PPL Training questions (UK)
HI all
3 years after I did a taster lesson in a DA20, (CubAir Redhill) and with some luck in saving, I've decided that 2021 will be the year I finally try and get my PPL! But inevitably I have concerns that I'm not doing this properly. I'll let you guys see my proposed plan, and if anything obvious jumps out as daft can you let me know? OK, so firstly I know I should do my Class 2 medical check before I start any training. The school I had my taster lesson recommends one based at the same place as them. I assume this doesn't represent a conflict of interests. I'm 42 and in pretty good health, don't drink much, don't smoke, not overweight, regularly sporty, so I don't imagine this to be a problem Location wise I'm roughly between Biggin Hill and Redhill. Probably closer to BH. But I've heard with it being so busy can result in less time actually flying and a fair amount of sitting and waiting whilst the litany of private jets get priority, so I'm erring towards Redhill. The lesson I had at Cubair was enjoyable, and the instructor seemed good. Though I must admit I was concentrating, so I wasn't very chatty! At Biggin, I see reasonable reviews for EFG, but don't know anyone there. In fact I don't know anyone with a PPL in the real world so I cant ask for recommendations. Also to think about is the surface. BH being paved and Redhill being grass. Is one more favourable to a complete beginner? I've seen the phrase "brakes off to brakes on" Is that a good thing? Or can you end up sat just off a runway for 20mins very easily? Plane choice. This is where I'm semi open. Cubair use Katana DA20s and EFG go for PA28s. I seriously doubt I will ever go on to do a CPL. But I recall that some of the larger CPL schools prefer DA20s and some lean towards Pipers, so I would like for the training to give me options if I ever find myself in that position. (Or at least not really restrict me) Or does it not really matter in the long term. DA20 obviously has a stick and the PAs have a Yoke. Is there a preference? Is there a snobbery even? Time Frame Everything I've read says that you shouldn't go too long between lessons as it's a skill that you need to build on regularly. I was thinking to start in probably April ish and aim to have passed by September-ish Is that a feasible time frame? Too ambitious? Would people recommend booking 3-4-5 hours every 2/3 weeks. TBH I'm sure some people just smash through it in 2 weeks or so, but I'm not looking to rush it. Suggestions welcome. Similarly is there non flight related things I could be looking to start now, books to study etc so that time in the plane is spent learning to fly and not wasted on things I could have done at home. On that note, how much time is prudent for home studies per week? Contingencies. Again I'm sure some people pass everything first time in the minimum about of time, but I'm human, so I guess there'll be things I don't do perfectly. So based on others experience, how many hours seem normal 50? 60? Obviously there's a cost angle to remember, but if you see headline figure say £15K is that realistic or are you looking at £18-20K when all is said and done? I have seen that others say you shouldn't pre pay for hours. But both schools I've mentioned offer discounts the more you buy, so is there a happy medium there? Say no more than 5 or 10 hours in one go? Thanks all for reading. Over to you guys to correct the glaring mistakes! :ok: |
Hi Plain 1,
Welcome! Firstly, 3 golden rules 1. Never pay up-front for flying training 2. Never pay up-front for flying training 3. Never pay up-front for flying training Now, the straight choice between Biggin and Redhill. As you say, Biggin benefits from a hard runway, Redhill is grass (mostly!) I'm not sure what's happening about the taxiway, had heard the widening was in dispute. No matter, the issue with the grass at Redhill is mostly about waterlogging in the Winter. You say you're planning on starting in April, when the grass should be OK. As you say, Biggin is really busy with exec. jets. Whilst the big airports like Gatwick are like ghost towns, private jets are still operating so I would imagine Biggin will still be subject to delays. Stick over yoke? I learned on a stick aircraft, then flew with a yoke, still sometimes fly with a stick. It's good to do both, can't say which is better to start with. How many hours? Minimum for a PPL is 45, budget for 60. I was 33 when I learned, took me 58. The extra hours are never wasted (well, shouldn't be anyway) Make sure you get something out of every flight. Book at least one flight a week, 2 if you can. 50% will get cancelled by weather. It'll still take you a year, unless you can invest mid-week time and make 4 bookings a week. There are 2 popular sets of manuals, AFE and Pooley's. If you want to do some reading ahead of time, buy book one, either one will do. This describes the flying exercises in accordance with the syllabus. If you can find out which syllabus each school uses, then you can get that book. I wouldn't buy any of the other text books just yet, until you've discussed it with your instructor. If you can, book a taster flight with both locations, so you can see for yourself not only how the airfield operates, but whether or not you're going to get on with the people, especially the instructors. If I can express a personal opinion, I've done quite a bit of flying from both places (though not recently) and I'd come down on the side of Redhill and Cubair. However, as I said, you REALLY need to meet the folk at each place and see if you'll get on with them. Good luck and let us know through these pages how you get on. TOO |
You already know that you like Cubair - decision made.
