated threats to ensure no competition?

https://www.flightglobal.com/helicop...154670.article

NutLoose 25th August 2023 15:21


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 11491288)
A knackered starboard engine which has been hot starting for a while and is now toast and due a replacement:)
Fortunately we have a few spares.

Pssst.... you wanna buy some? sadly not Wessex ones.


https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/115628263...Bk9SR5yIvNTFYg

[email protected] 25th August 2023 15:23

Thanks Nutty but we have quite a few proper Wessex ones to choose from:ok:

PPRuNeUser0211 25th August 2023 20:37


Originally Posted by Northernstar (Post 11491391)
Are jobs really at risk given this week's news? Or is it the usual Yeovil grab of everything with associated threats to ensure no competition?

https://www.flightglobal.com/helicop...154670.article

I'd say it's a good opportunity to play a little waiting game then break the Yeovil stranglehold if they've got enough orders of WC/me from elsewhere. Get Sikorsky in with some actual battlefield helicopters

trim it out 25th August 2023 20:50


Originally Posted by pba_target (Post 11491579)
I'd say it's a good opportunity to play a little waiting game then break the Yeovil stranglehold if they've got enough orders of WC/me from elsewhere. Get Sikorsky in with some actual battlefield helicopters

Why should the boots on the ground and in the air have to wait because some politicians and uniformed desk jockeys try and play a game with an industry they know don't really understand, or have a terrible reputation for playing poorly at.

Somebody just needs to get a grip and get on with it. "The only thing worse than a bad decision, is no decision".

[email protected] 26th August 2023 06:45

Those politicians and desk jockeys have been playing this game for all the time I have been flying and will probably continue to do so because there isn't the money to have what we want - or so they keep telling us..

We wanted Blackhawk back in the 80's and we're still waiting.

trim it out 26th August 2023 07:50


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 11491737)
Those politicians and desk jockeys have been playing this game for all the time I have been flying and will probably continue to do so because there isn't the money to have what we want - or so they keep telling us..

We wanted Blackhawk back in the 80's and we're still waiting.

"We" never get asked though.

The people making procurement decisions (who get shuffled around every couple of years) likely will never operate in or with the kit they are on the project teams for. The only people that suffer are the end users. Defence industry sounds like a great place to work though from all the career fairs (circuses) I've been to!


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:24.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.