Oban Crash Inquest
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: long left base EGCC
Posts: 100
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Does anyone know the rate of dissipation of alcohol in the blood per hour after consumption
Let's face it, it's bad airmanship to fly even with a hangover . . . . . let alone no medical, no IMC traing, overweight . . . . . GRRRRRR . . .
I must say I'm pleased to see how firmly and unanimously this sort of behaviour has been condemned in this thread. In other threads involving fatalities there has been evidence of "sensitivities" being rubbed up the wrong ways. We seem to be largely in agreement on this one.
Pompey till I die
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Guildford
Age: 51
Posts: 779
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
turns my stomache
I must say I'm pleased to see how firmly and unanimously this sort of behaviour has been condemned in this thread
I feel for any family members reading this thread.
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Surrey. UK
Age: 55
Posts: 7
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
No sympathy for either "pilot".
In fact, the less of these hare-brained idiots there are in aviation, the safer the rest of us will be. Got their just deserts as far as I'm concerned
Condolences to the surviving family members though
SR
In fact, the less of these hare-brained idiots there are in aviation, the safer the rest of us will be. Got their just deserts as far as I'm concerned
Condolences to the surviving family members though
SR
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: long left base EGCC
Posts: 100
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
They made some mistakes
That must be the grossest understatement I have seen in many years.
This is a free country, we have the right to free speech, I would vigorously defend your right to hold opinions which differ from mine.
But, if you are at least a realist, you would acknowledge that on this occasion you appear to be in a fairly small minority.
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: UK
Posts: 3,325
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
"the AAIB report says - ....If these levels genuinely reflect the amount of alcohol present in the blood at the time of the accident, it is possible that they may have produced some decrement in performance which may have been prejudicial to the safe conduct of the flight."
A lot of posters here have jumped straight onto the alchohol aspects of this accident. Seems to me the AAIB have a far more balanced view than some ranters on here. The limit for flying is very low, and I think the AAIB's comments take this into account.
This pilot (whichever of the two was the pilot) should not have been drinking. But the real cause of this tracgedy is flying in IMC without relevant skills, and then having the rug pulled out from under them by an AI failure in IMC.
The alchohol factor is deplorable, but probaly not too significant here. Being in IMC while unqualified is a known killer - to then lose the primary attitude instrument while in that demanding situation pretty much guarantees a tragic ending.
SSD
A lot of posters here have jumped straight onto the alchohol aspects of this accident. Seems to me the AAIB have a far more balanced view than some ranters on here. The limit for flying is very low, and I think the AAIB's comments take this into account.
This pilot (whichever of the two was the pilot) should not have been drinking. But the real cause of this tracgedy is flying in IMC without relevant skills, and then having the rug pulled out from under them by an AI failure in IMC.
The alchohol factor is deplorable, but probaly not too significant here. Being in IMC while unqualified is a known killer - to then lose the primary attitude instrument while in that demanding situation pretty much guarantees a tragic ending.
SSD
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: long left base EGCC
Posts: 100
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I would say that would be quite relevant
Gentlemen, let's not fall out about the minutiae of this story. It's well known that there is no single cause for any accident, numerous things stack up. But what we have here is a very very sad story which will no doubt become an educational classic case for those whose job it is to impart what is (or, actually, is not) meant by "good airmanship".
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: In the boot of my car!
Posts: 5,982
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Pace
not sure what you mean by this:
Quote:
What happened to the people on the ground to even allow this guy to takeoff with NO regard for his passengers
Are you suggesting that those on the ground should have physically stopped him?
Perhaps the guy behind the bar should not have been pouring drink down his throat..
Perhaps the syndicate members should have eyeballed every members license and medical etc as part of them continuing to be part of the syndicate etc.
Perhaps the CAA should do ramp checks - as is done here in the US by the FAA Inspectors.
Where do you draw the line..
not sure what you mean by this:
Quote:
What happened to the people on the ground to even allow this guy to takeoff with NO regard for his passengers
Are you suggesting that those on the ground should have physically stopped him?