Book as often as you can, plan to lose half of those booked. Never pay more upfront for flying than you can afford to lose. Don't worry about how long it takes, it takes as long as it takes, it's all flying. You're going to be paying to fly once you have your licence, what's the difference? Remember to enjoy it. |
What is your end goal? If you're thinking about ever going commercial (and having a 20 year career at a pilot ahead of you) then definitely get a class one medical sooner rather than later.
As for flying, go for the PA28 - it's not expensive but will save you money in the long run. As others have said - it takes as long as it takes: if you are getting into flying as a hobby, you'll continue flying after your PPL, so hours don't matter. If you're getting a PPL as a stepping stone to a CPL, you'll still need to build hours afterwards, so again (to a point) hours don't matter. The number of hours for your PPL is a matter of ego only. With that said, and not wanting to start any arguments - it should be easy to get a PPL in 45 hours if you follow some simple rules (which you won't!): 1. Get the exams out of the way before you go flying. With them out of the way you can have an uninterrupted course of flying with only weather and maintenance getting in the way. You want to be flying 5 times a week if possible. So do it in summer. Or Florida. 2. Learn everything about the aircraft before you get in it. Know the POH and checklists off by heart and when you need them. 3. Don't plan on learning anything in the aircraft - you should get in knowing what you're going to be doing. That's where a good brief is with its weight in gold. Use the time in the aircraft to watch the demo then practice, that's all your brain will have capacity to do. 4. Chair-fly every day. This is the best piece of advice you'll ever get and it's free. Your instructor is simply looking for you to demonstrate competency in each maneuver: if you forget to put the carb heat on, or do a checklist on downwind - you'll have to do that maneuver again. You give yourself the best chance of getting it right sooner if you chair fly and turn up prepared. 5. Learn in a 4 seater. Pick a buddy to learn with and back-seat as many of each others flights as you can. You will learn as much if not more from the back seat watching someone else struggle as you will from the front - because the pressure is off and you have spare capacity. You'll have much more exposure to radio calls, traffic patterns and especially navigation and area familiarity. For free. |
I would just like to echo the point about backseating a friend's lessons, you will absorb so much more whilst you aren't sweating in the front in the circuit.
|
EFG, great school but severely hampered by Biggin management including circuit and student solo restrictions and heavy landing fees.
Redhill regularly waterlogged and unusable, but don't forget to include Redhill Aviation in your search if you're determined to go there. They have a longstanding and envious reputation. You have many other airfield options if you are mobile, lots within an hour or so. Commuting cost is peanuts compared to the cost of flying. Following any training event and it's debrief, you will self debrief for some time after anyway and some of this can be done on the way home. Unless you're very blessed it'll likely be 55 to 60 hours and: Don't pay upfront! |
Don't be negative about your talents.
I was 32 when as a motorcycle rider & working far away from home I first decided to have a go at flying, Then had to break the learning sequence between Sydney Aus. and U.K. Shoreham Sussex - it took some 15 months (lowish finances) and just under 40 hrs to GFT. Heard about the PFA - now LAA - and shared ownership initially got me into the fun side of light a/c ownership; I have stayed PPL ever since, Radio licence wasn't necessary or done legally till much later. As for Nav. well with the magic of GPS & mapped screens nowadays it should be easier really ! |
Decide for yourself what you want the PPL for. As a goal by itself, the PPL has little value over "lower" licenses. Its main advantage is that one can add to it: CPL, IFR, night flying.
|
I drive to BH a few times a year for various reasons from the Heathrow area. On average, and not pushing it, I leave about an hour and a quarter and am rarely over an hour. So, starting from BH in that time you could be at Fairoaks or Rochester and probably Headcorn as well and probably many other ‘smaller’ fields. Damyns Hall in enemy territory might be an option?
