PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   Helicopter Static Charge? (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/309803-helicopter-static-charge.html)

unstable load 28th April 2009 04:25

I have hooked loads onto the S61 on land and ships and in conditions ranging from hot and dry to cold and wet and found the "best way" to handle the shock if a ground pole was not available was to grab the strop as firmly and as hard as you could.
It still bites:eek: but not as bad as tip-toeing around the spark.

Adam Nams 28th April 2009 09:48

Quite agree - suck it in man! Grab it quick - what are you a man or a mouse?

Always a pleasure using the old chain, cable, hook method to ground the aircraft. Even better if you managed to convince the u/t pilot "helping out" that the best way to make sure that he didn't trip over the chain ........ was to put it in his pocket. :E


eeeeeek eeeek eeeeeek

John R81 28th April 2009 11:28

What limits

I think the physics is quite simple. Just like rubbing a balloon on your jumper, really. If it is simple, then........ (if not simple then someone who knows what they are talking about will be along shortly!)

The rotating blades impact molecules (like balloon and jumper) and the impact knocks electrons off the outer orbit of an atom. That molecule becomes + charged and the roter takes on a - charge. The one molecule is left behind, but the rotor hits more molecules and so builds a bigger - charge. The - charge then affects the whole airframe.

When the potential difference between the machine and earth is greater than the resistance of a path between the two, a spark runs up from the ground to the machine along the path of least resistance, earthing the charge on the machine. The longer between earthing, the more molecules to hit (eg rain) etc the bigger the - charge built on the airframe before earthing.

The spark has very high voltage but no amps - it is static electricity. Hence a BIG impact felt if it earths through the loader with little damage. The charge can get big enough, however, to create spark erosion type damage at the point where the charge earths from the airframe. I would guess that damage to electric components is theoretically possible if the charge is big enough but the size of the charge would be getting towards "Lightning" (same process) value.

cockney steve 28th April 2009 14:50

The helicopter effectively forms a Faraday Cage around the electronics.

Same as a F.W. aircraft,= damage is extremely remote.
In-service aircraft are hit by lightning every day, somewhere in the world.

Damage is usually due to broken bonding straps between surfaces.

How come Helo's don't have "wicks" to dissipate the charge?

Winch-control 28th April 2009 15:31

Hmm I have managed to weld the static discharge lead to the deck of the ship that I am landing on, and have been in the un envious position of being unable to grab the rails of a boat... Got it ..nah shock... got it nah shock....got it nah shock.... lots of times! Static discharge leads do work, but I have been defibed more times than I care to think about!

unstable load 29th April 2009 13:13

cockney steve,

Helicopters do have static discharge wicks.

206Fan 23rd November 2013 15:59


We were lifting 40ft Containers in East Timor with the Mi26 and had a few Local guy's trained(As best we could) to do the hook up's. One of the boys forgot to ground the hook and it Blew him off the container and straightened his Curls...Very Funny!!!
I was watching a show on documentaries earlier called "X-Machines". Showed the Mi-26 lifting a container in Alberta and moving it to a building site. The commentator said the 26 can build up 4 Million Volts of Static. Insane!

Hughes500 23rd November 2013 17:06

I find it depends upon weather . have been using a 500d for brash lifting here in Uk. Have moved 10000 bags 4 to 5 at a time, haven't had a belt at all although we haven't been flying in wet weather which normally seems to generate a charge

Thomas coupling 23rd November 2013 17:07

During a winchex in the 80's from a Sea King the winch man we were collecting after the first cct grabbed the harness assembly before it grounded. He collapsed and his heart stopped. He was resuscitated eventually and went on to a fullfilling career. They estimate a charge in excess of 40,000v can be generated in the right circumstances but obviously only with a small amperage.

I haven't heard of any (professional) unit that winches/hoists/sling loads without an earthing strop? :ooh:

Jack Carson 23rd November 2013 18:42

H-53E can be really shocking
 
The static discharge from the C/MH-53E is very significant. The ground crews use a Sheppard’s hook with a grounding wire to ground the aircraft prior to touching the hook during load hook ups. The system also incorporates a grounding wire from the hook up the pendant providing a path into the airframe. There was at least one instance where the ground wire became detached as the pendant stretched during a 32,000 lb lift. In this case the crewman in the aircraft with his hand on the mechanical hook release was knocked on his butt.

SASless 23rd November 2013 19:00

The Chinook in dusty conditions builds a bit of Static.....well actually....enough to replicate Lightning almost.

In the infinite wisdom of the US Army, some innovative folks once put a static discharger on the side of the fuselage which was supposed to safely discharge static buildups.

There was a Pilot operated set of switches for operating the system and the default position on the ground was of course the "Off" position.

