PPL Airlaw?!?!?!?!
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Urf
Age: 55
Posts: 31
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
God, the air law was painful....
There are two consoling factors.. firstly, everything they ask is in the book. Know the book & you're OK - mightn't seem like much but its something! Secondly, the books (& exams) get better & more fun after that one.
There are two consoling factors.. firstly, everything they ask is in the book. Know the book & you're OK - mightn't seem like much but its something! Secondly, the books (& exams) get better & more fun after that one.
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2008
Location: UK
Posts: 525
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks
Thanks to all - good to know I'm not in a minority. Aside from the actual need for all the Chicago Convention stuff - having now read the up to date revision (think I was using a 1995 book initially from the local library as I wrongly assumed Air Law couln't have changed that much), it now makes much more sense as a lot of the ICAO stuff wasn't included. Future learning for others - get the up-to-date material!!!
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Aberdeen
Posts: 1,234
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Know of anyone who gave up because of the exams? No. And never heard of such a person, some who have struggled but none gave up.
We are a classic 'self-selecting' population. Because we 'want' to fly, we are motivated and will put up with an amazing amount of aggravation to do that. Which has a lot to do with why flying clubs are so rubbish at any sort of customer care and why we are prepared to put up with the 'word game' approach to the exams.
It's just a bit of a shame that when people have overcome all these hurdles and got a PPL they usually find the continuing aggravation more than they want to put up with.........
We are a classic 'self-selecting' population. Because we 'want' to fly, we are motivated and will put up with an amazing amount of aggravation to do that. Which has a lot to do with why flying clubs are so rubbish at any sort of customer care and why we are prepared to put up with the 'word game' approach to the exams.
It's just a bit of a shame that when people have overcome all these hurdles and got a PPL they usually find the continuing aggravation more than they want to put up with.........
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: N Ireland
Age: 55
Posts: 133
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
3 questions wrong across all 7 exams
Just done Nav with just the one question wrong, that's 2 questions wrong in 4 exams so far.
I have been using the online practice exams at airquiz.com as well as the confuser. So far I have found:
Air Law: Questions were if anything more like those on airquiz. Easy enough if you know the source material, although (as has been stated) watch the dodgy wording. Oh, and yes you do need to read the supplementary material.
Met: Questions were very similar to those in the confuser. Airquiz examples were a little too easy I thought, actual exam was trickier.
Human Perf: All examples were easy, exam also easy if you know the source material.
Nav: Again the confuser seemed to have the more representative questions. The first 10-12 questions were based around planning a flight with 2 legs and an alternate. You spend the first 15 minutes marking the route on the chart (which was provided) and don't actually get any questions answered in this time. During the Nav exam, as for Met, I found that there were slight time pressures (i.e. I barely had enough time to check my answers).
The worst thing about the exams, IMHO, is the amount of study time required, sometimes it's not easy for me to juggle it with family and all the other stuff I'm involved in
. There's a lot of reading, also I'm not blessed with a photographic memory so usually have to work quite hard at remembering it.But it's still progessing as quickly as the flying at the moment, partly thanks to 'summer' 2008
.Gav.
www.madgav.org
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: N Ireland
Age: 55
Posts: 133
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Being a 40 something
the long one at the end that thinks you should take-off and battle with thunderstorms
. Got it right in the real exam though.......All the best for the 2nd part of your skills test, I seem to remember that you soloed just a few days before me or something, obviously you've made a bit more progress than I have since then
Because we 'want' to fly, we are motivated and will put up with an amazing amount of aggravation to do that
get the up-to-date material!!!
Passed my air law a few weeks ago, first go, 95%. First exam I have done for twenty years, almost to the day, although before that my life for ten years consisted of little else. I still occasionally wake-up in the morning panicing that I'm not ready for my university finals!
Don't know whether this will help anyone else but this was my method for Air Law:
- Buy the AFE book, 2007 edition (unless a 2008 one comes out!). I bought another book from a different publisher as well as the AFE one and the other one was out-of-date.
- Read it as many times as you can stand, in chunks small enough that you don't doze off. Mark-up the key facts and also cross-refer the airspace and VMC minima diagrams and text.
- Do all the practice questions in the book. They are nothing like the exam but make you think and hence really learn.
