PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   Broward County accident... (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/654469-broward-county-accident.html)

Aser 29th Aug 2023 06:56

That looks to me like the battery compartment... :ooh:

skadi 29th Aug 2023 07:29


Originally Posted by Sir Korsky (Post 11493241)
Pretty sure that 135 had no fire bottles installed. I've flown 4 or 5 airframes and all of them had no bottles. Never liked the 135 because of this.


Originally Posted by Scattercat (Post 11493247)
The 135 has a Fire Extinguisher system available as a supplemental kit option (FMS 9.2-9) ... the basic configuration has a Fire Warning system only.

I had flown many 135 from 1997 on, all of them had the bottles installed. Never saw one without. As for the supplements, the SAS is also in there and I've never seen one without

skadi

Sir Korsky 29th Aug 2023 08:18

Welcome to the USA, where those pesky heavy fire bottles can be seen as a weight shave. I'd be surprised if any HAA 135's in the US had them installed.

SilsoeSid 29th Aug 2023 08:40

Discussion of whether fire extinguisher bottle(s) were fitted/used is a moot point considering the location of the fire.

212man 29th Aug 2023 08:59


Originally Posted by SilsoeSid (Post 11493350)
Discussion of whether fire extinguisher bottle(s) were fitted/used is a moot point considering the location of the fire.

and that the crew seemed unaware they were on fire (ATC recording)

RVDT 29th Aug 2023 09:01

Pretty sure FMS 9-2-9 Engine Fire Extinguisher (available in 1 shot or 2) is required if you are going to use the Cat A supplement.


SLFMS 29th Aug 2023 10:28

Isn’t the 135 IFR capable? I would have thought that would require fire suppression, or is that the point of the option?
It’s crazy it’s a choice.

SilsoeSid 29th Aug 2023 10:32

Watching the ABC News vid, the initial shot viewing the port side with ac moving right to left, the ‘source’ may be more inboard, under the ‘connecting flange’.

I wonder if the ac had recently been washed.

[email protected] 29th Aug 2023 10:38

If it is an uncontained fuel driven fire, that will be like a blowtorch so no wonder the TRDS and tailboom gave way.

SilsoeSid 29th Aug 2023 10:51


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 11493429)
If it is an uncontained fuel driven fire, that will be like a blowtorch so no wonder the TRDS and tailboom gave way.

Talking of possible blowtorches, the hydraulic line connectors are directly above the connecting flange, with fluid at a far greater pressure than fuel.
(Hyd@103 bar / Fuel press caution @ 0.6 bar P/W, 1.3 bar Arr2B1)

Effect rather than cause of fire?

NutLoose 29th Aug 2023 10:56

This looks like part of the fire was in the boom where it failed?.


hoistop 29th Aug 2023 11:35


Originally Posted by skadi (Post 11493117)
There is another video which shows the starboard side and there is also visible fire at or behind the engine bay. There is a titanium firewall between and aft of both engines. I don't think that <2min of flighttime is enough to break these walls with fire.

skadi

It is not the firewalls, the problem is that structure, attaching tailboom and/or tailboom itself failed. Tailboom is completelly made of composite, while attachment flange and fuselage is metal structure - Aluminum and titanium apron and firewalls. I worked many years on EC-135 and am astonished how fast the fire destroyed the primary structure. Like Concorde in Paris.

hoistop 29th Aug 2023 11:40

there was no tailboom baggage compartment on this helicopter-or any separate "baggage compartment" at all, as it is an EC-135 type.

[email protected] 29th Aug 2023 11:45


Effect rather than cause of fire?
If, as someone suggested above, the initial failure was a turbine burst with blades being shed - that would make a lot of sense Sid.:ok:​​​​​​​

212man 29th Aug 2023 12:27


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 11493497)
If, as someone suggested above, the initial failure was a turbine burst with blades being shed - that would make a lot of sense Sid.:ok:

Well, the crew did report an engine failure, so it seems more like the fire was a consequence.

SilsoeSid 29th Aug 2023 12:54


Originally Posted by 212man (Post 11493526)
Well, the crew did report an engine failure, so it seems more like the fire was a consequence.

The op link says:

According to officials, on Monday, the chopper had just taken off from the Pompano Air Park at 8:42 a.m. and was heading to a call in North Lauderdale regarding a car crash where a vehicle hit a bus stop at Prospect Road and State Road 7. Three minutes later, the BSFR helicopter had an engine failure that occurred shortly after takeoff.”

However, it also says… “It is unclear how they managed to maneuver onto the roof.”


:confused:

SLFMS 29th Aug 2023 13:02

This was my initial thoughts too, engine failure cause the fire. Seems most likely given engine failure was reported assuming that was correct

[email protected] 29th Aug 2023 13:05

If an engine does go bang as opposed to just turning itself off, who knows what collateral damage there could be and to which systems.

wrench1 29th Aug 2023 14:40


Originally Posted by hoistop (Post 11493485)
I worked many years on EC-135 and am astonished how fast the fire destroyed the primary structure.

Agree. But for a "fuel" fire he's trailing a lot of smoke for a long time if the valve was closed. Oil/Hyd fire something different. Maybe an oil leak ingested by engine causing performance issues then a fire at the end? Have even seen oil leaks on the xsmn deck dump excessive oil down the intake tunnel.

212man 29th Aug 2023 15:06


Originally Posted by SLFMS (Post 11493552)
This was my initial thoughts too, engine failure cause the fire. Seems most likely given engine failure was reported assuming that was correct

I've heard the ATC tape, but can't find a link. It was on LI.......

They say they had an engine failure and are requesting a priority landing using a runway. ATC (Pompano Tower) clears them to land RWY06 (or, RWY Six, as they say over there.....)


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:21.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.