PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Private Flying (https://www.pprune.org/private-flying-63/)
-   -   crossing the irish sea at night in SEP - possible? (https://www.pprune.org/private-flying/254095-crossing-irish-sea-night-sep-possible.html)

giloc 30th Nov 2006 13:13


Originally Posted by H Ferguson (Post 2993087)
thank you Consol,
we've also been a Republic since 1949, i find it a bit insulting when people call my country "Eire" ...

Bunreacht na hÉireann must really get up your nose then. From the preamble of the version in English: "We, the people of Éire, ..."

Great thread creep.

H Ferguson 30th Nov 2006 15:42


Originally Posted by giloc (Post 2994974)
Bunreacht na hÉireann must really get up your nose then. From the preamble of the version in English: "We, the people of Éire, ..."

not at all ,but "eire" is sometimes used in a condescending way especially by politicians.

Kirstey i did say a 'bit'...

giloc , great argument name calling.

ok ,rant over

giloc 30th Nov 2006 15:47


Originally Posted by H Ferguson (Post 2995285)
not at all ,but "eire" is sometimes used in a condescending way especially by politicians.

giloc , great argument name calling.

What 'name' is that then?

giloc 30th Nov 2006 16:28


Originally Posted by H Ferguson (Post 2995285)
giloc , great argument name calling.
ok ,rant over


Originally Posted by giloc (Post 2995299)
What 'name' is that then?

HF, I see now - you mean 'thread creep'! In addition to being insulted by someone using one of the names provided for by the Constitution of Ireland, you see the term 'thread creep' and assume it refers to you! I think you're trying too hard to find your insults.

Kirstey 1st Dec 2006 09:22

OK so this more thread creep.

So as a Englishmen.. how am I supposed to refer to the country of which Dublin is the capital?

giloc 1st Dec 2006 10:25


Originally Posted by Kirstey (Post 2996447)
OK so this more thread creep.
So as a Englishmen.. how am I supposed to refer to the country of which Dublin is the capital?

The Constitution of Ireland says that the name of the state is Ireland or Eire. The Republic of Ireland Act 1948, adds Republic of Ireland as a descriptive name. Take your pick.

Note that "Southern Ireland" was the 26-county state envisaged by the Government of Ireland Act 1920, but it never really functioned, and hasn't existed as a political entity since 1922.

dublinpilot 1st Dec 2006 11:37


So as a Englishmen.. how am I supposed to refer to the country of which Dublin is the capital?
Well the 'locals' would just call it "Ireland". If the context required a specific exclusion of Northern Ireland then the 'locals' would refer to it as "The Republic of Ireland" or more commonly, simply as "The Republic".

I don't think most people would take any offence at the country being called "Eire" but it does stand out, and identifies you as British (who isn't used to dealing here) straight away. It's just not a name we use in every day conversation.

For some reason I've never known most British people seem to use the Eire version. I suppose that's the version that is taught in British schools?

dp

H Ferguson 1st Dec 2006 11:53


Originally Posted by Kirstey (Post 2996447)
So as a Englishmen.. how am I supposed to refer to the country of which Dublin is the capital?

Kirstey, Ireland will do fine as this is how nearly everyone refers to it . It would seem that it is a particularly British thing to call Ireland "Eire".

I have absolutely no problem with "Eire " being used as it is used on our stamps and passports. The point i'm trying to make is that "Eire" does have certain condescending connotations dating back to the previous centuary.

[quote:giloc] I think you're trying too hard to find your insults

Giloc i may have taken you up wrong, if so i apologize.

tyro 1st Dec 2006 15:35

I'm British and I was taught it is called Eire by Miss Harris who was quite good at condescending connotations.

H Ferguson 1st Dec 2006 15:43

right, there's only one way to sort this out,

let's hire a plane,

fly across the Irish sea,

at night, :uhoh:

in IMC :ok:

now , who's going to fly the plane :)


crossing the irish sea at night in SEP - possible?

dublinpilot 1st Dec 2006 17:56

I've a better suggestion....

Why don't you guys fly over this direction next summer, we'll show you around, buy you a few drinks, let you chase our women (or men) around Temple Bar, and you see what we call ourselves, when we're all pissed :}

Isn't it time Pprune had an Irish flyin?? :ok:

dp


All times are GMT. The time now is 16:04.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.