Perhaps the guy behind the bar should not have been pouring drink down his throat..
Perhaps the syndicate members should have eyeballed every members license and medical etc as part of them continuing to be part of the syndicate etc.
Perhaps the CAA should do ramp checks - as is done here in the US by the FAA Inspectors.
Where do you draw the line..
The guy in the left seat had 99mg of alcohol in his system which was twice the driving limit and five times the aviation limit the pilot in the right seat was on the driving limit and two and a half times over the aviation limit.
Surely someone at the airport must have noticed something odd but didnt question or were not alerted.
Maybe the guy in the left seat regarded the woman pilot in the right seat as captain from the right. Maybe she didnt think her alcohol levels were so high.
No medical, no licence a history of medical problems, No instrument capability aircraft overweight???
The aircraft overweight in itself isnt a major problem on the right runway with the C of G correct, the vacuum failure isnt a major problem in alert and well trained IR pilot but looking at the total MIX of this flight the results were almost inevitable and reaks of someone who didnt care a toss.
Pace
Pompey till I die
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Guildford
Age: 51
Posts: 779
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
No difference
But, if you are at least a realist, you would acknowledge that on this occasion you appear to be in a fairly small minority.
I often am on this board. It doesn't really worry me. If I'm the only person human enough to suggest that slagging someone off that's died with comments like:
Got their just deserts as far as I'm concerned
Official PPRuNe Chaplain
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Witnesham, Suffolk
Age: 80
Posts: 3,498
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
We all do partial panel training for the IMC/IR or renewal in the UK, and like to think we'd spot an AI failure. But for a pilot who has never had any IMC training, and is relying on the AI to get through the clouds, I wouldn't be so confident. I think a vacuum pump failure in IMC, for a pilot who is stretching things like that, is one event too far.
This pilot clearly had decided that the normal rules didn't apply to him. He paid the ultimate price for that presumption. I find it very sad, but not surprising.
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Dublin
Posts: 2,547
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
which will no doubt become an educational classic case for those whose job it is to impart what is (or, actually, is not) meant by "good airmanship"
I think people take more (learn more) from an incident where all the decisions in isolation seem reasonable, but overall they build up to be a problem. Perhaps in those types of situation people could see themselves makeing was seem to be reasonable decisions, and learn something from it.
dp
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Aberdeen
Posts: 1,234
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This thread seems to have a lot of comparisons with red top journalism.
The alcohol limit for flying is very low - low enough that natural decomposition can mean you are over the limit. So for those making this noise bear in mind your relatives may read something similar!
The AAIB had to be careful about the alcohol contribution because a very unusual method of determining the alcohol concentration was used. One which could be challenged.
It's negligent to fly if you have health problems? But there were 2 pilots onboard. No one seems too worried about being overweight - possibly because they do it also?
Not having a current licence? Well there are a whole variety of reasons and ways in which that can occur - but again they were 2 pilots onboard.
These people died because the autopilot was flying them and the vacuum pump it was linked to failed - with the terrain and the height they were at they had little time to notice something which has killed a lot of current IR pilots.
Picking up on the perpherial aspects of the accident makes for a great deal of self rightousness but very much misses the point - but I suppose it allows people to feel smug.
The alcohol limit for flying is very low - low enough that natural decomposition can mean you are over the limit. So for those making this noise bear in mind your relatives may read something similar!
The AAIB had to be careful about the alcohol contribution because a very unusual method of determining the alcohol concentration was used. One which could be challenged.
It's negligent to fly if you have health problems? But there were 2 pilots onboard. No one seems too worried about being overweight - possibly because they do it also?
Not having a current licence? Well there are a whole variety of reasons and ways in which that can occur - but again they were 2 pilots onboard.
These people died because the autopilot was flying them and the vacuum pump it was linked to failed - with the terrain and the height they were at they had little time to notice something which has killed a lot of current IR pilots.
