PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   The Pacific: General Aviation & Questions (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions-91/)
-   -   Dick Smith's open letter to John Anderson (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions/639745-dick-smiths-open-letter-john-anderson.html)

Dick Smith 8th Apr 2021 04:01

Dick Smith's open letter to John Anderson
 
I was interviewed by Laura Jayes on Sky News today in relation to my open letter to John Anderson. It looks as if Bloggsie wrote her introductory piece.

Here is a link to the interview.

mcoates 8th Apr 2021 04:49

To me, it sounded like she was very much against you before you even started.....

Lookleft 8th Apr 2021 04:56

Or maybe she has done her research.

Dick Smith 8th Apr 2021 04:56

Yep. Mcoates. But I don’t mind that.

The more open communication about Airspace safety the greater the likelihood that someone in the Canberra bureaucracy will say. “ hold on - this is ridiculous- we should do something about this”

And then ATCs will not have to sit and watch while planes collide and people die!

Cat3508 8th Apr 2021 06:25

"where airline aircrafts":ugh:

Squawk7700 8th Apr 2021 07:12

It was a good interview.

She had done her research and so had you and you rebutted accordingly, adding value to your arguments. Well done.

She has an action to talk to the current transport minister, so let’s see what happens there.

Capn Bloggs 8th Apr 2021 09:18


It looks as if Bloggsie wrote her introductory piece.
Wasn't mine, Dick, I don't even call them planes, let alone aircrafts.

Traffic lights for all intersections NOW!, I hear him scream. Or do I? :cool:

Lookleft 8th Apr 2021 23:35


The more open communication about Airspace safety the greater the likelihood that someone in the Canberra bureaucracy will say. “ hold on - this is ridiculous- we should do something about this”
Why would they start to change their thinking now?

Dick Smith 9th Apr 2021 02:24

Four fatalities at Mangalore?

Lookleft 9th Apr 2021 02:31

Were there any RPT aircraft involved?

Dick Smith 9th Apr 2021 02:52

No. But four professional pilots.

Could be RPT at Ballina next time?

Lookleft 9th Apr 2021 03:11

Thats my point. Until it is RPT nothing will change. They have already had enough evidence that see and avoid does not work at Ballina yet they keep fiddling at the edges. They put in a fire station, now its a 15nm CTAF. The Canberra bureaucracy, that even you were unable to bring to heel, will continue to accept that there is no problem that a little tinkering won't fix. Its only when the TV news has wall to wall coverage of the burnt wreckage of a (insert airline of choice) then will action be taken.

Styx75 9th Apr 2021 08:45


Originally Posted by Lookleft (Post 11024795)
15nm CTAF.

it's a whole new type of airspace they've created, an MBZ.

Now when I'm doing flight reviews I give my usual spiel about mandatory CTAF radio calls, and then finish with "except when you're within 15nm of Ballina..."

buckshot1777 9th Apr 2021 09:54


Originally Posted by Styx75 (Post 11024923)
it's a whole new type of airspace they've created, an MBZ.

Its a Broadcast Area (which have been around in various places for many years) not an MBZ (which disappeared many years ago), nor is it a CTAF.

Geez - don't confuse your students any more than they probably already are :)

Styx75 9th Apr 2021 11:38


Originally Posted by buckshot1777 (Post 11024976)
Geez - don't confuse your students any more than they probably already are :)

Doubt they'd be confused by the name given to it. What it's requirements are though however...

the_rookie 11th Apr 2021 13:43

Does Dick Smith always talk in 3rd person

Dick Smith 15th Apr 2021 04:38

For those who may be interested in reading the open letter to John Anderson, here is a link: https://aopa.com.au/dick-smith-issues-open-letter-to-former-aviation-minister-mr-john-anderson/?fbclid=IwAR1ENddU79-pejV640qjvCLZ4lMH29JNtYIm3btzAetvhrJX3LpX1_SnWOk

One of the prime reasons I have written the letter is because it will go into the aviation archives, and when future generations want to understand why GA in Australia was destroyed, they will have the information.





missy 15th Apr 2021 07:13

Dick, I understood that Anderson's directive to ASA regarding RADAR Class C airspace was issued on the understanding that you would withdraw your threat to stand against him in seat of Gwydir.
Is this correct or was I mis-led?

CaptainMidnight 15th Apr 2021 09:03


Originally Posted by missy (Post 11028477)
Dick, I understood that Anderson's directive to ASA regarding RADAR Class C airspace was issued on the understanding that you would withdraw your threat to stand against him in seat of Gwydir.
Is this correct or was I mis-led?

An "Advanced Search" on this site's "PPRuNe Worldwide" forum for the keyword "Gwydir" might turn up some interesting threads around the early 2004 period.

Dick Smith 15th Apr 2021 09:45

Missy. Great story! But it’s not true.

The radar directive was to get the E back in above the D.

Just like Broome! And all of the USA.


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:24.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.