PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   Apache cuts powerline in Germany (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/625857-apache-cuts-powerline-germany.html)

Rotorbee 27th Sep 2019 04:59

Apache cuts powerline in Germany
 
Near Windelsbach in Germany a Apache ran in a powerline. It landed with quite a bit of damage nearby. Apparently its a training area for the US-Army and they quite often fly under the power line. This time it was too close.
Abendzeitung

https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....b5ca62eca1.jpg

atakacs 27th Sep 2019 05:22

Very lucky to have survived it

Nubian 27th Sep 2019 11:36

Similar? Ah, you have no faith....see how big that is!

JimEli 27th Sep 2019 19:59


Originally Posted by Rotorbee (Post 10580512)
...and they quite often fly under the power line.

Really. What's your source for that comment?

fijdor 27th Sep 2019 23:47


Originally Posted by Mitchaa (Post 10581126)
Apaches have razor sharp wire cutters above and below the main fuselage. If hitting them directly it should just shear through.

One, maybe two wires and it depends of the speed and angle at time of impact. Looks like 4 wires on that structure and they don't look like telephone wire sizes.

JD

evil7 28th Sep 2019 07:53

The German report says it was six wires they cut and as you see it was a power line.
By the way - it also says there was no power cut to anybody / any facility as other systems jumped right in!

After reading the report again it seems the helicopter "only" hit the top line and that let the mast collapse which then ripped the six power lines.

Rotorbee 28th Sep 2019 08:52

Well, the article says, it hit a heavy steel cable. On the picture you see that the top cable is still under tension and therefore probably not broken. Anyway, top cables today - well here where I life - are data and ground cables and not that heavy. I don't think it is strong enough to pull a mast down. On the other hand, the six high voltage cables - mostly aluminium with a steel core - are all at the same level. How could he have cut all of them in a row and still be able to land the ship? The damage on the ship isn't extensive.

Vzlet 1st Oct 2019 12:07

Flying Under Power Lines
 
FWIW, returning from a patrol mission along the West German/Czechoslovakian border with the U.S. Army in the late 1980s, we took some time for the accompanying AH-1 to do a series of under-the-wires crossings. My impression was that it was box checking for a proficiency requirement. No lines visible in this picture, but it was during that activity, IIRC.

https://live.staticflickr.com/1924/4...0543d6d0_c.jpg
Bell AH-1F Cobra by Mark Carlisle, on Flickr

ShyTorque 1st Oct 2019 13:54

In the 1980s it was classed as a routine exercise. RAF crews were required to practice under-wires crossings at least once a month. It wasn't done at cruise speed though!


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:13.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.