Retention of student records
Thread Starter
Retention of student records
Hi Folks
Not sure if this has been discussed before, can't find any reference.
Would a flying school be justified in holding on to a students records when the student was in considerable debt to them and wished to go elsewhere?
Not sure if this has been discussed before, can't find any reference.
Would a flying school be justified in holding on to a students records when the student was in considerable debt to them and wished to go elsewhere?
holding on to a students records when the student was in considerable debt to them
MJ
Join Date: Oct 2012
Location: UK
Posts: 256
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm not going to comment on whether it is justified.
Legally, the training records would fall under the Data Protection Act (the school should be registered as a data controller), and if the student requests all data that is stored about them (electronically or in a filing system) then the school would have to disclose all personal data to the student - which will likely cover the training records themselves. The student would have to pay a maximum £10 fee. The school would then have 40 days to comply with the request, otherwise the school can be prosecuted and fined.
Legally, the training records would fall under the Data Protection Act (the school should be registered as a data controller), and if the student requests all data that is stored about them (electronically or in a filing system) then the school would have to disclose all personal data to the student - which will likely cover the training records themselves. The student would have to pay a maximum £10 fee. The school would then have 40 days to comply with the request, otherwise the school can be prosecuted and fined.
Last edited by wb9999; 28th Feb 2014 at 17:45.
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: In the boot of my car!
Posts: 5,982
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Solar
If you are in considerable debt to them and wish to go elsewhere then why are you reluctant to pay that debt?
If its because you are unhappy with the value for money you have had with them or that they have not met up to what what you have expected, then Surely you should negotiate an agreement with them!
If not they will take you to court to recover debt and costs involved unless you can prove due cause for with holding monies owed!
I think you should sort this out before building a new debt with a new club
i am also surprised that a club would allow you to build a CONSIDERABLE debt?
Pace
If you are in considerable debt to them and wish to go elsewhere then why are you reluctant to pay that debt?
If its because you are unhappy with the value for money you have had with them or that they have not met up to what what you have expected, then Surely you should negotiate an agreement with them!
If not they will take you to court to recover debt and costs involved unless you can prove due cause for with holding monies owed!
I think you should sort this out before building a new debt with a new club
i am also surprised that a club would allow you to build a CONSIDERABLE debt?
Pace
Join Date: Oct 2000
Location: South West UK
Posts: 367
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The logbook is not a record of training, even if signed by a CFI certifying all entries are correct. It is simply a record of flights undertaken - not the same thing at all!
3 Point
3 Point
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: Mare Imbrium
Posts: 638
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The school needs to hold on to a student's records, even after they have gone elsewhere or finished their training in case there is subsequently a dispute. Backside covering if you like - but its the only way a school can show that the student received all the training that was required (in say an accident enquiry).
The student is entitled to have access to the records and to be able to take a copy with them.
The student is entitled to have access to the records and to be able to take a copy with them.
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Earth
Posts: 1,189
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Unless I'm mistaken, you've run up a debt with a flying school. They're in it to make money and they have a client who hasn't paid up.
All they have as a 'persuader' to get you to pay are your records. Can you blame them for holding on to them?!!
Sometimes I can't help feel that some people think that training establishments are there as some romantic entity who are obliged to fulfil their flying dreams.
Sorry, but they're there to make money. You chose to train there, you should pay for what you've had.
I apologise in advance if I've completely (along with others) misread your post.
All they have as a 'persuader' to get you to pay are your records. Can you blame them for holding on to them?!!
Sometimes I can't help feel that some people think that training establishments are there as some romantic entity who are obliged to fulfil their flying dreams.
Sorry, but they're there to make money. You chose to train there, you should pay for what you've had.
I apologise in advance if I've completely (along with others) misread your post.
Thread Starter
Lads
A few seem to have got the wrong idea here, unusual for PPrune I know.
I am not in debt to anybody except the missus and two aeroplanes.
I am a member of a club adjacent to the school in question and as well as knowing the owner very well I also use their aircraft time to time.
In the course of conversation about a certain student the owner told me that he was holding on to a students records as he was owed considerable monies and as has been answered by wb9999 and I suspected it may not be legal, justified is one thing.
I would be of the same opinion as Mach Jump in that I would hold on to them as leverage for as long as possible.
When I was involved in a small garage we would occasionally "retain" the keys of suspect payers as a means of getting them to stump up, if I remember correctly at the time a solicitor mate told me that was illegal which is why I posed the question.
A few seem to have got the wrong idea here, unusual for PPrune I know.
I am not in debt to anybody except the missus and two aeroplanes.
I am a member of a club adjacent to the school in question and as well as knowing the owner very well I also use their aircraft time to time.
