PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   R44 200ftAGL engine out Autorotation video (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/639033-r44-200ftagl-engine-out-autorotation-video.html)

EMS R22 6th Mar 2021 02:13

Great work they all walked away!!

They are still building helicopters!!

Stuart Sutcliffe 6th Mar 2021 08:57


Originally Posted by gulliBell (Post 11002407)
No link. Personal communication with the owner.

A few basic details here:

https://aviation-safety.net/wikibase/248409

Interesting that the nature of the flight is noted as Private, rather than Commercial?

Inputting the registration into the NTSB accident database returns zero results.

Bravo73 6th Mar 2021 09:20


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 11002508)
Plenty of us are used to gun culture - it is ingrained from day 1 in the military and shooting all manner of weapons from helicopters is best left to professionals.

https://s2helicopterservices.com/videos

rb14 6th Mar 2021 09:46


Originally Posted by DOUBLE BOGEY (Post 11001798)
I do not know anything about Robbies but...….if that poxy 50p key in the wrong position can result in such a cluster why is there not a dirty big red light or even a beepy noise telling you that the MAGS are not properly switched ON before you slip the surly bonds of earth?

Absolutely this. So much of aviation is regulated to the ends of eternity, but simple stuff like you suggest, not a chance.

On ebay recently I saw a Cessna key blank being offered for £20. Twenty quid. Anything aviation, start off multiplying by a factor of ten, then doubling it.

Me: "Why?"
Instructor: "Apparently it's for all the safety testing, reliability and certification."
"OK, so if I try to fly the plane with a key turned maybe 15 degrees from the correct position, will I get a warning?"
"No."
"Really?"
"No."
"Even though it could cause me serious problems?"
"No."
"Hmmm. Well at least I can rely on the important stuff, like the fuel gauges?"
"Yeah, funny you should mention them...."

[email protected] 6th Mar 2021 11:58

Bravo73 - not much professional activity going on there I think.

Robbiee 6th Mar 2021 14:59


Originally Posted by DOUBLE BOGEY (Post 11001798)
I do not know anything about Robbies but...….if that poxy 50p key in the wrong position can result in such a cluster why is there not a dirty big red light or even a beepy noise telling you that the MAGS are not properly switched ON before you slip the surly bonds of earth?
To err is human. To design something that f***ks you up when you err without telling you beforehand is criminal! Does a 44 have a caution/warning panel OR is that the thing I cannot see hiding under the IPAD?

However, the little wild piggy's got to live another day so there was a positive!

Well, if you are the type who needs the government to hold his hand through life, Robinson did develop a "full throttle" light for inattentive pilots, so perhaps they'll give you your "ignition key off" light one day, if this keeps happening?

172510 6th Mar 2021 17:46

Has this accident been investigated? Is the official report available? I couldn't read the registration number of the aircraft. With the registration number I could locate the report

NWstu 6th Mar 2021 18:21

2 Attachment(s)

Originally Posted by Stuart Sutcliffe (Post 11003039)
A few basic details here:

https://aviation-safety.net/wikibase/248409

Interesting that the nature of the flight is noted as Private, rather than Commercial?

Inputting the registration into the NTSB accident database returns zero results.

Here's the preliminary. Nothing revealing yet. Use this website for any aviation occurrences 1/1/2008 and later

Satoshi Nakamoto 6th Mar 2021 18:45

The video posted by Findon 40 taken by the rear seat passenger appears to show the front passenger was not wearing his seat belt. In which case he was extremely lucky to walk away.

wrench1 6th Mar 2021 19:03


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 11002622)
It also seems that there are firms out there doing far more scientific hog culling using traps and enclosures - yes they still shoot them in the end but they avoid dispersing the hogs the way that dog and helicopter hunting does which both create more damage not less.

FYI:
From the scientific side, it is impossible to mechanically eradicate all feral hogs as they are too prolific and smart. In Texas for example, in order to keep their 2 million hog population in check, it would require the harvest of 1.25 million hogs per year. They barely achieve 400,000 each year and this is with a 365 day, 24/7, legal hunting season. Traps tend to work one time then must lay dormant for months or moved as other hogs will not enter the trap after the 1st use.

Considering hogs cause over a $1 Billion in damage in the US alone, a niche industry has sprung up with aerial hunts as shown in the video. There are quite a few ops out there. There are also professional aerial hog hunters who specialize in night flights from either a small fixed wing or helicopter using thermal imaging sights. Given a farmer can incur up to a $70,000+ loss in one night, the issue is very serious in the agricultural belts around the country.

The latest move over the past several years has been toward developing a poison that will kill just the hog and leave a biological marker that it was poisoned in case the animal is harvested for sport. Regardless, even with a lethal poison it will still be a chore to reduce the feral hog populations in my experience. Just be thankful they haven’t figured out how to swim the big pond… yet.

topradio 6th Mar 2021 19:13

Sorry, I don't believe the gun/key story. What's the chance of the gun switching the key to off in the first place, pretty small I would say. In all the 22 & 44's I've flown the switch takes a definite twist and just knocking the key is highly unlikely to move it 3 positions! And then to cap it all the switch also has to be faulty!

I don't buy it, has all the hallmarks of a tale cooked-up after the event to spare the blushes of the pilot.

Edit to say, and keep the insurance company happy.

DDG-37 6th Mar 2021 21:23

Much more than "pilot blushes"...The tail rotor and aft end of the boom is gone!!

megan 7th Mar 2021 01:46

Shooting seems to be a major part of their operation.