Think about the type of flying you want to do - why a PPL and not LAPL / NPPL(A) / Microlight and then move up if necessary. Wherever and whatever you choose, pop in and have a chat and get the feel for it - where are you comfortable and who are you comfortable with? |
Thanks everyone for the responses. Loads of great info to digest.
Originally Posted by TheOddOne
(Post 10971479)
...
1. Never pay up-front for flying training 2. Never pay up-front for flying training 3. Never pay up-front for flying training ... 50% will get cancelled by weather
Originally Posted by MaxR
(Post 10971730)
Book as often as you can, plan to lose half of those booked. Never pay more upfront for flying than you can afford to lose..
Originally Posted by MrAverage
(Post 10971872)
Don't pay upfront!
Originally Posted by rudestuff
(Post 10971805)
What is your end goal? If you're thinking about ever going commercial (and having a 20 year career at a pilot ahead of you) then definitely get a class one medical sooner rather than later.
Originally Posted by rudestuff
(Post 10971805)
As for flying, go for the PA28 - it's not expensive but will save you money in the long run. 3. Don't plan on learning anything in the aircraft - you should get in knowing what you're going to be doing. That's where a good brief is with its weight in gold. Use the time in the aircraft to watch the demo then practice, that's all your brain will have capacity to do. 4. Chair-fly every day. This is the best piece of advice you'll ever get and it's free. Your instructor is simply looking for you to demonstrate competency in each manoeuvre: if you forget to put the carb heat on, or do a checklist on downwind - you'll have to do that manoeuvre again. You give yourself the best chance of getting it right sooner if you chair fly and turn up prepared. 5. Learn in a 4 seater. Pick a buddy to learn with and back-seat as many of each others flights as you can. You will learn as much if not more from the back seat watching someone else struggle as you will from the front - because the pressure is off and you have spare capacity. You'll have much more exposure to radio calls, traffic patterns and especially navigation and area familiarity. For free.
Originally Posted by TheOddOne
(Post 10971479)
...
Book at least one flight a week, 2 if you can.. It'll still take you a year, unless you can invest mid-week time and make 4 bookings a week. There are 2 popular sets of manuals, AFE and Pooley's. If you want to do some reading ahead of time, buy book one, either one will do. This describes the flying exercises in accordance with the syllabus. If you can find out which syllabus each school uses, then you can get that book. I wouldn't buy any of the other text books just yet, until you've discussed it with your instructor.
Originally Posted by MrAverage
(Post 10971872)
... but don't forget to include Redhill Aviation in your search if you're determined to go there. They have a longstanding and envious reputation.
You have many other airfield options if you are mobile, lots within an hour or so. Commuting cost is peanuts compared to the cost of flying. Following any training event and it's debrief, you will self debrief for some time after anyway and some of this can be done on the way home. Which brings me to
Originally Posted by Duchess_Driver
(Post 10972390)
...you could be at Fairoaks...
But clearly Flysynergy.com operate Pipers from there so they are definitely on my list. Especially since I work closer to there than I do to Redhill. Meaning flying after work would be an option. I would guess very few schools would allow lessons to start at 6am during the week, but maybe I'm wrong. Thanks again everyone |
Plain1
Most flying clubs and schools are limited companies. They've been going bust owing people significant amounts of money since long before I started and will continue to do so. Just like airlines. Many, but not all (there are some who protect your money) rely on your £5k to pay some outstanding bills in order to stay afloat. You can ask me how I know in a PM if you wish. |
Some good advice from above replies. Just a few words on the katana. Did some hours early on in my training 17 years ago. Loved the aircraft and the great visibility. Only transferred to a PA28 due to lack of availability on the katana. Advantage vs PA28 or C152 is the c/s or wobbly prop. Hours spent training on this type will qualify you for other complex aircraft in the future should you wish to fly one. The katana is a slippery aircraft compared to most other trainers, and the skill needed to control speed on approach is IMO a useful extra tool to have. If you can nail the approach in a katana, you will find a PA28 easy.
