Over Torquing
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: earth
Posts: 76
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Over Torquing
If a single engine turbine is over torqued, where is the damage in the drive train likely to occur and which components most likely effected first ? Also, which maneuvers are most likely to lead to OT. Not a type specific question but more of a trawling for info one.
Thanks.
Thanks.
Gearbox (es), rotor mast, drive shafts, Thomas couplings, blades....need I go on? And was the engine overtemped in the process?
Any suspected overtorque should be reported to the approved maintnenance organisation and investigated iaw the type's Maintenance Manual.
Any suspected overtorque should be reported to the approved maintnenance organisation and investigated iaw the type's Maintenance Manual.
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Philadelphia PA
Age: 73
Posts: 1,835
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
What gets changed depends on the amount and duration of the over-torque. And what type of recording device, if any, was fitted.
Is the overtorque supported by corresponding engine information, or was it only registered on the torque meter?
Fitting something like the Intellistart system to a helicopter is going to save you from just a hot start event, it's going to record all the engine and transmission information, and possibly save you from replacing components due to a very minor overtorque.
Is the overtorque supported by corresponding engine information, or was it only registered on the torque meter?
Fitting something like the Intellistart system to a helicopter is going to save you from just a hot start event, it's going to record all the engine and transmission information, and possibly save you from replacing components due to a very minor overtorque.
To answer your specific questions:
I would look at the tail rotor blades and associated drivetrain first. The maintenance manual will/should tell you where to look based on the severity of the event. The main rotor stuff (blades, gearbox, etc.) is MUCH tougher.
And by "OT" I assume you mean "overtorque." Obviously, takeoffs and landings. Probably a landing gone wrong - oops! (No need for that much power in translated flight.) Left pedal turn in a very heavy hover, perhaps? Couple of different scenarios I can think of, each as "likely" as the next.
If a single engine turbine is over torqued, where is the damage in the drive train likely to occur and which components most likely effected first ?
Also, which maneuvers are most likely to lead to OT.
Below the Glidepath - not correcting
There's no generic answer for this because design details in the transmission and power assembly dictate the load path. Most transmissions use flexible and rigid couplings where excess torque will displace or distort the disks in the coupling pack or the fasteners holding the coupling to the drive shaft which may give a visual indication of damage.
But make no mistake, over torque checks are for qualified engineers using the approved maintenance documents. As a pilot, your only indication is the torque indicating system and if that is ever exceeded, it must be reported to a maintenance person.
Your question is hopefully hypothetical, but the acid test of a professional pilot is reporting all and any damage they may have caused before it kills the next occupant.
But make no mistake, over torque checks are for qualified engineers using the approved maintenance documents. As a pilot, your only indication is the torque indicating system and if that is ever exceeded, it must be reported to a maintenance person.
Your question is hopefully hypothetical, but the acid test of a professional pilot is reporting all and any damage they may have caused before it kills the next occupant.
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Over here
Posts: 1,030
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From what I've seen, takeoffs and landings are where overtorques usually happen, more often landing than taking off. I've known of a few that happened during a start. You can also just wind up the throttle too fast, but I think the most common scenario is a hot approach, and having to pull too much collective to stop. In a 206, it's very easy to overtorque on takeoff with a heavy load, by not being directly into the wind, having the nose come around, and having to shove in a lot of left pedal to prevent LTE, when you're at about 99.9% torque already. Large pedal inputs produce large torque spikes. My 206 takeoff technique was always to leave just a little in reserve, and most important, never let the nose move at all. If you keep the nose absolutely straight, you don't need to stomp on the pedal, and you can control the torque. Let it start to turn, and you're in trouble. I treat other models pretty much the same, because things are always better when you have a smooth control touch.
keep in mind that cyclic inputs do cause changes in tq..
also another point if you're taking off from an elevated helipad and you're just below your tq or even ITT limit, then keep in mind the attitude change that is about to happen to forward flight.
also another point if you're taking off from an elevated helipad and you're just below your tq or even ITT limit, then keep in mind the attitude change that is about to happen to forward flight.
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Indonesia
Posts: 289
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
'If a single engine turbine is over torqued, where is the damage in the drive train likely to occur and which components most likely effected first ? Also, which maneuvers are most likely to lead to OT. Not a type specific question but more of a trawling for info one.'
On the off chance you mean a single engine on a twin engined helicopter, its possible to overtorque the one engine without overtorqing the transmission system, saying this with the Bell 212 in mind.
If my memory serves me right this is true to the first level of overtorque inspections required at 106% (without books at hand to refer to). At 112% overtorque a lot of bits will need sending away for overhaul and inspection.
A big problem is when someone sees what is happening, maybe with eyes locked on TOTs who can truly say how long it was on over torque and what the peak was, time seems to 'telescope' in times of instant anxiety.
All the info for a decision will be in the maintenance books for both airframe and engines inspections.
On the off chance you mean a single engine on a twin engined helicopter, its possible to overtorque the one engine without overtorqing the transmission system, saying this with the Bell 212 in mind.
