PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   EC135 HEMS accident in Norway (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/531876-ec135-hems-accident-norway.html)

Nubian 14th Jan 2014 16:05

From the last 2 pictures, streetlights looks to be installed between the first and 2nd picture was taken. They seem to ''stand out'' more, and I will not be surprised if not the pilot's main focus was to clear that, preparing for a low-vis snowy landing causing him to miss the higher span. The poles for that span looks also like they are almost hidden against the trees.

Very sad regardless of reason.

Condolences to the families, colleagues and all involved.

GenuineHoverBug 14th Jan 2014 17:18

Here is a video from a different angle.

Does the rotorhead not appear to "wobble" on the way down?

M609 14th Jan 2014 18:12

Video of the AIBN lifting the a/c onto transport: dagbladet.no

MightyGem 14th Jan 2014 22:46


Does the rotorhead not appear to "wobble" on the way down?
Yes, probably due to damage because of the blades hitting the wires.

nomorehelosforme 14th Jan 2014 22:49

M609
 
No disrespect to you,but, having lost close friends in crashes, I find that a very harrowing video and won't be watching it again.

Again thoughts with all friends, families and colleagues

CJ Romeo 15th Jan 2014 10:28

That's pretty bad.


As an outsider, it would seem logical to me that those calling in air support from the ground should try (note try) and establish a safe landing area and advise back via the controller of obstacles/ hazards like this?


Does this happen in the UK?

jayteeto 15th Jan 2014 10:45

The helicopter is often first on scene in rural areas

outofoffice 15th Jan 2014 11:59

Latest information indicates that the air ambulance service has six channels for radio communication and one mobile phone onboard. Police have also stated that they tried to warn the incoming helicopter about the wires, but no response was given from the helicopter.

Further, it has been informed that preliminary checks have confirmed the most current version of map system used onboard these helicopters have the power lines in question indicated. However, it still remains to be confirmed if this also was the case for the map version loaded onto the downed helicopter.

CJ Romeo 15th Jan 2014 13:01

Pretty sad all around that people died on their way to help others.

maf 15th Jan 2014 15:46

The pilot was a highly skilled veteran with just over 20 years of flying for the NLA. Before that he was an airforce pilot in the 771 squadron.

It just goes to show just how dangerous wires are, when they even knock out such a skilled and experienced pilot.

My thoughts and condolances goes to the families of the two deceased men.

I hope the paramedic turns out just fine.

almoehi 15th Jan 2014 18:24

try to warn
 
You are pretty lucky, when you recieve information about obstacles from the landing site. Most of the time there are police and rescueteams, who not even think about an information for the helicoptercrew:ugh:.

By the way, It´s always a miracle, when we loose a "highly skilled veteran". I have to remember, that you won´t find a greenhorn on an HEMS mission.

Normally, you will see the black cables in front of the white background. Except, you´ll do a very steep approach and you fix a reference point in the front of you to avoid a "white out". In this case, the wires are exactly under the helicopter and for all crew members "invisible".

Very sad...

BluSdUp 15th Jan 2014 23:48

One man ops. Why!
 
Time for a change.
When I first saw this tragic news I recall all my fellow pilots that are no more due to money.
Is it not time for two pilots in HEMS ?
I hear them overhead here on the westcoast on the most hidious of snowy nights, low level.
And I think :that is what I wanted to do , before someone gave me a first-officer and a twin, to warn me off,,,. Off,,,anything,,.!
While he gets experiance,,,!
Take as many details as You want, heli-ops will never get safer untill you get a First officer. Get the Government contractor to pay, or We shall pay.
I am tired of funeralls.
Yours Sincerely
Capt B

jimf671 16th Jan 2014 13:18


Originally Posted by outofoffice (Post 8265349)
Latest information indicates that the air ambulance service has six channels for radio communication and one mobile phone onboard. Police have also stated that they tried to warn the incoming helicopter about the wires, but no response was given from the helicopter.
... ...

Some problems exist in the UK with on-scene comms. A/C would normally be expected to talk to each other on 123.1 but air-ground comms are a bit of a mess. Our emergency services are heavily "infected" with Airwave which is the equivalent of Nodnett. At rural locations where a major incident occurs, trunked systems have been known to overload and fail. Additionally, mountainous terrain seriously affects coverage. Police, road ambulance and volunteer agencies are never likely to get 123.1 and only SAR a/c use Land SAR frequencies. Even if you have experienced heli-ops personnel on the ground at the scene, waving our arms can be the best comms available.


Huge respect for these guys. En trist dag.

Has the injured paramedic been named?

GenuineHoverBug 16th Jan 2014 13:19

Preliminary information from the AIB-Norway
 
A brief preliminary report was just published.
It is i Norwegian, but with two pictures. One of them showing that one of the wires got wound around the mast and severed the pitch-links.

M609 16th Jan 2014 14:40


Has the injured paramedic been named?

Sondre Bjartland

www.vg.no
http://static.vg.no/uploaded/image/2...ed_ramme_1.jpg

Pitch links.....

http://gfx.dagbladet.no/labrador/313...ctive/978x.jpg

SASless 16th Jan 2014 15:08

Was the aircraft equipped with a Wire Strike Safety System (Wire Cutter)?

Looking at the Video's.....it would question if it would have helped due to the very slow speed the aircraft was moving while doing the slow cautious approach the Pilot seemed to be making.

skadi 16th Jan 2014 15:12

It was equipped with a WSPS, it could be seen on the video of the salvage, the upper part was red.

Photo: LN-OON (CN: 1033) Norsk Luftambulanse Eurocopter EC 135P2+ by Stig Rokkones - JetPhotos.Net

skadi

SASless 16th Jan 2014 15:42

That makes this all the more tragic.

The wire(s) were quite small....and should not have been that hard to cut....but very hard to see.

MightyGem 16th Jan 2014 16:28

I saw a Bell 206 with WSPS hit a wire and it ended up with severed pitch change rods as well. They reckoned that the wire went through a 1 inch gap between the top of the cutter and the rotor disc.

maf 16th Jan 2014 16:35

Speaking of single pilot ops..

The irony in this is that once you got big enough ships, you are required to have dual crew, even if the operations are not nearly as hazardous as EMS flying can be, escpesially in mountainious countries.

If there are any operations that should have two pilots, its such one as this. Clearly, it works well most of the time (2004 was the last accident they had, wihtout fatalities, 1996 with fatalities).

But the question they should ask them self is:

Is it really worth the money saved on single pilot ops when we
have loss of lives that could have been avoided?


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:47.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.