Twin Turbine, Single engine performance & safety
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: North of Antartica
Posts: 180
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Single Engine versus Multi Engine Helicopter(safety)
OK Its the old chesnut reborn. Last week I overheard a pilot waxing lyrical to some VIP passengers that Multi engine helicopters only had a 2% safety improvement over Single engine helicopters!! so for the extra cost the Multi engine was just a waste of another US$1.5 million
I would love to know the figures upon which this was based.
Are they comparing like with like?? only types I could think of would be AS350 v AS355 or A109 power v A119 Koala.
I fly both multi and single machines and I always feel happier in the twin, not just because of the extra donkey, but also the extra generator, hydraulic system Etc. Am I wrong to feel "safer" in the twin. what are the figures on this??
Please don't post the usual "well they still share the transmission/tail rotor/fuel source". that does not really prove one type over another rather its an event which is equally likely in either!!
just deal with the differences and statistics to support/refute multi engine safety advantage .
Thanks
I would love to know the figures upon which this was based.
Are they comparing like with like?? only types I could think of would be AS350 v AS355 or A109 power v A119 Koala.
I fly both multi and single machines and I always feel happier in the twin, not just because of the extra donkey, but also the extra generator, hydraulic system Etc. Am I wrong to feel "safer" in the twin. what are the figures on this??
Please don't post the usual "well they still share the transmission/tail rotor/fuel source". that does not really prove one type over another rather its an event which is equally likely in either!!
just deal with the differences and statistics to support/refute multi engine safety advantage .
Thanks
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: USA (PA)
Age: 47
Posts: 300
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Heli-phile: In addition to this thread, where your post has been moved to, here is another (now locked) discussion about twin-engine/Cat A reliability and statistics you might find interesting:
http://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/154...oid-curve.html
Phil77
Thanks for the link: the thread is now unlocked.
Splot
http://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/154...oid-curve.html
Phil77
Thanks for the link: the thread is now unlocked.
Splot