|
I learned in a Thielert diesel DA40. Learning while making trips with a coffee break in the middle for changing student places was relaxed with very useful opportunity for learning while in the 'supervisory' backseat. Requires that neither the CFI nor either student is on a tight schedule.
|
My 2¢ for what it's worth. I learned in the US so not directly comparable, at one of the busiest small airports in the world (Palo Alto) - on a fine Saturday morning, being number 5 to land is common.
First, it really doesn't matter what you learn on (within reason - there are people who have learned in a Pitts, but that doesn't make it a good idea). You'd be amazed at how easy the transition is from low wing to high wing, or yoke to stick, or whatever, once you've established a basic skill level. I learned on a 172, with odd lessons in a 152. Not long after I transitioned to a 182, then my own TR182, with odd flights in a PA28, SR20 and Robin. It takes about five minutes to stop noticing the different controls. While learning stick to one type, but afterwards you'll transition easily enough. (Low wing to/from high wing takes a bit of practice, but no biggie - you'll nail it in an hour). The ONLY hard thing in flying is landing. (There are lots of things that SEEM hard, but landing well takes a lot of practice). So while learning, you need to do it as often as possible. That rules out Biggin - and PAO too, for intensive pattern work we would bop over to one of the less busy fields in the area. (Fond memories of my tailwheel checkout, 13 landings in 30 minutes on a calm day at Byron where we flew dog-leg turns at each end of the runway). My only times at Redhill have been in a heli, and I don't think I've ever seen a fixed wing movement there! - always waterlogged. |
Follow the steps below (in that particular order):
1. get your class 2 medical 2. study and pass ppl theory 3. go flying Any other order may incur unnecessary costs. Good luck! |
Originally Posted by n5296s
(Post 10985242)
The ONLY hard thing in flying is landing.
|
Originally Posted by Bosi72
(Post 10988163)
Follow the steps below (in that particular order):
1. get your class 2 medical 2. study and pass ppl theory 3. go flying Any other order may incur unnecessary costs. Good luck! |
I fly at Cubair, have done for about 10 years. Do it because they are a good friendly bunch, who genuinely want people to learn and enjoy themselves. I'm more of a friend than a customer.
I have had a PPL a long long time and fly their PA-28. I used to fly the DA40-180 and will again when it's available. The Cub is also an option but one I've never followed. I've only flown a DA-20 once, just have a preference for the PA-28 as most of my time is on various models of Cherokee/Warrior/Archer and 172s. I don't have an issue with the wet boggy grass because there are hard taxiways and a slightly challenging piece of taxiway known as RWY 25/08 (look in the AIP or on the Redhill Aerodrome web site) used when the grass is too wet and soft. It generally works fine but being narrow is a bit cross wind limited. Normal crap visibility is more of a constraint than the soft airfield. I last flew in December and am just waiting for Covid to allow me to fly again. I am quite happy there. |
Rudestuff
Some great advice there, especially about the armchair flying & the backseating |
Originally Posted by rudestuff
(Post 10988234)
The best advice I ever had about landing was from Douglas Adams in the Hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy: "The knack lies in learning how to throw yourself at the ground and miss."
