PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Private Flying (https://www.pprune.org/private-flying-63/)
-   -   Doncaster Sheffield - New Class D Airspace (https://www.pprune.org/private-flying/336055-doncaster-sheffield-new-class-d-airspace.html)

ShyTorque 21st Jul 2008 14:42

Doncaster Sheffield - New Class D Airspace
 
AIC 269 (Yellow 269) outlines new Class D airspace, a significant amount of airspace!

So this is why the Northern 1:500,000 CAA chart has been delayed....

Now all they need is for someone to change those blown 13 Amp fuses in the primary radar, the secondary radar, the ATIS machine, the ILS for runway 02, the DME..... etc, etc.

Mark 1 21st Jul 2008 14:51

A lot of people will still be using the 1/2 mill south when routing via Gamston or to Netherthorpe. It'll be interesting to see how many busts they get in the first few months.
Still, it's not likely to cause problems to their 12 IFR movements unless your unlucky.
And don't use the map provided to find your way to Waddington!

soay 21st Jul 2008 16:47


Originally Posted by ShyTorque
Now all they need is for someone to change those blown 13 Amp fuses in the primary radar, the secondary radar, the ATIS machine, the ILS for runway 02, the DME..... etc, etc.

They don't seem to be issuing METARs any more, either.

chevvron 21st Jul 2008 16:54

Why do they need class D for only 12 IFR per day? Surely the figure must be higher than that or DAP would never have allowed it; airfields such as Humberside, Coventry, Norwich must be busier than this.
Don't forget it can be taken away as it was with Southend, Blackpool and Prestwick.

Shunter 21st Jul 2008 17:42

It's sadly true. Just have a look at their website. About 12 aircraft coming in and out every day, and this is the summer season so it appears that includes charter. Huge swathes of Class D which I can't see a single justification for.

flybymike 21st Jul 2008 23:06

It is all part of a master plan to put a complete barrier of MATZs and controlled airspace to the East of the A1 for the entire length of the country.

proplover 23rd Jul 2008 09:28

Heard that Peels are claiming large operating losses at Doncaster, shades of Sheffield. Barton must also be on doggy ground as Peels make it increasingly difficult and costly to operate there, prelude to close it and turn it into an shopping mall a la Sheffield?
The extensive Class D airspace requirements seems totally unjustified unless they plan to take Heathrows overflow!
How can this be justified for so few flights?

GOLF_BRAVO_ZULU 23rd Jul 2008 15:53

Isn't this in the best traditions of Robin Hood? Take from the poor (GA/Sport) and give to the rich (AOC)? There's a flaw there, somewhere.

KeyPilot 23rd Jul 2008 21:13

I can hardly belive this - there are many airports (the ones mentioned above, plus Blackpool, Inverness, ...) which have more public transport movements that Doncaster... what criteria are being applied? This seems ridicuous to me.

bingoboy 23rd Jul 2008 21:30

"what criteria are being applied?"

possibly the ability and willingness to spend large sums of money

NorthSouth 24th Jul 2008 10:49


And don't use the map provided to find your way to Waddington!
Don't use it to fly any of the VFR lanes either cos it advocates flying in the opposite direction to what the Rules of the Air require. And don't use the VRPs cos some of them are so close to final approaches that ATC couldn't possibly route you there and keep safe separation from the IFR traffic on final.

And if you're flying into Doncaster on a schedule from Europe, look out for a split-arse turn and dirty dive from FL110 when you get to 6nm from the field, cos they've designed the controlled airspace in such a way that it's impossible to do normal vectoring to a left base for 20.

Amazing it got past the gatekeepers.

NS

CDH 24th Jul 2008 11:42

bloody hell-
Well we'll have see what happens when you request a transit then...

link here to the AIC
http://www.nats-uk.ead-it.com/aip/cu...8_Y_067_en.pdf

bigfoot01 24th Jul 2008 12:34

I think I already know...
 
...since this announcement all of my flights have told me to stay South and East/North and West, I suspect they are getting practice in for saying stay clear of controlled airspace. Somebody is going to have to help me with the procedure out of Sandtoft, however...

I remember the days of flying out of Sheffield straight through the overhead of Doncaster....

niknak 24th Jul 2008 21:10

I won't say where I work (but several of you will know), but we've many more commercial flights than Doncaster (although not quite as many passengers).
Unit management have been working (alongside and with the support of all of the airline, commercial and the majority of based and local private operators) for a lot longer than DSA to get a much smaller Control Zone.
Although we're hopeful of getting what we've requested within 12 months, there are no guarantees, how DSA got this one through is a total and utter mystery, as has been said, there's no justification for it at all under current DAP "goalposts".

I suspect that many other ATC units are asking the same questions and thinking the same thing.

Bravo73 24th Jul 2008 22:07


Originally Posted by NorthSouth (Post 4285557)
Don't use it to fly any of the VFR lanes either cos it advocates flying in the opposite direction to what the Rules of the Air require.

Huh? :confused: From the diagram, it looks like the S/VFR routes use the 'fly on the right of a line feature' rule.


Originally Posted by NorthSouth (Post 4285557)
And don't use the VRPs cos some of them are so close to final approaches that ATC couldn't possibly route you there and keep safe separation from the IFR traffic on final.

Huh(again)? :confused: All of the VRPs are at least 5nm from the airfield. These will be more than adequate for maintaining separation from inbound traffic. (Unless you plan on flying 4nm orbits, of course... :})


Are you looking at the same plan as the rest of us? ;)

flybymike 24th Jul 2008 22:45

Niknak. Go on, give us a clue as to where the next chunk of Class D is going to be, and how you got the GA contingent to back the idea, ;) or is it just home based GA who are in favour, rather than those who may have to reroute or negotiate a transit?

WorkingHard 25th Jul 2008 07:34

Any refusal for entry/transit of Class D that you genuinely believe is unwarranted and is controlled by NATS should be reported to the NATS safet department with an explanation. This should be done for anything that may impair safety, for example a last minute refusal. Whatever may be thought such matters will be investigated and reported back. For those units that are not NATS then report to DAP in the same way. WE HAVE TO STOP THE UNNECESSARY EXCLUSIVITY and it can only be done within the rules. So everyone get reporting PLEASE!

javelin 25th Jul 2008 11:18

I think we should all make a point of overflying the existing 2 & 2 until the airspace comes into force :E

Lurking123 25th Jul 2008 11:23

I think that is rather irresponsible and antagonistic behaviour. Then again, this is Proone.:bored:

WorkingHard 25th Jul 2008 11:28

Lurking123 I agree that is an irresponsible suggestion and clearly made in haste BUT let us not assume it is the GA pilot who is the antagonist please. Class D is open to all unless SAFETY dictates otherwise then CAT has priority. Of course all flight could file IFR flight plans with the appropriate turning point or waypoint inside the class D!


All times are GMT. The time now is 00:51.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.