- When you have mastered the above steps, buy the exam secrets book. Do the questions and study the answer explanations until you have them clear. Do not do this stage first as it will teach you enough to pass the exam but nowhere near enough to be safe let alone legal.
Good luck
Joe
Don't know whether this will help anyone else but this was my method for Air Law:
- Buy the AFE book, 2007 edition (unless a 2008 one comes out!). I bought another book from a different publisher as well as the AFE one and the other one was out-of-date.
- Read it as many times as you can stand, in chunks small enough that you don't doze off. Mark-up the key facts and also cross-refer the airspace and VMC minima diagrams and text.
- Do all the practice questions in the book. They are nothing like the exam but make you think and hence really learn.
- When you have mastered the above steps, buy the exam secrets book. Do the questions and study the answer explanations until you have them clear. Do not do this stage first as it will teach you enough to pass the exam but nowhere near enough to be safe let alone legal.
Good luck
Joe
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: France
Posts: 481
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If you know the topic properly, you'll pass the exams.
If you want to find a short-cut, good luck to you, but you'll be found out later in your 'career'.
Most of these daft books are about learning the short cuts without studying the topic.
/Rant ON
Air travel operates as it does now because of ICAO. Without the Freedoms we would not fly as we do. Without Chicago and the Annexes we would not fly safely.
Do credit to the folk who sorted this out with blood, sweat, and tears, and at least humble yourselves enough to find out about it...
...because none of you will ever, ever, achieve anything like what they did...
/Rant OFF
If you want to find a short-cut, good luck to you, but you'll be found out later in your 'career'.
Most of these daft books are about learning the short cuts without studying the topic.
/Rant ON
Air travel operates as it does now because of ICAO. Without the Freedoms we would not fly as we do. Without Chicago and the Annexes we would not fly safely.
Do credit to the folk who sorted this out with blood, sweat, and tears, and at least humble yourselves enough to find out about it...
...because none of you will ever, ever, achieve anything like what they did...
/Rant OFF
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: France
Posts: 481
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
G-EMMA, you said
Well, so do I. In particular I like to moan about people who think that 20 minutes with a book of questions and answers should qualify them to fly.
I quite like to moan about folk who don't know why aviation has been breaking down borders and barriers for years.
I love a moan about those who can't be bothered to research why commercial aviation achieves such impressively low levels of risk around the world.
So sorry to introduce a spot of wheat to this particular chav - sorry, chaff - conversation!
I like a good moan about the exams.
I quite like to moan about folk who don't know why aviation has been breaking down borders and barriers for years.
I love a moan about those who can't be bothered to research why commercial aviation achieves such impressively low levels of risk around the world.
So sorry to introduce a spot of wheat to this particular chav - sorry, chaff - conversation!
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: N Ireland
Age: 55
Posts: 133
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
OK, this is a bit OT, for which I apologise to the OP (I think this thread's run its course anyway & I don't think it's worth starting a new one), but today's flying activity was a wee bit more 'interesting' than usual:
Link
Quite an experience for a first landaway
Link
Quite an experience for a first landaway
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: EuroGA.org
Posts: 13,787
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The gotchas with these 'duration of' questions is that some entitlements run for X days, some run for X months, and some run for X calendar months. On the last one, an entitlement obtained on say the 15th of the month runs until the last day of the month of expiry. A real sod to remember. Especially as some of the 'X days' entitlements don't start counting the days until the first day after the entitlement was obtained.
Of course the questions are phrased to trap the common and easy misunderstandings. The #1 job with CAA exams especially is to read the Q several times.
Of course the questions are phrased to trap the common and easy misunderstandings. The #1 job with CAA exams especially is to read the Q several times.
Guest
Posts: n/a
The original question was about whether there was a point to having to learn about ICAO and other 'obscure' topics.
I'm with frontlefthamster on this. As a PPL, you'll proibably only have to pass an exam on Air Law once and thereafter your licence will qualify you to fly throughout pretty much any part of the world. Many countries have their own local variations to international standards but in order to understand how these variations affect you it's important to know what the baseline is (or, at least, where to look it up). I guess the exam is an attempt to ensure that, maybe 20 years after you took the exam, you'll have a chance at finding some information that has suddenly become important.
Sadly it doesn't seem to work because it it quite clear from other threads, for example the one which started on RT phraseology, that many people don't understand the basic ICAO rules and to appreciate what are local variations and thus are unable to pursue a reasoned discussion on the subject.
