PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   Cheapest helicopter to run? (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/381416-cheapest-helicopter-run.html)

princepilot 15th Jul 2009 17:11

Cheapest helicopter to run?
 
Hi,

Just after some figures....

What 4 seater helicopter would be the cheapest to run for private use? (inc of insurance, fuel economy, maintenance etc)

And do you have the figures to hand?

Cheers

Matt

61 Lafite 15th Jul 2009 18:28

The old quote of:

"If you have to ask, you can't afford it!"

springs to mind.... :E

Lafite

Mungo5 15th Jul 2009 18:30

R44 probably. R44 more ubiq. in the UK but high timers cost more are rebuild time.

ShyTorque 15th Jul 2009 18:49

Someone wrote "cheapest" and "helicopter" in the same sentence! :p

Whirlygig 15th Jul 2009 19:10

Perhaps he meant the "least expensive"? :ok:

Cheers

Whirls

princepilot 15th Jul 2009 20:16

The old quote of:

"If you have to ask, you can't afford it!"

springs to mind.... http://images.ibsrv.net/ibsrv/res/sr...ilies/evil.gif

Lafite

The old saying "look after the pennies and the pounds will look after themselves" springs to mind :*

I prefer money in my pocket not somebody elses

grizzled 15th Jul 2009 20:27

Cheapest 4 seater
 
This is the only one I've found that is truly affordable. And the safety record is impeccable.



http://i602.photobucket.com/albums/t...g?t=1247689459

krypton_john 15th Jul 2009 21:03

Build yourself a Hummingbird 260L with the LS7 engine option.

Hummingbird 260L Helicopter kits from Vertical Aviation Technologies

belloldtimer 15th Jul 2009 21:26

Homebuilt or production?
 
There is a great difference between doc (direct operating costs) of home built vs. production helios. Robinson win's hands down for production units, and as far as I know the hummingbird is the only 4 place homebuilt unit on the market today. Rotorway doesn't have a 4 place unit but they do build a slick 2 seater. Even the Robinson rebuild rates for a helo you already own to be factory rebuilt to new specs is not expensive when you compare it to anyother piston 4 seater. How bout considering a 3 seater from Schwitzer? Have you considered that, or a well maintained Bell 47 for a two place. There's a lot of product out there so take your time and choose wisely, sometimes the retail price may be high but the doc might be less then others on the market, so compare apples with apples and not oranges, or ducks! Good luck and cheers!:ok:

500e 15th Jul 2009 21:40

Cheap & helicopter in one sentence! don't understand:E

belloldtimer 15th Jul 2009 21:54

LEAST EXPENSIVE vs cheap
 
There's no such thing as cheap aviation there is less expensive ways to approach it, homebuilt vs. factory is one way to significantly reduce the cost of operation, Robinson as opposed to Bell in the 4 seater catagory trubine vs piston, etc. Pistons are always less expensive to operate then pistons unless your talking about very old read expensive to insure helios and then its a close horse race. In the 4 seater catagory if you compare Bell Jetranger vs Robinson R44 the 44 is almost sooooo much less to operate and is as fast if not faster then the JetRanger, sure it does'nt have the smell or cool sound of the JetRanger, or a lot of the amenities included in the Bell, but its a significantly less money to own and operate. Sure the hangers are about the same price, but the insurance and fuel are sure a lot more money, as are all the other costs associated with operating and ownership. Inexpensive does not equal cheap in aviation.:D As I said previously choose wisely and do the math on each one you are considering before signing on the dotted line. P.S. There are a few companies that specilize in helping people acquire helicopters like Bowers and others, a very good investment when you consider how complex the purchase of any helicopter is, they handle the pre-purchase inspection and hold your hand thru title insurance, etc, as I said a very wise invenstment on anyone's behalf who's considering the purchase of a new or used helicopter. Try the following link.....
www.bowerhelicopter.com

Coconutty 15th Jul 2009 22:26

Warning ! Warning !
 
Princepilot :

As you can see from some of the replies already, the question you have asked is being interpreted in a way you probably ( hopefully ) didn't anticipate .....