If my memory serves me right this is true to the first level of overtorque inspections required at 106% (without books at hand to refer to). At 112% overtorque a lot of bits will need sending away for overhaul and inspection.
A big problem is when someone sees what is happening, maybe with eyes locked on TOTs who can truly say how long it was on over torque and what the peak was, time seems to 'telescope' in times of instant anxiety.
All the info for a decision will be in the maintenance books for both airframe and engines inspections.
Join Date: May 2010
Location: Amazon Jungle
Age: 38
Posts: 304
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From what I learned from A-stars.
If you pass a certain limit for a certain time, you have to check everything, turbine, drivetrains, transmission blah blah blah, only mecanics know where to look for damage. Some birds will let you go past the red for a very short period of time, without causing damage. But it will be registered.
overtorque x time in it = damage
If you pass a certain limit for a certain time, you have to check everything, turbine, drivetrains, transmission blah blah blah, only mecanics know where to look for damage. Some birds will let you go past the red for a very short period of time, without causing damage. But it will be registered.
overtorque x time in it = damage
Another thing to be aware of
Most machines have a published transient inside which there is no maintenance action required.
A lot of machines have a varying list of inspections dependent on, as has been said above how far over you were and for how long. A little bit and for not very long costs less and vice versa.
The newer Agusta 109s (E and S models) have a very specific bit in the maintenance (or perhaps overhaul) manual that says something like above the transient limits remove the gearbox for maintenance at manufacturer (not a direct quote but you get the idea). Could catch some people coming from a 206 background and before anyone says it I wasn't looking because I had done it, I was putting together some training materials.
Most machines have a published transient inside which there is no maintenance action required.
A lot of machines have a varying list of inspections dependent on, as has been said above how far over you were and for how long. A little bit and for not very long costs less and vice versa.
The newer Agusta 109s (E and S models) have a very specific bit in the maintenance (or perhaps overhaul) manual that says something like above the transient limits remove the gearbox for maintenance at manufacturer (not a direct quote but you get the idea). Could catch some people coming from a 206 background and before anyone says it I wasn't looking because I had done it, I was putting together some training materials.
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Norway
Age: 44
Posts: 45
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My experience is that overtorque happens most likely on delivery of a heavy load, often if you come in too fast, or with a tailwind. Too hard pedal-inputs will result in an overtorque if you are on the limit.
In the AS 350, the freewheeling-unit may need replacement after a high overtorque, or several minor ones.
We had to replace a freewheeling-unit last year after a 16-sec 108% overtorque...! (There was a guy that ran under the load, and the pilot HAD to hold it until he was safe!). That unit had a pricetag of about 18,000,-Euros.
In the AS 350, the freewheeling-unit may need replacement after a high overtorque, or several minor ones.
We had to replace a freewheeling-unit last year after a 16-sec 108% overtorque...! (There was a guy that ran under the load, and the pilot HAD to hold it until he was safe!). That unit had a pricetag of about 18,000,-Euros.
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: White Waltham, Prestwick & Calgary
Age: 72
Posts: 4,149
Likes: 0
Received 29 Likes
on
14 Posts
If it was a 206, take a quick look at the brown stuff sealing the top and bottom parts of the MR gearbox for cracks (the two parts twist against each other), and the mast for crazing. Look under the engine at the pan and also the fuselage just forward of where the tailboom joins it for wrinkles. If you see anything there it was definitely over 120%!
110% on a 206 is a quick inspection, and 120% not much more. But as Nick Lappos once said - that's one out of your jar of sweeties gone!
It's always best to tell maintenance - engineers are very interested in their machines and like to know stuff like that. Sh*t happens and most of us have overtorqued at some time or other. In my case it was a sling load in a couple of gusts that came together from different directions before I managed to pickle it.
As for manoeuvres, you can get a lovely torque spike doing a power on recovery from autorotation if you don't watch it.
Phil
110% on a 206 is a quick inspection, and 120% not much more. But as Nick Lappos once said - that's one out of your jar of sweeties gone!
It's always best to tell maintenance - engineers are very interested in their machines and like to know stuff like that. Sh*t happens and most of us have overtorqued at some time or other. In my case it was a sling load in a couple of gusts that came together from different directions before I managed to pickle it.
As for manoeuvres, you can get a lovely torque spike doing a power on recovery from autorotation if you don't watch it.
Phil
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: CA
Age: 45
Posts: 15
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Let's not forget, that you can build helos that can not be over torqued.
Russian helicopters (it's always mentioned in general, I don't know which models it applies to or not) have no TQ gauge. The drivetrain is just built and rated so that it takes whatever the engine can deliver.
When the RRPM comes down you know you are over the TQ limit ;-)
Russian helicopters (it's always mentioned in general, I don't know which models it applies to or not) have no TQ gauge. The drivetrain is just built and rated so that it takes whatever the engine can deliver.
When the RRPM comes down you know you are over the TQ limit ;-)