I'm with frontlefthamster on this. As a PPL, you'll proibably only have to pass an exam on Air Law once and thereafter your licence will qualify you to fly throughout pretty much any part of the world. Many countries have their own local variations to international standards but in order to understand how these variations affect you it's important to know what the baseline is (or, at least, where to look it up). I guess the exam is an attempt to ensure that, maybe 20 years after you took the exam, you'll have a chance at finding some information that has suddenly become important.
Sadly it doesn't seem to work because it it quite clear from other threads, for example the one which started on RT phraseology, that many people don't understand the basic ICAO rules and to appreciate what are local variations and thus are unable to pursue a reasoned discussion on the subject.
Join Date: May 2008
Location: UK
Posts: 1,365
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I agree that the licence is an international one, and therefore you should learn international rules. However, the syllabus is full of which convention decided what, and what would you find in the AIP.
Ultimately, the AIP and AIC are reference documents. I think you should be able to take them into the exam, and they ask you specific rules to show you know how to use the reference material correctly and not misenturprate it (i'm sure the spelling police will be onto me about that one)
knowing that something was decided in tokyo in 1963 doesnt really help that much.
Ultimately, the AIP and AIC are reference documents. I think you should be able to take them into the exam, and they ask you specific rules to show you know how to use the reference material correctly and not misenturprate it (i'm sure the spelling police will be onto me about that one)
knowing that something was decided in tokyo in 1963 doesnt really help that much.
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Yorkshire
Posts: 1,040
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Whislt exams are well and good and show someones ability to take info onboard they are no indicator about how the person is going to perform in the role.
I get a lot of Grads come through my Dept at work and you would be surprised how many havent got an ounce of common sense! I had a Grad with a 1st in Maths from Oxford nearly have a breakdown on me after just 4 weeks as he was dealing with situations where he couldnt find the answer in one of his textbooks!!!!
So whilst 98% in exams may be nice, you may be worse at the actual role (pilot/engineer/doctor/etc) than the person who just scraped through. So knowing 98% of jack sh1t doesnt really come into it if you can't practically deliver the role required of you.
J.
I get a lot of Grads come through my Dept at work and you would be surprised how many havent got an ounce of common sense! I had a Grad with a 1st in Maths from Oxford nearly have a breakdown on me after just 4 weeks as he was dealing with situations where he couldnt find the answer in one of his textbooks!!!!
So whilst 98% in exams may be nice, you may be worse at the actual role (pilot/engineer/doctor/etc) than the person who just scraped through. So knowing 98% of jack sh1t doesnt really come into it if you can't practically deliver the role required of you.
J.
Guest
Posts: n/a
So whilst 98% in exams may be nice, you may be worse at the actual role (pilot/engineer/doctor/etc) than the person who just scraped through. So knowing 98% of jack sh1t doesnt really come into it if you can't practically deliver the role required of you.
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: EuroGA.org
Posts: 13,787
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The skills test does not include an oral exam, so why have the theory with all the rubbish in it?
The FAA licenses include on oral exam (2-3 hours in some cases) but then the theory is much more sensible.
The FAA licenses include on oral exam (2-3 hours in some cases) but then the theory is much more sensible.
I've got my Air Law exam on Monday - I've been putting it off and off. Would anyone who has done it recently have any tips further to the above?
I've read the book and done all the confuser questions but I'm still a bit unsure. Not the most exciting subject is it?
I've read the book and done all the confuser questions but I'm still a bit unsure. Not the most exciting subject is it?
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Amsterdam
Posts: 4,598
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
When in doubt, the correct answer is either the longest answer, with the most legalese, or C.
If you consistently score good marks with the confuser, then don't sweat. Just get up there and do it.
If you consistently score good marks with the confuser, then don't sweat. Just get up there and do it.
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: EGBB
Age: 36
Posts: 22
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Had mine today scored 82%
Was pretty straight forward!
I read the Jeremy Pratt book and also had the confuser
I made a few silly mistakes which COULD of cost me a pass
So make sure you read the questions carefully!
Conk
Was pretty straight forward!
I read the Jeremy Pratt book and also had the confuser
I made a few silly mistakes which COULD of cost me a pass
So make sure you read the questions carefully!
Conk