PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   Yet another AW139 tail incident at Gulf helis (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/450392-yet-another-aw139-tail-incident-gulf-helis.html)

Bespoke 3rd May 2011 03:07

detachment
 
Apparently one TR Blade detached and flew across the apron and came to a stop 50m later in front of the main departure terminal. Good fortune not to hit anything or anyone, although I'm told may have clipped a couple of main rotor blades.

Also believed to be just out of maintenance.

Additionally Im told P2 shut it down as it came apart.:D

Now that the one picture is now available, come on guys give us more. Apparently every man and his dog were snapping away !

Spoke.

Swinging Spanner 3rd May 2011 03:31

I believe that not "all" AW139's in country are grounded. I think you will find it has to do with local aviation authority policy and company procedure to ground the affected company's remaining fleet of AW139's only, until such time both the manufacturer and aviation authority deem to be safe to resume operations. ;)

aegir 3rd May 2011 08:36

This Incident is similar to the Hong Kong one, or it seems...

helihub 3rd May 2011 09:42


The AB139 is a major leap forward in safety and has yet to be involved in a fatal accident (at least with a pilot at the controls)
ShellManagement. Can you tell us how a pilot was not "at the controls" on these fatal accidents

helihub 3rd May 2011 09:52

Just found another photo of the Hong Kong one

http://www.helihub.com/wordpress/wp-...00703-bmhj.jpg

eivissa 3rd May 2011 11:00

@helihub: although I dont think it was appropriate, SM probably meant that in the Almeria accident one is led to believe both pilots lost situational awareness, then made wrong corrections on the flight controls and let it fly its-self into the water.

http://www.fomento.es/NR/rdonlyres/7..._statement.pdf

thehighlander959 3rd May 2011 11:59

I am in Qatar at present offshore. There have been no AW139 Operation in our field out here today.Not sure about anywhere else.
Flights in our field are being done by the Bell 214 which are the in-field helicopters running back and forward to Doha.

blakmax 3rd May 2011 12:30

What is the structure?
 
Hard to tell from the photos, but what is the structure like? Is there any composite/adhesive bonded structure as in the tail boom?

Regards

blakmax

aegir 3rd May 2011 13:02

eivissa
 
and what about the korean AW139? no pilot at the controls?
these are the accident/incident involving AW139 helicopters (thank to Aviation Safety Network)

22-APR-2002 I-ACOI / 01 Bell/Agusta Aerospace fat. 2 near Monteleone, Cesena
21-JAN-2010 EC-KYR Salvamento Marítimo (Helisureste) fat. 3 Mediterranean Sea, off Almeria
03-JUL-2010 B-MHJ Sky Shuttle Helicopters, opf. East Asia Airlines fat.0 Victoria Harbour
23-FEB-2011 South Korean Coast Guard fat. 5 West of the resort island of Jeju

It's missing theaccident of June in Abu Dhabi involving Sheikh Nasser Bin Zayed Al Nahyan. all the passengers died.

In addition we have the 2 accident to Gulf helicopter, the one of 2009 and the seconf of yesterday.

So we have some fatal accident with pilot at the controls and the AW139 isn't safe as SM says.
But no helicopter are totally safer, for sure!

IntheTin 3rd May 2011 13:17


22-APR-2002 I-ACOI / 01 Bell/Agusta Aerospace fat. 2 near Monteleone, Cesena
21-JAN-2010 EC-KYR Salvamento Marítimo (Helisureste) fat. 3 Mediterranean Sea, off Almeria
03-JUL-2010 B-MHJ Sky Shuttle Helicopters, opf. East Asia Airlines fat.0 Victoria Harbour
23-FEB-2011 South Korean Coast Guard fat. 5 West of the resort island of Jeju

It's missing theaccident of June in Abu Dhabi involving Sheikh Nasser Bin Zayed Al Nahyan. all the passengers died.

In addition we have the 2 accident to Gulf helicopter, the one of 2009 and the seconf of yesterday.
The AB crash was being test flown.
The Almeria was flown into the sea. Nothing mechanical as far as I was aware. CFIT.
The Hong Kong accident is still under investigation. Amazing how well the aircraft flew if it had no MGB.
The South Korean crash is also still under investigation isn't it?
Abu-Dhabi crash was flown into the sea. Not too sure who was flying at the time.
Gulf's two aircraft had no fatalities thankfully.

eivissa 3rd May 2011 13:52

aegir
 
You are right. We dont know yet what happened to the Korean AW139 or at least I haven't seen any new information and I forgot to address that. Also I forgot to mention the crash in Abu Dhabi, but that was probably what SM was on about.

Some people like to think it was Sheikh Nasser Bin Zayed Al Nahyan at the controls at the time of the crash. We will probably never find out.

If all the AW139 crash rumours were true we have a machine with considerable weaknesses in the aft section as well as pilots loosing situational awareness in best flying conditions.

Outwest 3rd May 2011 13:56

Does anyone have the airframe and/or component times (TR) of the HK and Doha a/c? Are the numbers close?

Gordy 3rd May 2011 14:00

Another photo:

http://sjdrimages.com/Mb/UserUploads/s85Ar11QPl6n56.JPG

aegir 3rd May 2011 16:30

eivissa
 
I completly agree with you, this weakness of the AW139 it's very dangerous and seems that Agusta hasn't found a solution up to now!

Thankfully these two accidents happened when the helicopter was on ground!

stickysunrise 3rd May 2011 17:27

not just another for the AW139, another incident 4 Gulf
 
what about the collective control snapping in two mid-flight on the 412 at gulf helis last year?

seems things have gone very quiet about that incident- any news?

Now another major component breaking in their fleet? :sad: who's looking after the ponies in gulf heli's stables?

griffothefog 3rd May 2011 17:40

Yes, GHC are very consistent...:eek:

Perhaps the old chestnut of "you pay peanuts.." refers to their Engineering history of recent years.. :{

When I was there early 2000, they had a great team of Aussie engineers and pilots and things ran pretty smoothly.. :ok:

I'll say this only once... White middle UN-TRAINED management.......

9Aplus 3rd May 2011 18:26


this weakness of the AW139 it's very dangerous and seems that Agusta hasn't found a solution up to now!
:ugh: Like to know what was source of that "tail fire" than
jump in to big words cloclusions....

Aser 3rd May 2011 19:16

Hydraulic fire? :rolleyes:

Aser 3rd May 2011 22:21

For educational purposes...
http://i66.photobucket.com/albums/h2..._2999Small.jpg

http://i66.photobucket.com/albums/h2..._3015Small.jpg

Regards
Aser

SK76 3rd May 2011 23:03

AW139 incident with Gulf Helis
 
Let see to whom to be blame this time ... Manufacturer or engineering .
This is too much now


All times are GMT. The time now is 20:27.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.