As Sod's Law prevails in the US Army (oh but doesn't it!).... along trods a young Soldier heading to his Bunker on the Flight Line to pull his Night Sentry Duty and like a Bolt from the Blue.....a huge arc of fire and brimstone flashed from the parked Chinook...to his Steel Helmet and then to ol' Mother Earth.

Wiser heads prevailed and the Static Discharging Systems were all removed from the Fleet.

A Golden Rule while hooking up sling loads.....always touch the lifting tackle to the Hook.....never hold the lifting tackle in one hand and touch the cargo hook with the other hand.....as it will sometimes be a thrill.

206Fan 23rd November 2013 19:30

Video showing the discharge from a bucket. Bell 212?


TRC 23rd November 2013 21:48

Jared, you have PM.

Savoia 24th November 2013 08:21

In Papua New Guinea, late 80's, we had a ground-handler who had been working loads for about a week before he encountered the 'hook of shock'!

He was pretty efficient at hooking-up loads and would waste no time in reaching-out for the hook in order to slide the D-bolt 'shackle' (attached to the load ropes) through the hook's keeper.

As was the norm for the PNG highlands, rain showers abounded, and with less manoeuverability than would be so without a load, one sometimes couldn't avoid penetrating the edges of the lighter showers.

Returning from such a trip I sailed in to uplift a new load when upon arrival I saw the loadsman jump back after grabbing the hook followed by a sharp glance skywards where, even from 100ft, it was clear to see that he was not pleased.

Pressing on, the load was hooked-up and, 20 or so minutes later I was back for more when to my surprise the loadsman had armed himself with a stick and was now stabbing at the hook in a display which reminded me of the staircase sword-fighting scene between Errol Flynn and Basil Rathbone from 'The Adventures of Robin Hood' (1938).

It have to say that I had a wee chuckle at his expense but, thereafter landed and explained to him that the present weather was building-up a charge on the aircraft (not that I think he understood this) and that he should allow me to 'ground' the hook before he grabbed it.

On his day off he turned-up at the exploration camp in his full tribal regalia and of which visit I have a photo somewhere!

oldgrubber 24th November 2013 08:30

I remember preparing for a RAS evolution from "Lusty" to some support vessels many years ago when I was the deck Supervisor for a MK6 sqdn. I duly briefed the lads on their duties and we got started. It was only when the lad was about to hook the sacru hook with his earthing pole that I noticed he had the earthing plate in his jacket pocket! Luckily I got to him before the helicopter.
Not strictly on topic but another incident back at Culdrose many years ago consisted of spotting an earthing cable from a static fuel dispenser on 706 sqdn line (being used) knotted together. The lad fuelling the aircraft said the tractor had driven over it and had snapped it so he "fixed" it to complete the refuel!!

Jack, you gotta love him.

Cheers

megan 14th December 2023 02:39

Sling Loads
 
Has anyone had experience with static electrical build up on the airframe that presented an issue with the hook up individual, or use grounding prior to hook up?

Just been reading on the subject and see turbine aircraft build up there own static charge, CAP 426,

The results when the exhaust gases contain a preponderance of ions of a particular polarity, leaving the aircraft charged with the opposite polarity. The magnitude of the effect varies widely between different types of helicopter; it is negligible in some but in others can cause voltages of 30 – 50kV to be reached within 1˝ - 2 minutes. The process usually imparts a positive charge to the helicopter and is largely independent of weather conditions so that it leads to a persistent static problem which exists even under conditions where all other static charging mechanisms are absent.
Never heard of that before, learn some thing new every day. Never engaged in earthing the aircraft prior to hook up myself, nor ever had the hook up chap say he got a jolt.

MechEngr 14th December 2023 03:07

Interesting about the engines.

Dust over blades and wings can also generate a huge static charge.

Essentially one needs to match the voltage between two items that are otherwise insulated either by air or the tires. The same voltage matching is seen in high-tension crews working from helicopters or bucket trucks.

I have heard of crews letting the new guy go and grab a sling and get knocked on his butt by the electrical discharge to teach them about the importance of voltage matching before touching.

Fark'n'ell 14th December 2023 04:57

sling loads
 
Has anyone had experience with static electrical build up on the airframe that presented an issue with the hook up individual, or use grounding prior to hook up

Quite a lot.Used to work in an industry where a lot of work was 4000-5000 feet or sometimes higher.Over snow it was not uncomman to get a belt or two. High altitude
cold air and a lack of water vapour in the air prevented the helicopter from naturally discharging

Cornish Jack 14th December 2023 10:05

Surprisingly, only just come across this thread. One of our tasks at Thorney was to do trials with the Littlehampton lifeboat to allow a team from Farnborough to take measurements of helo static discharges. Chatting with the team afterwards and they mentioned figures in the range of 160,000 -180,000 volts (low current, of course !) Water/deck/land contact, when winching, was made less painful by keeping hands off the cable. On one notable occasion, I forgot to do so at the end of a particularly strenuous wet winching session in Holyhead harbour. I was winched onto the Marine Unit's pinnace and touched down with hand on the wire and mouth open, breathing hard. I have a 'collection' of amalgam molars, upper and lower and the inevitable static discharged across them - the taste, and smell, remained for several hours !