|
I am confused here. My expectation is that if I pre book say 10 lessons to get a cheaper rate, then why would cancellations outside my control mean I might lose them? Weather is weather, maintenance of aircraft is not my fault. If I don't turn up, I'd expect to lose out, but is there something I'm missing about the way flight schools operate? Yes, flying schools are run on very tight margins and often go bust. When that happens, usually the students don't see a penny of their money back. It is also not unknown for students, for whatever reasons of their own, to decide they're not happy and wish to switch schools - and then for the old school to refuse to refund any money already paid, regardless of whether that's been flown or not. Don't pay up front any more money than you can afford to write off. G |
Redhill is great to learn
I train at redhill Aviation i recommend them , great selection of cessna & piper aircrafts. Great airspace to learn being so close to Gatwick. At redhill there is also an AME where you can get your class 2 initial done, redhill is mainly grass but when runway is waterlogged they use the taxi way as a runway. Incase you didnt know EFG is now going to be based at Redhill
|
I am confused here. My expectation is that if I pre book say 10 lessons to get a cheaper rate, then why would cancellations outside my control mean I might lose them? Weather is weather, maintenance of aircraft is not my fault. If I don't turn up, I'd expect to lose out, but is there something I'm missing about the way flight schools operate? That said, a financially aware person can mitigate this risk in a number of ways (and thus take advantage of block booking discounts). Due diligence on the flying school (some have been around for decades and are perfectly financially sound) Paying in small blocks and using them quickly. Paying by credit card to to get Section 75 credit card cover (there are rules to be followed here and you need to check the detail of the payment processor to ensure coverage). Advance Payment Protection insurance may be an option especially if you can pay for the lessons through a company. If you can't be assed to do go through the nause of doing any/all of the above (and you're not rich :)) then yeah, just pay cash as you go along. |
Originally Posted by Genghis the Engineer
(Post 10988867)
Yes, flying schools are run on very tight margins and often go bust. When that happens, usually the students don't see a penny of their money back. It is also not unknown for students, for whatever reasons of their own, to decide they're not happy and wish to switch schools - and then for the old school to refuse to refund any money already paid, regardless of whether that's been flown or not. Don't pay up front any more money than you can afford to write off. G Can someone else give advice on making sure that a student has enough evidence of training hours/lessons completed at licence issue time by the CAA when/if the flying school has gone bust by then? |
1. Log book, each flight signed off by instructor. Not currently mandated, but I'm doing this now, anyway.
2. Make sure you see each entry recorded in your student notes, you should be signing them off. I discuss what I've written with each student, as part of the debrief. 3. Student notes SHOULD be forwarded to the CAA on cessation of trading by a DTO/ATO. Why wouldn't they do this? A student can't be in possession of their own notes. TOO |
TOO wrote:
"Student notes SHOULD be forwarded to the CAA on cessation of trading by a DTO/ATO. Why wouldn't they do this? A student can't be in possession of their own notes." I know they should but have heard of cases where they have not after a flying school has gone bust.. Good tip to get each training flight signed off by your instructor though. I hope the thread starter does not get put off by all this because there are reliable flying schools about as others have mentioned. Despite this, I would still stick to TOO's original 3 golden rules: 1. Never pay up-front for flying training 2. Never pay up-front for flying training 3. Never pay up-front for flying training |
Hi everyone.
Just a couple of quickies (ooh er!) Just wondering if anyone has any suggestions on additional questions to ask at the various schools I'm considering. Questions I've already decided to ask are: 1) Is flying limited in terms of hours (ie nothing before say 8am or after 7pm, only Wednesday to Sunday etc) 2) What books do you recommend. (Pooleys or AFE) Anecdotally it seems Pooleys is the preferred one. 3) What's your pass rate? And average hours 4) Is there any form of payment protection should the worst happen (I think this is less likely with Redhill Aviation or CubAir since they've seemingly been around a long time. Not sure how long Synergy @ Fairoaks have existed) On a side note, I've seen suggestions of learning abroad (often in a more condensed time frame due to better weather probability) Hypothetically, if I could get 6-8 weeks semi-unpaid leave from my employer, ) is this even a good idea? (A few colleagues have gotten 6 weeks off to travel Australia and the Far East, so there is precedent) I cant speak any language to a fluent level (though I'm "get by level" in French and German) so worry about that inhibiting me. And that's before we even consider the post Brexit changes in going abroad to study.