Services - Cattle Herding, Hunting, Patriot Range, Aerial Survey, Pipeline Inspection, Power Line Inspection, Hunting Price
https://s2helicopterservices.com/

PR0PWASH 7th Mar 2021 07:08

Look at the start of the video, the key was in the of position before they even got off the ground
Unless the barrel of the switch was rotated in the panel then my money is on malfunctioning P Leads and a poor pre-flight.

[email protected] 7th Mar 2021 09:39

Wrench1 - seems it was a very self-inflicted problem https://www.germaniainsurance.com/bl...ld-pig-problem

You start by introducing them for sport and then suddenly you have millions of them.

Another interesting comment here https://www.si.com/sports-illustrate...as-helicopters - seems like the answer is going to need more than a few tourists with AR 15s

Couldn't the governor take them on holiday with him?:)

aa777888 7th Mar 2021 11:13

Don't forget this is likely to become a problem in the UK, too. ShootingUK estimates the population is now up to 2600 and climbing rapidly. See also the link I posted earlier in this thread. Now is the time for you folks to completely eradicate them, before it's too late.

Hot and Hi 7th Mar 2021 11:41


Originally Posted by PR0PWASH (Post 11003606)
Look at the start of the video, the key was in the of position before they even got off the ground
Unless the barrel of the switch was rotated in the panel then my money is on malfunctioning P Leads and a poor pre-flight.

It appears so. As much as on shutdown (cool-down period, then clutch OFF) we check at this moment that the mechanical (engine-driven) fuel pump on its own works well (as clutch OFF disengages the electric fuel pump), one could also check the magneto key switch OFF function.

30 sec after clutch OFF you would then normally kill the engine by pulling the mixture. You might just decide to once in a while kill the engine by turning the magneto key switch to OFF. It's not in the POM, and others here can advise if there are any reasons for not doing this way...

With correct wiring you would get:

- Immediate engine stop when turning the key to OFF
- Noticeable, positive engine roughness and RPM drop between 3 and 5 % (but less than 7% within 2 sec) by running in either one magneto
- Positive rpm and smoothness recovery when switch from one magneto back to two magnetos

If you religiously follow a pre-takeoff *checklist* even if the engine was just off for a few minutes, I agree very little chances that you take-off with the key in the wrong position AND the wiring to be totally wrong AND the wiring miraculously coming right (ie engine stop) after 20 sec.

--

No passenger can change a switch position in the cockpit, with the engine running and the pilot at the controls, without the pilot noticing. Full stop. Let alone accidentally.

OK, last time that happened was in NYC with the Squirrel where the passenger's camera strap or similar caught the fuel shutoff lever and then pulled up that lever thereby shutting off fuel flow. But let's just say that here the idea that the front pax with his rifle knocked a rotary switch from the 5 o'clock to the 1 o'clock position only suits one person, the pilot.

--

Great auto?

While we are all happy that all pax walked away from this accident unhurt, and while I wouldn't boast that I would have done much better, adding to the above this was a fairly botched autorotation (loss of speed, loss RRPM). The pilot treated the engine out like if it was at cruise speed (with the stick in forward position before the engine stops), not adjusting his technique for the fact that he was still in the climb (with the stick in an AFT position).

The good thing that can be said is that he didn't stop flying the aircraft until the impact and until the aircraft come to a complete stop, avoiding obstacles left right and centre. And doing a great run-on landing on rough terrain without toppling over. That was *not* luck.

[email protected] 7th Mar 2021 12:44


Don't forget this is likely to become a problem in the UK, too. ShootingUK estimates the population is now up to 2600 and climbing rapidly. See also the link I posted earlier in this thread. Now is the time for you folks to completely eradicate them, before it's too late.
I'll just nip down to Walmart and get me an AR 15 and a bucket of bullets then :)

But that 2600 is spread across the whole of the UK with the majority being in one place - the Forest of Dean. You didn't mention that Shooting UK also advocates a closed season on lactating sows, something that I suspect wouldn't be acceptable in Texas.

wrench1 7th Mar 2021 13:38


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 11003698)
Wrench1 - seems it was a very self-inflicted problem ... You start by introducing them for sport and then suddenly you have millions of them.

True to a point. The other half is the loss of habitat which is compounding the existing problem. I've been dealing with this issue for over 30 years as a land lessee/owner and supported various aerial ops but not the pay-for-hunt type in the video. Most state hog populations were managed effectively up until the 80s and 90s when the sport hunting side took off. Free enterprise at its best and worst. Just like the python issues in the Florida Everglades, the nutria in the marshes of the GOM, and the Kudzu plants of the southeastern US. They all started as good ideas but people were clueless on the ramifications when they released these animals/plants into prime survival areas. With luck, if the current chemical treatments continue to work, along with all the other measures being used, to include the aerial cowboys in the OP, they may get the populations back into control, but never 100% eradicated. At least thats how things are moving around my end of the spectrum. Now back to our regular programing......

aa777888 7th Mar 2021 13:53


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 11003818)
I'll just nip down to Walmart and get me an AR 15 and a bucket of bullets then :)

Ha ha! I'll believe that when I see it, even if you could! Mr-not-a-gun-guy ;)


But that 2600 is spread across the whole of the UK with the majority being in one place - the Forest of Dean. You didn't mention that Shooting UK also advocates a closed season on lactating sows, something that I suspect wouldn't be acceptable in Texas.
Very true. Shades of the same economic and philosophical motivations that exist in parts of the Texas eradication--er--hunting industry, I suspect. You know, more pigs means more hunting, guns, guides and tours that will be necessary. It's a fine line between conservation, wild game and pest. But I'm a naturally suspicious type. Hope it doesn't get out of hand!


All times are GMT. The time now is 20:36.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.