Hughes500 14th December 2023 11:08

Interestingly we use a Hu 369D for Moorland restoration. Over past 11 years we have moved 75000 dumpy bags anything from single to 6's so one can imagine the number of lift cycles, Had no more than a handful of static belts ! Seems to happen when there is moisture in the air in particular snow. Just come back from 10 days and over 1100 cycles, ground crew who catch the hook didnt have any belts

RVDT 14th December 2023 18:22

You need the right conditions - and a cause for the "potential" excess of electrons one way or the other. Dry powder snow is frictional or a thunderstorm within ~ 20 miles will help. Doing seismic we would sit and wait it out if a thunderstorm nearby for a couple of reasons, giving the ground crew belts, which you sometimes would see the spark and hear it on the radio, plus lighting up the recording electronics and jugs or electric dets and bombs was a potential issue. Also surprising how fast it builds up after discharge, literally seconds after grounding it's good to go again. Badge of honour for juggy's as to how hard they were! Funny looking down the longline to see people sit down so quickly!

SASless 14th December 2023 22:36

To add to my post that was resurrected......the linked file describes the device the US Army spent loads of money in developing, testing, fielding, and very quickly discarding....that I described earlier.

Memory serves me it stuck out on the port side of the helicopter and looked like a wee short wing shaped device....on our aircraft it had ribs rather than the two prongs and something that at first glance could have been. mistaken for a position light at the tip.

We could never see any useful effect from it and in not much time it was deactivated and ultimately removed.

There were reported events of injury and at least one death from inadvertent discharge from parked aircraft which lead to the device being removed.

Dry, dusty conditions and prolonged hovering in a Chinook does cause a large build up of static electricity that can make the shortest military haircut stand upright.

https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/tr/pdf/AD0664201.pdf


Some interesting photos in this article.....with an interesting textual account of why the helicopters were operating there.

There photographer notes how the static display around the blades change with the amount of pitch applied to the blades and the ramp touching the ground.

There should be static wicks that hang down between the tires of the landing gear unless there has been a mod since I flew them.

Hats off to t he Crews and to the Troops they were supporting!

https://realitypod.com/story/helicop...corona-effect/







roscoe1 17th December 2023 03:31

Many moons ago I worked for a company that did lift work in the San Francisco Bay area with a couple of S58Ts. I got to climb up the suspension cable on the Oakland Bay bridge to lift some steel and painting supplies to the top of one of the towers, about 600 feet off the water. It was awesome fun. At the finish of the job I was not looking forward to the walk down, looking at the water and bridge deck the whole way, so the pilot asked if I wanted to be picked up on top of the tower. I happily said yes. There was a platform just big enough to set a wheel down and give me 6 or 8 feet to approach the ship and hop into the cargo door. No guard rail anywhere at all the very top. You guessed it, I grabbed the door handle and was knocked to my knees by the visible mini bolt of lightning, I hit the step outside the door, . I even knew better, it wasn't my first rodeo. Without a ground strap my normal modus was to slap the hook hard enough to hurt so I didn't notice the shock so much. Young and dumb.

NutLoose 17th December 2023 14:00


Originally Posted by unstable load (Post 4894125)
cockney steve,

Helicopters do have static discharge wicks.

RAF Pumas used to have little short ones on the blades, prior to that the had longer items, one of which snaped off during a Rotors turning refuel and iirc burying itself in a Rocks head, hence the change, the Rock survived.

ShyTorque 17th December 2023 15:08

Yes, I remember that, I was on that squadron at the time. The static wicks on the blades were part of the tip cap and were deleted when composite blades replaced the old metal type.

Rho Tarbled 18th December 2023 09:31

Could someone explain the Rock and its head?

NutLoose 18th December 2023 10:08

Thr RAF regiment are referred to as Rock Apes and at Odiham used to do site defence etc in the field, but during the rest of the time they would drive the aircraft refuellers, IIRC the longer static wicks that used to fail and nobody had problems with before this one, detached and hit him in the head, I seem to remember it penetrated his skull and he was flown to hospital ( by the aircraft he refuelled? )

brett s 18th December 2023 11:15

As Chinook crew you learned pretty quickly how to hook a load up without getting zapped - you also learned how to make sure someone you didn't like got nailed :)


All times are GMT. The time now is 16:00.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.