PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Private Flying (https://www.pprune.org/private-flying-63/)
-   -   How often did you have to divert to an alternate A/D ? (https://www.pprune.org/private-flying/347171-how-often-did-you-have-divert-alternate-d.html)

englishal 17th Oct 2008 08:19

Diverted once for a steak ;) IFR in California, decided we were hungry, and only 20 miles from Harris Ranch, a fly in steak restaraunt, so we cancelled IFR, and Oakland Centre gave us vectors. Best steak ever.

Mind you try that in Euroland and you'd have a £1000 bill to deal with. In the US it is easy to divert - you just do it.

Katamarino 17th Oct 2008 08:51

I've been forced to divert twice, and chosen to a number of times more.

The first forced one was on my PPL QXC in Florida. Flying west from Fort Pierce, the cloud was getting lower and lower, and I went with it down to about 400' (silly inexperienced student!) I decided at this point, finally, that this was a bad plan and turned around, heading south away from the cloud to land at Pahokee and check weather for an alternate route onwards. On returning to Ft Pierce my instructor pointed out that technically my landing was illegal as he had to sign me off in advance for any airport I wished to land at, but agreed it was the right decision! It was during this landing that I came very close to having a 'dog strike', as a I recall...

Fuji Abound 17th Oct 2008 10:21


On returning to Ft Pierce my instructor pointed out that technically my landing was illegal as he had to sign me off in advance for any airport I wished to land at, but agreed it was the right decision!
Is anything illegal, technically or otherwise, if the safety of the aircraft is at stake? Shirley what you did to get your self into the situation in the first place (flying into IMC when not qualified to do so) might be illegal but what you did to get yourself out of it is another matter. Just musing.

Katamarino 17th Oct 2008 11:09

I was never IMC, but I was pretty low! And this was the view that both he and I took; common sense decisions over safety should take precedence over the technicalities of the legislation.

possel 17th Oct 2008 11:44

Four times in 320 hours, each time due to UK weather. I was looked after exceedingly well on three occasions (Cranfield, Denham and Sherburn), and the fourth time no-one knew as it was after closing hours (won't say where)!

And as regards legality, the captain is always, above all, responsible for the safety of his aircraft, passengers and self - if he doesn't look after those, THEN he is "endangering the safety" and that's illegal (and worse than any "technicality", I submit)!

AfricanEagle 17th Oct 2008 13:38

Twice.

Once due to meteo conditions, landed at a military airfield.

The other time I couldn't find the farmer strip I was meant to spend the night at and diverted to big airport when it got too dark to continue searching :uhoh:

SkyHawk-N 17th Oct 2008 13:38


I find it hard to believe anybody would divert to have a wee. Why not carry a plastic bottle?
Who said "wee" anyway, jumping to conclusions again IO540? It could have been a young female passenger who didn't want to wee infront of strangers...maybe? Someone could have been ill, couldn't they? :rolleyes:

Piper.Classique 17th Oct 2008 15:24


I find it hard to believe anybody would divert to have a wee. Why not carry a plastic bottle?
Because I don't have a penis to put in the bottle. Some of us have differently arranged anatomy. And yes, I have before now diverted to use facilities not available in the aircraft.

SNS3Guppy 17th Oct 2008 15:32


I find it hard to believe anybody would divert to have a wee. Why not carry a plastic bottle?
I surely have diverted and landed for that very reason.

You try working it out in a small single seat cockpit in severe turbulence and see how you fare.

S-Works 17th Oct 2008 15:38

Don't worry, IO has one of the new long range TB20's soon to be adopted by easyjet. He struggles to understand why the rest of us don't enjoy sitting in a spamcan for 6hrs peeing in a coke bottle in aid of getting to where ever he is heading non stop.

Personally I prefer to meander in my general aviation flying and the journey along with all with all of the stops is what makes the trip worthwhile.

