Apparently Prince Harry Can't Fly a Helicopter
Nope, never have. I've got nothing against Will and Harry - they both seem like thoroughly decent chaps (and Harry's Invictus work is actually pretty inspirational). I'm just not kidding myself that either were given the opportunity to become military helicopter pilots for any other reason than they are royals. I am sure that I would have been laughed out the recruitment office had I shown up with a B in A-level Art and a D in geography and said I wanted to be an Apache pilot.
If you had passed the aptitude tests (as they did) you would have got in with those qualifications - I did with far less.
Charles already had his PPL(A) and flew himself to Cranwell for RAF jet training.
Charles already had his PPL(A) and flew himself to Cranwell for RAF jet training.
If you had passed the aptitude tests (as they did) you would have got in with those qualifications
...you would have got in with those qualifications - I did with far less
Charles already had his PPL(A) and flew himself to Cranwell for RAF jet training.
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: North Up
Posts: 489
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Charles already had his PPL(A) and flew himself to Cranwell for RAF jet training.
I went by train and was met by a Service minibus which was driven by a very sirly Corporal..
You were really selected for RAF officer/air crew selection with "far less" than two very poor A-levels
You joined and served as an officer? I'm guessing from your moniker that it wasn't any time recently. Under current requirements, you would need two A-levels as a minimum according to the RAF website. I suspect given the numbers that apply, you would need more than 'pass' grades in art and geography, and a decent degree as well.
Of course, when you did O levels fareastdriver they were probably as hard as A-levels and a degree today. Maybe crab too...
Of course, when you did O levels fareastdriver they were probably as hard as A-levels and a degree today. Maybe crab too...
Last edited by melmothtw; 3rd Oct 2017 at 13:32.
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: North Up
Posts: 489
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
In my day (very earliest 1970's) it was at least two "A" levels (I did the Scottish version: Highers) and at least five O Grades.
At the time, it was approximately the same as University Entrance, but the with the add-on fun bit of a five day membership at Biggin Hill Sports & Gaming Club.
At the time, it was approximately the same as University Entrance, but the with the add-on fun bit of a five day membership at Biggin Hill Sports & Gaming Club.
I'm guessing from your 'crab' moniker that you are (former) RAF? You were really selected for RAF officer/air crew selection with "far less" than two very poor A-levels (one of which was in art)? If that's true I take my hat off to you, but can only assume that you joined at a time when pilot spots weren't at quite the premium they were when the HRHs signed up.
I was lucky and got what I wanted - to be a helicopter pilot - in the days when the chop rate was significant and they could pick and choose who they wanted (early 80's). Just goes to show that what is required to be a pilot isn't always academic qualifications (the number of graduates that were chopped in my day was very high).
32 years later (all spent in flying posts) I retired but continue to fly and instruct.
As William and Harry prove - exam results do not make the man (or the pilot) - that is due to far more factors so perhaps you can stop being so disrespectful of two guys who have already done far more for their country than you ever will.
Avoid imitations
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Wandering the FIR and cyberspace often at highly unsociable times
Posts: 14,573
Received 413 Likes
on
218 Posts
I was qualified for a permanent commission in the mid 1970s with A levels in Maths and Physics. The academic requirements for selection as pilot remain to this day at two A levels. Definitely no need for a degree. There's a lot more to military piloting than higher academics.
As William and Harry prove - exam results do not make the man (or the pilot) - that is due to far more factors...
As I said in my earlier post I have no beef with either of them or the work that they have done for this country (though to be fair, doing work for the country is kind of in the job description, and the least I would expect from a royal family).
The point is, however, that once they had decided they were going to be military pilots the establishment and all that that entails was going to bend over backwards to make sure that they became military pilots because of who they are. If you're ok with that, then no problem. I'm not, which is why I said so.
Nope, never have. I've got nothing against Will and Harry - they both seem like thoroughly decent chaps (and Harry's Invictus work is actually pretty inspirational). I'm just not kidding myself that either were given the opportunity to become military helicopter pilots for any other reason than they are royals. I am sure that I would have been laughed out the recruitment office had I shown up with a B in A-level Art and a D in geography and said I wanted to be an Apache pilot.
Now if I had walked in to the CIO with crap academic quals and admitted to drug use, would I be selected for a commission?
Not a chance is the answer.
We all know it but the drones will find some reason to make it right in this case.
more to the point how many of the current crop (of any political persuasion) of £70,000+ p.a. part timers with unlimited perks and huge expenses have worn the colours and put themselves in harms way ?
Who are the real freeloaders ? Not the brave young man in the Apache helicopter.
There's enough danger out there without the risk of being shot in the back by some parliamentary
whose freedom of speech has been hard earned and rigorously protected by courageous youngsters irrespective of birth right for generations.
