1986 UK Chinook Disaster Mini-Documentary
Originally Posted by [email protected]
I believe HUMS data stopped the rather punchy RAF Chinook display.
Shame, it was a very good display but you can't argue with the data.
I displayed the Lynx at Cosford this year and I'm sure people were disappointed that there were no backflips, loops and rolls but you just can't do that stuff any more - the Blue Eagles Lynx had G meters and in the F700 all the manouevres were recorded , each of which reduce component life significantly.
A private owner can't afford to do that and the permit to fly wouldn't allow it anyway.
I displayed the Lynx at Cosford this year and I'm sure people were disappointed that there were no backflips, loops and rolls but you just can't do that stuff any more - the Blue Eagles Lynx had G meters and in the F700 all the manouevres were recorded , each of which reduce component life significantly.
A private owner can't afford to do that and the permit to fly wouldn't allow it anyway.
Originally Posted by [email protected]
Shame, it was a very good display but you can't argue with the data.
I displayed the Lynx at Cosford this year and I'm sure people were disappointed that there were no backflips, loops and rolls but you just can't do that stuff any more - the Blue Eagles Lynx had G meters and in the F700 all the manouevres were recorded , each of which reduce component life significantly.
A private owner can't afford to do that and the permit to fly wouldn't allow it anyway.
I displayed the Lynx at Cosford this year and I'm sure people were disappointed that there were no backflips, loops and rolls but you just can't do that stuff any more - the Blue Eagles Lynx had G meters and in the F700 all the manouevres were recorded , each of which reduce component life significantly.
A private owner can't afford to do that and the permit to fly wouldn't allow it anyway.
was that XZ179?
Avoid imitations
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Wandering the FIR and cyberspace often at highly unsociable times
Posts: 14,573
Received 413 Likes
on
218 Posts
Originally Posted by [email protected]
I believe HUMS data stopped the rather punchy RAF Chinook display.
HC.....thank you for confirming what I said....so perhaps what you missed is I was noting that exactly as stated in the Accident Report...new designs might not work as anticipated and that would include systems like Hums and similar technology and we should be very careful our consideration of their effectiveness.
I am old enough to remember rotor track and balance being done with a pole and flag and some grease pencils and lived long enough to see the Chadwick system come along and change the standard for the better.
Same for. Hums....I saw the old bent knuckle advance to the state of the art systems we enjoy today.
That being said....just as your comment reminds us there is a limit to every system's ability to give advance warning of failures.
But as in your example....the chip detector system had to be altered and improved didn't it?
Did Eurocopterr ever come out with the exact cause of the failures....the actual root cause?
I recall they were being a bit quiet about it despite stating they had it figured out and fixed.
I know it was a sad day for you when those Cabs got hauled off for use as potting sheds.
I felt the same when that happened to the Chinook on the North Sea.
The only good of that was Columbia got some darn good helicopters cheap and. have flown them since and made a lot of money tn the process.
Forecasts are the Chinook design shall be flying well over a hundred years after coming to service with the US Military.
I am old enough to remember rotor track and balance being done with a pole and flag and some grease pencils and lived long enough to see the Chadwick system come along and change the standard for the better.
Same for. Hums....I saw the old bent knuckle advance to the state of the art systems we enjoy today.
That being said....just as your comment reminds us there is a limit to every system's ability to give advance warning of failures.
But as in your example....the chip detector system had to be altered and improved didn't it?
Did Eurocopterr ever come out with the exact cause of the failures....the actual root cause?
I recall they were being a bit quiet about it despite stating they had it figured out and fixed.
I know it was a sad day for you when those Cabs got hauled off for use as potting sheds.
I felt the same when that happened to the Chinook on the North Sea.
The only good of that was Columbia got some darn good helicopters cheap and. have flown them since and made a lot of money tn the process.
Forecasts are the Chinook design shall be flying well over a hundred years after coming to service with the US Military.
