PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   S61N crash Florida (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/584079-s61n-crash-florida.html)

CertGuy 14th September 2016 12:35

Well, the TC Data Sheet lists max passengers at 39 + 2 pilots. That's 41.

Minimum Crew: 2 (pilot, copilot)
Maximum Passengers: 39, limited by emergency exit requirements

Shabby reporting by who? Looks accurate, though obviously they weren't outfitted for 41. I doubt many are.

212man 14th September 2016 13:57

http://rgl.faa.gov/Regulatory_and_Guidance_Library/rgMakeModel.nsf/0/04d7abf9f420a47786257c670064810c/$FILE/1H15_Rev_18.pdf

I wonder how that looks? Maybe they use narrower seats in the right hand double rows, and then add doubles to the left?

SASless 14th September 2016 14:05

Insider....it said "Seats"....not "Passengers".

Small detail I know....but.....really!


Sadly, the FAA and their Preliminary Reports do not have a wonderful record of excellence.

If they get the Tail Number right seems to be about the limit of accuracy sometimes.

212man 14th September 2016 14:36


, the FAA and their Preliminary Reports
NTSB even - small detail I know..... ;)

SASless 14th September 2016 20:05

212man.....finger/brain interface problem....thinking one thing and typed another.:{

industry insider 14th September 2016 21:47

I will stand corrected on the TCDS then, I should have checked. Never saw more than 23 +3 crew in my day but the Penzance aircraft carried 30+ I think.

John Eacott 14th September 2016 22:44

Updated report and some pre and post crash video:

Remaining Palm Bay helicopter crash victims ID'd


Authorities confirmed the identities of two other people killed in a fiery helicopter crash last week in Palm Bay.

Brevard County officials named Jason Dunnam, 41, and Bill Nesbitt, 54, as the two other people killed in the Sept. 6 accident involving the Sikorsky S-61N helicopter. The pilot was identified Tuesday.

Authorities had tentative names but used dental and medical records to confirm the identify the men, all employees of AAR Airlift. The company has a hangar at Orlando Melbourne International Airport. The helicopter was on a "post-maintenance test flight" when the 1974 model aircraft crashed in a remote field in a mostly rural portion of Palm Bay..

The body of Greggory Cluff, 57, a retired Utah National Guard master aviator with more than 6,000 hours of flight experience, was found in the pilot’s seat of the air craft. Dunnam was identified as the co-pilot.

The accident happened as the helicopter hovered about 100 feet off the ground. The three filed a flight plan before leaving Orlando Melbourne International Airport.

The National Transportation Safety Board is investigating the accident.
http://www.gannett-cdn.com/-mm-/f697...ptercrash1.jpg

Steve Stubbs 15th September 2016 22:00

Penzance S61NM seating
 
Actually Insider, at full occupancy it was 32+3 Crew.

And climbing out of the Penzance strip at maximum weight when the WAT Curve allowed was quite something in terms of the decision height at the top of the 20 Knot climb.

I only ever did rejected take-offs from CDP out of there in training, the critical thing was not to dump the collective after touchdown as the ground was way too soft. But the permiiter fence was very close after stopping!

Geoffersincornwall 16th September 2016 07:18

Yes Steve - methinks the guy who approved that profile/WAT had his 'can-do' hat on that day. ;-)

G.

SASless 17th September 2016 04:41

Total fuel on board of what....30 minutes?

AnFI 25th September 2016 12:41

Quote; "The accident happened as the helicopter hovered about 100 feet off the ground"

looks to me like it happenned on the ground

engine failure presumably?

[email protected] 27th September 2016 11:25

Read 212 man's post #11 - for the likely explanation rather than making stuff up:ugh:

AnFI 28th September 2016 17:50

crab i do note the ref to the CG heli fire
but I think I have as much right to speculate about a likely cause
and I would say more likely to be engine fail (and 2nd place inability to hover at height)

given "as the helicopter hovered about 100 feet"
anyhow it is just speculation either way unless there's some other inside gen i am not aware of
someone here probably knows what it was

[email protected] 28th September 2016 18:58

So - engine failure at 100' - lower lever to contain Nr, push 10 - 15 deg nose down to gain speed. If ETL and say VTOSS achieved then fly away - if not flare and overpitch onto the ground - neither sound like a recipe for a fatal crash and all consuming fire.

Engine fire in 100' hover - as above but shutting down burning engine and using fire ext buttons.

That's the big advantage of a twin AnFi, the remaining engine gives you some options.

chopjock 28th September 2016 20:26


That's the big advantage of a twin AnFi, the remaining engine gives you some options.
Is that a good thing? Thinking about those options could waste valuable time and lead you into a false sense of security...

212man 28th September 2016 20:33


Originally Posted by chopjock (Post 9523997)
Is that a good thing? Thinking about those options could waste valuable time and lead you into a false sense of security...

If your brain works that slowly, you're probably in the wrong profession!

Lonewolf_50 28th September 2016 22:15

Here's something for me to look forward too.


When the NTSB issues its report I will be looking it over to see if their assessment includes "one too many engines" or "extra engine carried created task overload for the crew" or words to that effect. :rolleyes: I expect that I won't find any of that, but maybe the NTSB will surprise me.

CertGuy 29th September 2016 13:08

Lonewolf,
Now that was funny.

[email protected] 29th September 2016 16:58

Yes, excellent:ok:

chopjock 29th September 2016 17:13

Lonewolf

When the NTSB issues its report I will be looking it over to see if their assessment includes "one too many engines" or "extra engine carried created task overload for the crew" or words to that effect.
LOL Or perhaps the report might state "this aircraft has twin engine redundancy and should not have crashed, PERIOD"!


All times are GMT. The time now is 14:42.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.