In the course of conversation about a certain student the owner told me that he was holding on to a students records as he was owed considerable monies and as has been answered by wb9999 and I suspected it may not be legal, justified is one thing.
I would be of the same opinion as Mach Jump in that I would hold on to them as leverage for as long as possible.
When I was involved in a small garage we would occasionally "retain" the keys of suspect payers as a means of getting them to stump up, if I remember correctly at the time a solicitor mate told me that was illegal which is why I posed the question.
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: In the boot of my car!
Posts: 5,982
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Solar
Whoops
sorry but that is how it read !
In that situation legal or not I would certainly not hand over the records!
Yes force. The student to take legal action and then explain his debt!
I am not a lawyer but if you have not paid for something it's not yours but do not know if this would refer to records!
My question would be why such a huge debt was allowed to build in the first place and why has the student not paid!
But yes legal or not I think I would accidentally loose all the records for now and let him play his hand
Pace
Whoops
sorry but that is how it read !In that situation legal or not I would certainly not hand over the records!
Yes force. The student to take legal action and then explain his debt!
I am not a lawyer but if you have not paid for something it's not yours but do not know if this would refer to records!
My question would be why such a huge debt was allowed to build in the first place and why has the student not paid!
But yes legal or not I think I would accidentally loose all the records for now and let him play his hand
Pace
Join Date: May 2001
Posts: 10,815
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
As per say you can never remove records from a school only copy them.
Having struggled to get the records without debts or anything else untoward it can be a bit of a problem from some schools.
The school has to give copys to the caa if they request them. So they can be used but they don`t like it.
But to be honest without knowing what the debt is...
I have had one student who transfered because the school had issues because all the aircraft were off line due star annual issues. They had been on a course and pid and flown two thirds. Then no flying for over a month so wanted to complete school said course was disccounted. So to transfer they would have to pay an extra 10 quid an hour undiscounted rate so 300. I got the records and the student didn`t pay the 300 but it was a pain.
The school is being daft anyway. They should just start a small claims or get them declared bankrupt.
But maybe the reason they don`t is because they are on rocky ground with the debt anyway.
Always wondered if not paying for flying lessons would be in breach of the ANO ppl payment rules.
Having struggled to get the records without debts or anything else untoward it can be a bit of a problem from some schools.
The school has to give copys to the caa if they request them. So they can be used but they don`t like it.
But to be honest without knowing what the debt is...
I have had one student who transfered because the school had issues because all the aircraft were off line due star annual issues. They had been on a course and pid and flown two thirds. Then no flying for over a month so wanted to complete school said course was disccounted. So to transfer they would have to pay an extra 10 quid an hour undiscounted rate so 300. I got the records and the student didn`t pay the 300 but it was a pain.
The school is being daft anyway. They should just start a small claims or get them declared bankrupt.
But maybe the reason they don`t is because they are on rocky ground with the debt anyway.
Always wondered if not paying for flying lessons would be in breach of the ANO ppl payment rules.
Thread Starter
Cheers Pace
It's a long story and presently there is court case involved so obviously not a lot can be said.
I did ask the owner why he let the debt get so high and basically he was on a bit of a business learning curve as he had only fairly recently started the school.
There is a rogue instructor in the mix as well and involves a student that in his opinion was more capable than he actually demonstrated. Messy to say the least.
It's a long story and presently there is court case involved so obviously not a lot can be said.
I did ask the owner why he let the debt get so high and basically he was on a bit of a business learning curve as he had only fairly recently started the school.
There is a rogue instructor in the mix as well and involves a student that in his opinion was more capable than he actually demonstrated. Messy to say the least.
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: lancs.UK
Age: 77
Posts: 1,191
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
WRT the Motor Trade, AFAIK, Norn Irn is the same as the mainland.
Any vehicle -repairer has a LIEN on the vehicle, that is, he "owns" it until , either he returns it to the owner OR the debt is settled and the Lien satisfied....`the repairer has a duty to look after the car and cannot use it. A sensible operator will make it clear to the debtor that storage charges will be £x per day...charges reaching the value of the vehicle mean statutory notices in the papers and the vehicle sold for market price...after costs and debt satisfaction, the rest is to be held to the account of the debtor.
In the case of training, It would be prudent to establish just how much of the information is subject to Data protection....the Creditor may get a pleasant surprise and find that most is not protected.
I would advise the debtor to settle or make a satisfactory arrangement, within 10 days of (recorded delivery) letter....(make this package look as though it may be the records and the debtor will quite happily sign for it
)
With the threat that, after the allowed time, all personal information will be destroyed.
Unfortunately, the pupil won't care if his intention is to bilk the debtanyway...he'll simply go to another trainer and start again.