What 4 seater helicopter would be the cheapest to run for private use?
There will be those that will hope this isn't followed up with questions like :

"Where can I get the cheapest maintenance ?"

"Where can I get the cheapest / reconditioned / generic spares ?"

"Do I really need to carry out those time consuming pre-Flight checks every time ?"

The phrase "cheapest" in this context will often conjur up such thoughts...:rolleyes:

Perhaps a better question would be :

"Which 4 seater helicopter would provide the best value for money, in terms of Purchase price, Depreciation, Maintenance costs, Running costs, Fuel efficiency etc. based on an estimated xxx hours per year - for private use, and can anyone provide an estimate of the approximate total annual direct operating costs ?"

Having said all that I am not in a position to offer any answers to your question ( however it is worded ), but there are plenty here that can :)

http://i34.photobucket.com/albums/d1.../Coconutty.jpg

BV234driver 16th Jul 2009 01:14

Horse before cart.
 
First things first- as coconutty has said, there's questions of maintenance/spares, etc in addition to insurance and way more.

Each operator has a set or develops an operating requirement(s). From there, likely candidates are cast and evaluated for selection based on all factors. There is very little subjectivity when all the chips are down- operators usually will fly Bell, S, or AW airframes because they already have spares, operators, and maintainers familiar with said family of airframes.

'tis all getting too far from the helicopter & wrenches, and too close to the offices for my taste though. ;)

61 Lafite 16th Jul 2009 05:24


The old saying "look after the pennies and the pounds will look after themselves" springs to mind http://images.ibsrv.net/ibsrv/res/sr...milies/bah.gif

I prefer money in my pocket not somebody elses
Sadly, however hard you look after the pennies, helicopters have a nasty habit of ripping the pounds from your pocket with their untamed rotors and spewing them all over the ground.

You can plan your costs and we all do, but there is no place for 'cheap' and 'helicopter' in the same sentence, as wisely pointed out above.

A preference for money in your own pockets and helicopter ownership may be incompatible lifestyle choices!

... meant only half humorously..... :)

Lafite.

powerstall 16th Jul 2009 05:46

R44's would be a good bet. :ok:

princepilot 16th Jul 2009 10:40

toptobottom,

Thanks very much for this reply.

Ive pm'd you for some advice.

Matt

chopjock 16th Jul 2009 10:56

I'd say a H500C with a C18 is a very economical 4 seat helicopter. Obviously not new, but probably cheaper to run than a 44. :ok:

krypton_john 16th Jul 2009 11:00

How do you figure that, Chopjock?

toptobottom 16th Jul 2009 11:36

The $/£ rate has shifted significantly since i bought my 44. It cost me appx. £235k including a few bits n bobs, but the same ship would be almost £290k to buy new today.

Assume you do 100 hours as a PPL(H) p.a. Also assume a certain hull value after 12 years and take into account your likely usage over the period you will own the machine and you can easily work out the running costs per hour (if you look on Robinson's web****e, they attempt a similar thing but it's wildly optmistic, of course!).

If you assume an R44 is worth £40k as a timed out hull after 12 years and the cost of a 'standard spec' machine is say £275k to buy new today, the depreciation cost of owning one is (275-40)/2200 = £106 per hour. Add on maintenance, that's 1 x 50hrs plus 1 x 100 hr, an annual and ARC, say £6,500 plus £2,000 for ADs and other unscheduled maintenance, so that's another £85 per hour . Insurance, say £9,000 p.a. so £90 per hour. Finally, fuel (60 litres/hour) and oil, adds £90/hour.

Obviously the cost will vary according to your usage, the timing of scheduled maintenance and 'surprises', but in this case, you can expect a TCO of about £371 per hour. No doubt some people will disagree with my assumptions, but they're welcome to insert their own and do the maths :rolleyes:

Kelly Hopper 16th Jul 2009 12:05

Not forgetting the £290k up front to buy it or the cost of financing £290k.
At 5% that is £14500 a year in interest or £145 ph.
Makes you wanna just rent one really?

If it flies, floats or f@@ks, rent it!


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:34.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.