Originally Posted by Peter Ahonsi
(Post 10988871)
I train at redhill Aviation i recommend them , great selection of cessna & piper aircrafts. Great airspace to learn being so close to Gatwick. At redhill there is also an AME where you can get your class 2 initial done, redhill is mainly grass but when runway is waterlogged they use the taxi way as a runway. Incase you didnt know EFG is now going to be based at Redhill
RE: EFG I went past Biggin Hill a few weeks ago and there were no planes visible by their unit. Though the signage is still up. I had already discounted anyone at BH simply for the traffic issues. Thanks everyone for the advice |
I’m not going to bother cutting and pasting anything after that, but I would tend to disagree with the learn in a four seater and watch from the back as your pilot buddy learns advice. Yes it works well in commercial and instrument rating training, but relies on you and your flying buddy always being available at the same time for lessons. Also don’t forget the price differential. Where I instruct it costs an extra £45 per hour to fly a four seat aircraft as opposed to a two seat aircraft. If you sensibly budget for sixty hours training that’s an extra £2700, or 22.5 hours in the Cessna 152. Your not going to save that time watching someone else fly. Train in the two seater, and then do at most a couple of hours in a four seater once you e got your licence, if you want to carry more weight.
Also, if you’re sure you are only ever going to fly privately think seriously about microlights. With the new 600kg weight limits coming in modern three axis microlights are as capable for VFR flying as a Cessna 152/ Tomahawk / piper cub etc, and the exams and syllabus is a lot simpler and the licence will be cheaper to obtain. |
Plain 1 to answer your specific question in post #27.
Check the licensed hours of the airfield as training will need to be done in these hours. I started at Blackbushe in early spring, but once the light evenings came along I realised I could not make use of them due to limited licensed hours. I ended up going to White Waltham to complete my training and took advantage of lower weekday rates. With reference to the hours needed, as mentioned by other posters, it can vary greatly, but I am no ace pilot and managed to pass in 47 hours. A lot will depend on your relationship with your instructor. I got along really well with mine, and I’m sure it helped me enormously. |
I don't agree with some of the concepts presented in the earlier posts. As said just above, training with someone in the back seat is not always a good idea, and a not so good idea for basic flight training. I'm not saying not to flay a four seat plane, but if you do, leave the back seats empty. A new student pilot does not need the distraction of someone in the back. Focus on what you're doing, minimize distractions as much as possible. Anyone on board is a distraction. For dual instruction, an instructor is a necessary distraction.
As much as possible, mix "in airplane" time with book study. It is unwise to attempt to get most of the way through book study and ground school without some time in the plane. Even time spent sitting in the plane on a poor weather day has benefit. If you memorize the books, you may have to unlearn some of what you thought you knew from the books, when you get in the plane - "Oh, it's like that!....". As much as practical, mix it up, that will show you that you cannot be fully prepared to fly from reading the books only. Some hands and feet, and developing muscle memory is necessary, and for a GA type plane, that only comes from sitting in it. Many of us learned to fly entirely in the aircraft, with ground school being a fill in the blanks activity to assure passing the exams. Sit in as many airplanes as you can, and make an effort to understand every control and instrument. Understand similarities, and differences. Yes, your instructor is probably underpaid! That is something you can affect! Pay your instructor for their time! Do not expect to have a half hour of their time after a flight at their personal, nor the school's expense. Willingly pay for ground briefings before and after the flight. Willingly pay for a little extra flying here and there when you need to build certain skills. With the information age, there is a vast amount of information placed where student pilot's will find it. Some of it has value. But, remind yourself that information typed onto the internet is low cost, so more voluminous (because of low cost to create) and less valuable when it applies to actual hands on aircraft handling skill building. Watching Youtube, flying computer flight simulators and reading about flying can provide only a small amount of what a student needs to learn about basic airplane handling. Yes, rules of the air, weather, navigation and some systems can be taught out of the plane, but handling learning it is best done in the plane. |
Hi PL,
That's a fantastic job you did there distilling all the info from previous posts. However, Make sure each flight is recorded in your student record folder held by your school. Get a copy of each sheet of your student record folder, even if it just a photo, but better to have a scan or a photocopy. If the company goes bust, this is all you will have for your money. Remember that you have a right to have a copy of your record folder and that you can take them and your business to another school without asking for permission. Anyone got anything in writing from the UK CAA? TOO |
All times are GMT. The time now is 09:04. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.