Fuji Abound 17th Oct 2008 16:16

I have never tried. Not sure I could aim that straight. :)

Mind you there are plenty of pi**ing competitions on here so I bet some of us are better than others :) :).

I have suggested it to my wife and a couple of other girls including my daughter that like to fly even explaining the finer detail, but when they looked absolutely horrified at the idea, I gave it up completly and have had to promise never to mention it again. :} I should add thats them doing the pi**ing, not me, in one of those contraption specially designed for the lady in your life I am told.

Mind you I will always remember taking my son on the flight to Manchester or some where like that when he was very young in the days they didnt have a loo on board - perhaps they still dont. Of course his first question was where is the loo Dad. he was equally horrified to be told there wasnt one. Rest assured the hostie was at pains to say she had had to deal with far far worse.

Hope you had a good trip Bose.

IO540 17th Oct 2008 16:30

Trust me, I would win any pi**ing competition, with the amount of practice I've had. Twice today, at FL050 :)

Piper.Classique, my apologies ;)


And as regards legality, the captain is always, above all, responsible for the safety of his aircraft, passengers and self - if he doesn't look after those, THEN he is "endangering the safety" and that's illegal (and worse than any "technicality", I submit)!
I agree, but how do you square that with all the various rules about where one can and cannot land. PPR, PPR for Customs, PPR for this and that. Some places (in Europe) you will get into only by declaring a mayday. Tricky! BTW I believe that most airports that are "PPR" are probably acting illegally.

PlasticPilot 17th Oct 2008 17:18

I can remember five of them over 360 hours:

One because of low visibility on a VFR flight shortly after getting my PPL
One return to home, VFR, because of a failed alternator
Twice on alpine VFR flights because of cloud obstructed passes
One going IFR to Zurich (LSZH). The weather there was below CAT I minimas, and did not lift as expected.

Romeo Tango 17th Oct 2008 18:08

Not yet this year.

Fuji Abound 17th Oct 2008 19:08


He struggles to understand why the rest of us don't enjoy sitting in a spamcan for 6hrs peeing in a coke bottle in aid of getting to where ever he is heading non stop.
Bose - you are not conceeding that you are not up to the pi**ing competition are you? :)

Airbus Girl 17th Oct 2008 22:23

Anyway, returning to the subject......

There was another time I diverted - spent a long time planning a return route from the Florida Keys up to the north and out of Florida. Got the weather - was told CAVOK or thereabouts until northern Florida. Took off from KLey West. Got as far as Marathon (which is the next airfield). Noted rather large CBs ahead. Landed, called for an update on the weather. Told CAVOK on route. Hmmm I said, that is strange because there appear to be a whole load of CBs ahead. When they updated their weather radar they agreed with me!!!! So stopped a night there and tried again next day. Storms moving in, were to the north west of Florida. So decided to hotfoot it up into the north of Florida and keep updated on their movement. Got as far as Pensacola I think it was, before deciding those large CBs were getting a little too close. Landed, nightstopped and got out next morning. It was a bargain too - free car, and abouit $20 for a large motel room in town.

tuscan 19th Oct 2008 09:56

I too have diverted to make use of facilities only to find there were none and a quick scamper off to the nearest bushes was the best option.
Flying with a full bladder is one of the most stressful experiences of my life and I will always divert rather than suffer.
At 6ft,4 the thought of using a recepticle in a light aircraft does not appeal to me and I dont think my passengers would appreciate it......

Anyway, the diversion was into Plockton whilst routing to Broadford (Isle of Skye). For those in the know there is only a few minutes between the two but the situation was becoming desperate.:\

Another was into Oban whilst routing from Inverness to Islay, this time it was a squeemish passenger that spent too much time staring into their camera and not enough time looking out at the scenery.:yuk:

S-Works 19th Oct 2008 10:12


Bose - you are not conceeding that you are not up to the pi**ing competition are you?
When it comes to pissing in a plastic bottle, I acknowledge 100% that Peter is the king of the hill.....
:p


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:15.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.