PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   Increased parasite drag by dirt and bugs (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/608537-increased-parasite-drag-dirt-bugs.html)

Jimmy. 6th May 2018 09:19

Increased parasite drag by dirt and bugs
 
Does anybody have sources with data about the subject? On a quick research I just have found airplane information and few or no numbers.
Thanks!

Ascend Charlie 6th May 2018 11:07

Dirty rotor blades - salt, bugs, dust - can make the torque requirements go up quite a bit. Ice is even worse. Data? None, sorry, but I have seen the Tq go down when I have cleaned and sprayed the blades with WD40.

GrayHorizonsHeli 6th May 2018 11:42

before anyone goes and lubes up their blades so that they may lift humongous loads with ease, be sure that the product is acceptable for use by the manufacturer, especially on a composite blade. I'm sure I don't need to be telling people that, however...Ive seen some really stooopid !!!! over the years.

My story on the subject involved 500's with ice and horse flies. No matter the season, the buildup did have an effect, most noticeably on the torque.
With so many blade shapes, designs and sizes, to do a comprehensive data collection would be an enormous task, and I don't think it's worth the time do to so to simply find out dirty blades effect performance and to what degree.

Simple solution is to clean them when they are dirty.

TwinHueyMan 6th May 2018 16:29

I've found it matters quite a bit when performance margins are close. I carry a rag in my bag for this exact reason. Using water out of my bottle I always have anyways usually does the trick and keeps the mechanics from yelling at me. Don't forget the tail rotor.

When I was taught to do it, twas at flight school in a salty environment with 22s. Seem to remember it could drop your MAP at a hover by an inch or more if I'm remembering correctly, but it's been a while.

Mike

albatross 6th May 2018 18:42

The smaller the blade chord the greater the loss of lift..500s were famous for this...dirt, bug, ice contamination or sand erosion and useful load was lower.
Brand new 500...stump puller...2-300 hrs in a sand environment..not so good.
Luv the 500, great aircraft, so no criticism intended.

Ascend Charlie 6th May 2018 19:51

Just read the title again and Jimmy is after Parasite Drag, rather than Profile Drag, so I suspect he is more interested in dirt on the fuselage.
At helicopter speeds, it won't make much difference, though a shiny aircraft will impress the customers more than a dirty one.

r22butters 6th May 2018 21:38


Originally Posted by Ascend Charlie (Post 10139715)
Just read the title again and Jimmy is after Parasite Drag, rather than Profile Drag, so I suspect he is more interested in dirt on the fuselage.
At helicopter speeds, it won't make much difference, though a shiny aircraft will impress the customers more than a dirty one.

So, wipe the bird !!!! off the blades, but leave the dead bugs on the windshield.

Jimmy. 8th May 2018 21:42

Thank you all for the answers. Ascend Charlie is right, I was thinking about the fuselage.
Despite the logical way to don't worry about this is to keep it clean, when you are not directly responsible for the cleaning/washing and need to make an argument on reducing intervals, some data or case study could help.

Wiggins61 9th May 2018 00:53


Originally Posted by Jimmy. (Post 10141635)
Thank you all for the answers. Ascend Charlie is right, I was thinking about the fuselage.
Despite the logical way to don't worry about this is to keep it clean, when you are not directly responsible for the cleaning/washing and need to make an argument on reducing intervals, some data or case study could help.


Time to take on more responsibility me thinks.

John Eacott 9th May 2018 01:15

Many moons ago I operated 206L on low skids with skid fairings, which got along fairly well at about 108kias. A complete professional polish with an approved Teflon polish put the cruise up to ~115kias, and later a further polish of the blades (after much checking with Bell for approval) nudged the cruise up to 117kias, all with the same power and OAT, etc.

So, the initial fuselage polish was predominantly responsible for the improved performance, all from an asthmatic C20!
http://www.eacott.com.au/gallery/d/4...hurst+1987.jpg

Jimmy. 9th May 2018 09:39


Originally Posted by Wiggins61 (Post 10141720)



Time to take on more responsibility me thinks.

I agree. However, sometimes a pilot could be fliyng in a company with a tight flight schedule -45 minutes between flights, down to 30 in some occasions-, where pilots are not allowed to clean or wash the helicopters and the maintenance perform preflight inspections -pilots just performing turnarounds.

whoknows idont 9th May 2018 18:48


Originally Posted by Jimmy. (Post 10141979)
I agree. However, sometimes a pilot could be fliyng in a company with a tight flight schedule -45 minutes between flights, down to 30 in some occasions-, where pilots are not allowed to clean or wash the helicopters and the maintenance perform preflight inspections -pilots just performing turnarounds.

Well if you trust these chaps with your preflight then you might as well just trust them with how thoroughly they clean the thing.

ShyTorque 9th May 2018 20:28

Typical PPRuNe...chap asks a question about practical aerodynamics and soon ends up getting told how he should run his operation. :rolleyes:

nocarsgo 9th May 2018 21:43

Just pickup a few rolls of this to smooth things over.


https://multimedia.3m.com/mws/media/...l-tape-425.jpg


http://www.flystickers.com/media/cat...spdtape-bl.jpg

whoknows idont 9th May 2018 21:49

Shy, you are right. No insult intended. It just appeared a bit like he was looking for a scientific way to tell his footmen to keep his toy nice and shiny.

Jimmy, have you compared the values prior and after a much needed cleaning?

Jimmy. 10th May 2018 20:22


Originally Posted by whoknows idont (Post 10142513)
Shy, you are right. No insult intended. It just appeared a bit like he was looking for a scientific way to tell his footmen to keep his toy nice and shiny.

Jimmy, have you compared the values prior and after a much needed cleaning?

No, when started to think about I posted here. I'll to do that on my next shift and post. Thank you all.
:ok:

FLY 7 11th May 2018 08:26

Blade tape also hampers performance.


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:25.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.