Picking up on the perpherial aspects of the accident makes for a great deal of self rightousness but very much misses the point - but I suppose it allows people to feel smug.
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Central London
Posts: 460
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
These people died because the autopilot was flying them and the vacuum pump it was linked to failed - with the terrain and the height they were at they had little time to notice something which has killed a lot of current IR pilots.
Don't blame the vac pump. They took off in to non VFR conditions without the neccesary training and qualifications to cope with the problems that could arise.
No doubt they had employed the same trick in the past but this time fate took a hand.Play with fire and at some time you will get burnt.
I just hope others who fly will the same attitude will think again after reading the AAIB report and the details of the inquest.
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: An island somewhere
Posts: 423
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Don't blame the vac pump. They took off in to non VFR conditions without the neccesary training and qualifications to cope with the problems that could arise.
In my flying lifetime, there have been numerous fatalities following instrument failure in IMC. Whilst in no way suggesting that training, qualifications and being below the legal alcohol limit are unimportant, what is absolutely certain is that they are not sufficient to guarantee a survivable outcome from the type and timing of mechanical failure experienced on this fateful flight.
Two prominent examples (from many) come to mind:
1) The Knight Air Bandeirante that lost one or possibly both artificial horizons two minutes after take-off from Leeds/Bradford (May 1995), and crashed killing all twelve occupants. Two highly trained, qualified and current professional pilots.
2) The Beech Bonanza that had a gyro failure one and half minutes after take off from Linden, New Jersey (November 1999), and crashed a mile from downtown Newark killing all three occupants and injuring twenty five people on the ground. An ATPL pilot with >4,000 hours, flying 200-300 hours p.a. on type and regular acting as instrument instructor in the highly-acclaimed Bonanza Pilot Proficiency Program.
As gasax says:
Picking up on the perpherial aspects of the accident makes for a great deal of self rightousness but very much misses the point
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: UK
Posts: 3,325
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ermmm, well had he abided by the law, he would have been on the ground... and 3 lives would have been saved..
I would say that would be quite relevant.
That's just silly. By that logic if he'd never learned to fly he would have been on the ground. It's of course true like the stuff you quoted, but entirely irrelevant to that accident!
They died because they ventured into IMC without the requisite skills, and the failure of the AI pretty much ensured disaster. The alcohol didn't help. All the rest is fluff.
SSD
I would say that would be quite relevant.
That's just silly. By that logic if he'd never learned to fly he would have been on the ground. It's of course true like the stuff you quoted, but entirely irrelevant to that accident!
They died because they ventured into IMC without the requisite skills, and the failure of the AI pretty much ensured disaster. The alcohol didn't help. All the rest is fluff.
SSD
Last edited by Shaggy Sheep Driver; 21st Nov 2008 at 12:25.
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: In the boot of my car!
Posts: 5,982
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The well known footballer Luke Mc Cormick was jailed for killing two young boys when loosing control of his car. His Alcohol level was twice the drink driving limit or the same as the left seat pilot of this aircraft.
To fly an aircraft in IMC while qualified to do so is demanding enough add a possible vacuum failure and the pilot would have to be quick thinking, well co ordinated and current to stay on top of the situation.
Put a drunk pilot at the controls, one who is not even qualified in instrument flying and who no longer holds a medical or licence???
Had he survived the crash I am sure he too would have been imprisoned for killing his passengers.
Pace
To fly an aircraft in IMC while qualified to do so is demanding enough add a possible vacuum failure and the pilot would have to be quick thinking, well co ordinated and current to stay on top of the situation.
Put a drunk pilot at the controls, one who is not even qualified in instrument flying and who no longer holds a medical or licence???
Had he survived the crash I am sure he too would have been imprisoned for killing his passengers.
Pace
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: An island somewhere
Posts: 423
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
His Alcohol level was twice the drink driving limit or the same as the left seat pilot of this aircraft [my bold]
Pace, surely it's incumbent on those making strong allegations to at least get their facts straight?
