PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Private Flying (https://www.pprune.org/private-flying-63/)
-   -   please explain this one (https://www.pprune.org/private-flying/508484-please-explain-one.html)

piperboy84 20th Feb 2013 19:46

please explain this one
 
Is there something wrong or am I just being a dummy.

Line up on 27, wet compass shows 27 set HI to 27 and set off in very light variable wind. Fly about an hour north then turn around to head home, set the Garmin 496 for "go direct" back to my home field and follow the pointer that extends from the wee plane on the screen. The Garmin shows my Course, Bearing and Track all 180 BUT the wet compass and HI show I am flying 210 !

What am I missing here?

fisbangwollop 20th Feb 2013 20:06

Maybe a strong westerly wind, tracking 180 but heading 210? :cool:

piperboy84 20th Feb 2013 20:08

I understand that bearing doesn't but course and track must use either magnetic or true as a reference, or am I completely off the reservation here?


Maybe a strong westerly wind, tracking 180 but heading 210
If that was the case then wouldn't my course and track be different to reflect that?

fisbangwollop 20th Feb 2013 20:12

Back to basics for you Piperboy....

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Course_(navigation)

piperarcher 20th Feb 2013 20:13

Do you have anything metal placed close to the Compass. I put my Zaon MRX up on top of the instrument panel and it was at the time a little too close to the compass and was knocking it off by about 20 degrees. Other than I can only guess one of the two screws that calibrate it have moved and your compass needs recalibrating. I would agree its a bit stange but I often find the wet compass is never as precise as a GPS reading.

rans6andrew 20th Feb 2013 20:16

If you get the ball back in the centre, does it all swing back into agreement?;)

Rans6...

piperboy84 20th Feb 2013 20:17

i have a Zaon XRX up there also

piperboy84 20th Feb 2013 20:18


Back to basics for you Piperboy....
Looks like I may have to scurry away and do some reading (or re-reading) before I dig myself in deeper !!!

Johnm 20th Feb 2013 20:42

Hmmmm magnetic heading is where the aeroplane is pointing. Track is the actual direction of travel over planet earth, the difference is the correction for drift due to wind. 30 degrees is a lot of drift so it's likely that the compass is subject to some sort of interference too.

You need to revise your basic navigation and make sure that there's nothing within a foot of the compass that might have magnetic properties.

dublinpilot 20th Feb 2013 22:13

Is your GPS track set to true rather than magnetic?

What is the magnetic variation in your area?

phiggsbroadband 20th Feb 2013 22:31

Hi, if you assume that magnetic = true for the purpose of an easy calculation, then you can use a velocity triangle to determine the wind velocity. The Hypotenuse side is your airspeed, and the Opposite side is the wind speed. Remember OHMS? Opp/Hyp means Sin.

So for 30 degrees, sin 30 = 0.5

Which means your cross wind is 0.5 of your airspeed... Say 45 knots if you are in a 90 knot cessna.

(Even allowing 3 deg magnetic variation, its still 41 knots.)

dont overfil 21st Feb 2013 09:32

Thinking out the box here. Did you check the wet compass in level flight northbound?

Does your wet compass read differently in the level attitude compared with the more extreme 3 point attitude you have with the bigger wheels?

D.O.

rans6andrew 21st Feb 2013 10:54

and don't forget, the HI is a gyro instrument and will drift off by 15 degrees per hour, give or take.

UV 21st Feb 2013 12:24


the HI is a gyro instrument and will drift off by 15 degrees per hour, give or take.
Not if the Latitude nut is set correctly (which it should be).

RTN11 21st Feb 2013 12:55

The GPS has no idea of your heading or how much drift you are offsetting, it only shows track, so your track is 180, heading is 210, where's the issue?

Shaggy Sheep Driver 21st Feb 2013 15:27

This reminds me of a chap (non pilot) I used to take flying in the Chippy (him in rear cockpit) occasionally. One day we had a good ground speed and explained that was because of a healthy tail wind.

"Oh, I could tell that", he replied.... "by the wind blowing in under the back of the canopy!". :eek:

sycamore 21st Feb 2013 17:44

UV, the latitude nut caters for `transport drift` ,not Earth rotation.The Di must be reset to the best `compass` every 15 minutes,as it will still drift,due Earth rotation..

znww5 21st Feb 2013 21:35

A touch of wind
 
Perhaps worth mentioning; the winds might be 270 and light on/near the ground, but what about the winds aloft from F214?

keith williams 21st Feb 2013 23:02

Sycamore


the latitude nut caters for `transport drift` ,not Earth rotation.
The latitude nut is simply a metal nut mounted on a threaded stud which protrudes from the inner gimbal. Altering the position of the nut creates an imbalance of the gimbal. This in turn creates a wander rate which compensates for (part of) the wander of the gyro.

The latitude nut is not accessible to the pilot, so it can be adjusted only in the instrument workshop........................1

Earth rate wander (in degrees per hour) = 15 x Sin latitude. So for a given latitude it is constant.

Transport wander = West - East Ground speed x Tan Latitude / 60.

The west-east ground speed can be adjusted (within limits) at will by the pilot................2

If you look at statements 1 and 2 you should see that the (constant) position of the latitude nut cannot compensate for the (non constant) transport wander, but it can compensate for the (constant) earth rate wander.

Crash one 21st Feb 2013 23:11

Piperboy, If you flew north for an hour was that on the wet compass or the GPS?
Frinstance in a westerly of 15knots you will be 15nm east of where you thought in a hour if yr on the wet compass. If you then turn round & fly south on the wet compass fr another hour yr gonna be 30nm East of home, or thereabouts, aren't you? So the GPS go to is telling you where home really is innit? Never mind all this wind triangle deviation gobbledegook.:ok:


All times are GMT. The time now is 22:27.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.