PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   The Pacific: General Aviation & Questions (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions-91/)
-   -   Incident at Mount Gambier (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions/616172-incident-mount-gambier.html)

Desert Flower 9th Dec 2018 08:01


Originally Posted by Cloudee (Post 10331539)
https://www.atsb.gov.au/media/577203...-072-final.pdf
A Navajo touched its prop tips on the Birdsville runway causing similar damage when it tried to land wheels up and then did a circuit to land with the wheels in the correct position, 4/7/16.

I seem to remember a Chieftain with bent props at YMRE a few years back too. Also think there might have been a larger aircraft that suffered similar damage.

DF.

Bend alot 9th Dec 2018 08:08

A CAsA Bonanza at Serpentine - but elected to fly back to Jandakot.

1/2 bank 9th Dec 2018 08:30

YMTG Speci at the time...not a great look
 
speci ymtg 080100z auto 17011kt 9999 // ovc004 16/15 q1018
speci ymtg 080130z auto 18011kt 9999 // ovc003 16/15 q1018
speci ymtg 080200z auto 18012kt 9999 // ovc004 16/15 q1018

Bend alot 9th Dec 2018 08:42


Originally Posted by 1/2 bank (Post 10331572)
speci ymtg 080100z auto 17011kt 9999 // ovc004 16/15 q1018
speci ymtg 080130z auto 18011kt 9999 // ovc003 16/15 q1018
speci ymtg 080200z auto 18012kt 9999 // ovc004 16/15 q1018

Photo looks much better. One hell of a go around. Looks like the L/H eng might have a little bent shaft and let oil out.

A good recovery from a strong x wind.

Xatrix 9th Dec 2018 08:52

Strong crosswind?? 10kts straight down the runway

Bend alot 9th Dec 2018 09:05


Originally Posted by Xatrix (Post 10331585)
Strong crosswind?? 10kts straight down the runway


"Bad weather, strong crosswind - totally stuffed up!"

Quote as above.

On eyre 9th Dec 2018 09:13

Bend alot- maybe DF got it wrong with that quote.

compressor stall 9th Dec 2018 09:14

Hmmm,

Maybe Bendalot, but look at a photo of a king air front on. Tell me with wheels down, what AoB would be have to be to touch the prop on one side - and not damage the wingtip - AND also then repeat on the other? Geometrically I don't think it is even possible (although I am not sure what diameter prop this has). My money is on a wheels up after a poor weather approach to minima realised at the last second and went around and the props hit. Only just touched though as the antenna is still ok.

Either way, poor bugger. Hope s/he's doing OK tonight. Do you still get a gig with QF these days once you've done a wheels up?

nomorecatering 9th Dec 2018 09:17

Did something like this happen?

Desert Flower 9th Dec 2018 09:18


Originally Posted by On eyre (Post 10331601)
Bend alot- maybe DF got it wrong with that quote.

That was what our source told me - blame him!

DF.

AmarokGTI 9th Dec 2018 09:19

Ok look. I admit that my flying skills are not always perfect, but I would have to suggest that if you’re doing that much damage with the wind light and literally straight down the runway you shouldn’t be in the skies. Not to mention the lack of professionalism landing below minima. (Could argue that once the damage was done it was essential to bust the minima to land ASAP, but hard to argue that beforehand). As a MTG regular I know that it can hang around for a fair while. As a former B200 driver (very well behaved aircraft) I find this quite bizarre.

Desert Flower 9th Dec 2018 09:21


Originally Posted by compressor stall (Post 10331603)
Either way, poor bugger. Hope s/he's doing OK tonight. Do you still get a gig with QF these days once you've done a wheels up?

He's way past the age to get into QF!

DF.

Bend alot 9th Dec 2018 09:23


Originally Posted by compressor stall (Post 10331603)
Hmmm,

Maybe Bendalot, but look at a photo of a king air front on. Tell me with wheels out, what AoB would be have to be to touch the prop on one side - and not damage the wingtip - AND also then repeat on the other? Geometrically is it even possible (although I am not sure what diameter prop this has).

Either way, poor bugger. Hope s/he's doing OK tonight. Do you still get a gig with QF these days once you've done a wheels up?


That mate is a prop strike.

Wing tip strike?? that is why my first comment was about flaps.

The stub wing (till nacelles) on a king air is pretty flat - then the wing gets higher from the ground as it goes out/bd - so the lowest point of wing is in/db flaps if extended - then the engine nacelles - wing tips a few feet higher than that.

https://www.ctsys.com/blog/entry/cts...-air-b200.html

On eyre 9th Dec 2018 09:28

****ty weather, concentrating on the approach, below minima, forgot the wheels, prop strike, go-around with Qtips now installed, low level return to RWY 18, wheels down this time, oh **** sadly !!

compressor stall 9th Dec 2018 09:28

Yes, a prop strike with a wheels up landing and go around as the props touched. I was editing as you were replying Bendalot.

Cloudee 9th Dec 2018 09:45


Originally Posted by On eyre (Post 10331617)
****ty weather, concentrating on the approach, below minima, forgot the wheels, prop strike, go-around with Qtips now installed, low level return to RWY 18, wheels down this time, oh **** !!

I think PPRuNe has solved another one! Wonder how long it will take and how much it will cost for the ATSB to come to the same conclusion?

outnabout 9th Dec 2018 10:41

Will this be the end of a career?

Mach E Avelli 9th Dec 2018 10:58

.......more like the end of the company!

Desert Flower 9th Dec 2018 12:07

Same pilot forgot to put the wheels down on a DC3 at YPOD many years ago....

DF.

Outtahere 9th Dec 2018 18:48

Two pilots on board, one under training/ supervision at the time.


All times are GMT. The time now is 06:29.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.