Her letter of resignation should begin "I'm sorry and end thank you" but it won't.
Be lucky
David
Who are the real freeloaders ? Not the brave young man in the Apache helicopter.
There's enough danger out there without the risk of being shot in the back by some parliamentary
whose freedom of speech has been hard earned and rigorously protected by courageous youngsters irrespective of birth right for generations.Her letter of resignation should begin "I'm sorry and end thank you" but it won't.
Be lucky
David
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_o...itish_politics
So the fact that I, as an ex-RAF QHI (also served with AAC), can attest to their flying abilities and that their selection and training afforded them no privileges at all, doesn't give you a clue as to how far from the mark you are in judging them?
I think the drones are those who won't let the truth get in the way of their political bigotry because it doesn't suit their version of the story.
I'd like to see either of you (melmoth and heliringer) pass the ground and air check ride that I gave William on his last operational SAR tour - guess what? It was exactly the same as the check rides given to the other 30 pilots on the Sqn and he was far from being at the bottom of the pile.
Privilege doesn't cut it in the mountains at night in poor weather and he has been there many times as the Captain and handling pilot - not something you let little rich boys do.
You won't see past your blinkered anti-monarchy views for whatever reasons I don't care to fathom.
I think the drones are those who won't let the truth get in the way of their political bigotry because it doesn't suit their version of the story.
I'd like to see either of you (melmoth and heliringer) pass the ground and air check ride that I gave William on his last operational SAR tour - guess what? It was exactly the same as the check rides given to the other 30 pilots on the Sqn and he was far from being at the bottom of the pile.
Privilege doesn't cut it in the mountains at night in poor weather and he has been there many times as the Captain and handling pilot - not something you let little rich boys do.
You won't see past your blinkered anti-monarchy views for whatever reasons I don't care to fathom.
Originally Posted by [email protected]
So the fact that I, as an ex-RAF QHI (also served with AAC), can attest to their flying abilities and that their selection and training afforded them no privileges at all, doesn't give you a clue as to how far from the mark you are in judging them?
I think the drones are those who won't let the truth get in the way of their political bigotry because it doesn't suit their version of the story.
I'd like to see either of you (melmoth and heliringer) pass the ground and air check ride that I gave William on his last operational SAR tour - guess what? It was exactly the same as the check rides given to the other 30 pilots on the Sqn and he was far from being at the bottom of the pile.
Privilege doesn't cut it in the mountains at night in poor weather and he has been there many times as the Captain and handling pilot - not something you let little rich boys do.
You won't see past your blinkered anti-monarchy views for whatever reasons I don't care to fathom.
I think the drones are those who won't let the truth get in the way of their political bigotry because it doesn't suit their version of the story.
I'd like to see either of you (melmoth and heliringer) pass the ground and air check ride that I gave William on his last operational SAR tour - guess what? It was exactly the same as the check rides given to the other 30 pilots on the Sqn and he was far from being at the bottom of the pile.
Privilege doesn't cut it in the mountains at night in poor weather and he has been there many times as the Captain and handling pilot - not something you let little rich boys do.
You won't see past your blinkered anti-monarchy views for whatever reasons I don't care to fathom.
As to 'drones not letting the truth get in the way of their political bigotry because it doesn't suit their version of the story', we are in full agreement.
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Stockport MAN/EGCC
Age: 70
Posts: 991
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Present members of the HoC and HoL some who are stiill serving.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_o...itish_politics
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_o...itish_politics
Considerably more than I would have thought.
Be lucky
David
You're missing the point crab
I understand that you have to believe that two privately educated, well mannered, intelligent young men couldn't possibly have got in on their own merits but it happens every day to normal people with the bare minimum qualifications.
Originally Posted by [email protected]
No, Harry will have served with many other pilots in the AAC who had limited academic qualifications and very possibly a dodgy past - the AAC, up until recently, took Corporals into flying training and a significant number of them went on to be operational aircraft commanders before comissioning and becoming Officers.
I understand that you have to believe that two privately educated, well mannered, intelligent young men couldn't possibly have got in on their own merits but it happens every day to normal people with the bare minimum qualifications.
I understand that you have to believe that two privately educated, well mannered, intelligent young men couldn't possibly have got in on their own merits but it happens every day to normal people with the bare minimum qualifications.
Look, when it comes to the royals and military flying there is one of three things going on:
1. Every Windsor is a natural born aviator, and there is never any question as to them being selected for pilot training or excelling at it once selected.
2. Military flying just isn't that difficult, and anyone can do it.
3. They get given the opportunity regardless of their ability, because of who they are.
There is no fourth option.
Now, you choose to believe option 1. I believe it to be option 3. I don't think there's going to be any meeting of minds on the subject, so there we go.
Last edited by melmothtw; 3rd Oct 2017 at 17:34.