I suspect, from your last post, this "training" was, in fact, covert hire,for "jollies"....if he was a genuine student, it looks as though he's wasted the time,if he has to repeat all the lessons again.
Civil court ASAP....prepare the papers and include photocopies with the letter.....he'll know the Trainer means business.....most will fold and pay or arrange to pay, at this point. A CCJ can severely disrupt your life!
Any vehicle -repairer has a LIEN on the vehicle, that is, he "owns" it until , either he returns it to the owner OR the debt is settled and the Lien satisfied....`the repairer has a duty to look after the car and cannot use it. A sensible operator will make it clear to the debtor that storage charges will be £x per day...charges reaching the value of the vehicle mean statutory notices in the papers and the vehicle sold for market price...after costs and debt satisfaction, the rest is to be held to the account of the debtor.
In the case of training, It would be prudent to establish just how much of the information is subject to Data protection....the Creditor may get a pleasant surprise and find that most is not protected.
I would advise the debtor to settle or make a satisfactory arrangement, within 10 days of (recorded delivery) letter....(make this package look as though it may be the records and the debtor will quite happily sign for it
)With the threat that, after the allowed time, all personal information will be destroyed.
Unfortunately, the pupil won't care if his intention is to bilk the debtanyway...he'll simply go to another trainer and start again.
I suspect, from your last post, this "training" was, in fact, covert hire,for "jollies"....if he was a genuine student, it looks as though he's wasted the time,if he has to repeat all the lessons again.
Civil court ASAP....prepare the papers and include photocopies with the letter.....he'll know the Trainer means business.....most will fold and pay or arrange to pay, at this point. A CCJ can severely disrupt your life!
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: In the boot of my car!
Posts: 5,982
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Solar
I certainly would not make the records available to this student until an agreement with him is reached ( it's surprising how computers go wrong and documents get lost )
I do not know what grievances he has but without the documentation at least he will be encouraged to the negotiation table and it is always better to settle!
In future dont let debts grow to such an extent.
It's easy to do having been there with a lot of money owed to me flying private jets by a conman operator but we can only learn
Pace
I certainly would not make the records available to this student until an agreement with him is reached ( it's surprising how computers go wrong and documents get lost )
I do not know what grievances he has but without the documentation at least he will be encouraged to the negotiation table and it is always better to settle!
In future dont let debts grow to such an extent.
It's easy to do having been there with a lot of money owed to me flying private jets by a conman operator but we can only learn
Pace
Last edited by Pace; 1st Mar 2014 at 12:06.
Thread Starter
CS
I wasn't aware that the garage "owned" the vehicle as you say but then it was a very long time ago since I was involved and in those days solicitors were only used in your defense or house purchases. In NI we had more direct ways of sorting out debt!!!!!!
Pace
Just to clarify the monies are not owed to me.
My mate who owns the school in question is holding on to the records and the ex student (and he is a student by the way) is taking him to court over a different matter under the advice from the rogue instructor that I mentioned.
The instructor used to work for him but was let go for various reasons so perhaps you can see that it's not just as a straightforward case that my OP intimated.
I wasn't aware that the garage "owned" the vehicle as you say but then it was a very long time ago since I was involved and in those days solicitors were only used in your defense or house purchases. In NI we had more direct ways of sorting out debt!!!!!!
Pace
Just to clarify the monies are not owed to me.
My mate who owns the school in question is holding on to the records and the ex student (and he is a student by the way) is taking him to court over a different matter under the advice from the rogue instructor that I mentioned.
The instructor used to work for him but was let go for various reasons so perhaps you can see that it's not just as a straightforward case that my OP intimated.
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Scotland
Posts: 381
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If the records are on paper they are absolutely not covered by the data protection act. Strictly speaking they belong to the CAA but the school is under absolutely no obligation to hand the records over unless the courts tell them to other than a moral one, normally it is not an issue but if there is a debt owed the original school should definitely keep a hold of them until they must hand it over.
Join Date: Oct 2012
Location: UK
Posts: 256
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If the records are on paper they are absolutely not covered by the data protection act.
As a data controller for a company, I know that manual records are covered by the data protection act, if they are in a "relevant filing system" - which is anything where records are filed by name (chronological files are not covered). Flying training records will likely be filed by name, and so will be covered by the Data Protection Act.
If you can go straight to a record for an individual (whether paper or electronic), then that is a "relevant filing system" and the school has to registered with the Information Commissioner's Office.
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Scotland
Posts: 381
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
But the information needs to be private information( address, dob etc) student records are not, and you still need to be compelled to provide it which you aren't so unless you are legally compelled to do so, you do not have to give it up.