Paul Phelan 's latest
bias....??
As well as all the above, in AAT Quadrio they asked that one person be set aside, as he is a mate of one of the CASA persons.!
So even if he is as clean as the driven snow, there is a conflict of interest...and a perception of bias...which there was,IMHO
Same with the rotten CASA system where CASA persons "investigate" other CASA persons. Like the CASA newby/ex cop that "dealt " with my case, isnt likely to sh*t in his new nest and find against his colleagues.
So he didnt... failing to reveal relevant facts, a half arsed "investigation", and a bit of verballing thrown in.! Whatever it takes.
Funny isnt it, that 2 other non CASA investigations found in my favour!
What a gutless, spineless bunch of mfs run the rotten place
So even if he is as clean as the driven snow, there is a conflict of interest...and a perception of bias...which there was,IMHO
Same with the rotten CASA system where CASA persons "investigate" other CASA persons. Like the CASA newby/ex cop that "dealt " with my case, isnt likely to sh*t in his new nest and find against his colleagues.
So he didnt... failing to reveal relevant facts, a half arsed "investigation", and a bit of verballing thrown in.! Whatever it takes.
Funny isnt it, that 2 other non CASA investigations found in my favour!
What a gutless, spineless bunch of mfs run the rotten place
The charade falls over if it becomes too obvious and then they have to escalate to more powerful, but higher risk measures. Sometimes winning a battle is less important than...
I can tell you're part of 'the Establishment', Clinton, because you've just used the first method that they use - i.e. attempt to discredit those who refuse to acquiesce.
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: on the edge
Posts: 823
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
So what's the explanation for the AAT decisions that go against CASA?
The charade falls over if it becomes too obvious and then they have to escalate to more powerful, but higher risk measures. Sometimes winning a battle is less important than...
It's the Illuminati working behind the scenes.
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Alabama, then Wyoming, then Idaho and now staying with Kharon on Styx houseboat
Age: 61
Posts: 1,437
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Aagh yes and right on cue in comes blackhead, always the quintessential smart arse who has been deluded into believing he is somewhat of a gift to aviation and know's eveything, but in reality knows little.
If you lived your life looking outside of the box for once you would see some interesting things in this world.
Small minded insults by a perpetuator of ignorance and arrogance. I am hoping you are either a young bloke with lots of finger burning lessons yet to come in life, or you are you are an older bloke with stacks of money invested in super because the next 12-24 months will see a lot of that stripped away, and that is
If you lived your life looking outside of the box for once you would see some interesting things in this world.
You're at Byron with Gobbleduck, fess up now, too many bongs before dinner.
bh & gb do you guys follow each other around hijacking threads so you can sling off at each other?
Meanwhile old mate John is sitting up on the tablelands wondering if he will ever get his helo license back!
How would you feel if all of sudden you had to go an pick strawberrys, grind coffee or lug around 60 kg bunches of bananas? There the sort of jobs you do when you are trying to get a gig flying....sheeesh get a life you blokes (or gals)!
Meanwhile old mate John is sitting up on the tablelands wondering if he will ever get his helo license back!
How would you feel if all of sudden you had to go an pick strawberrys, grind coffee or lug around 60 kg bunches of bananas? There the sort of jobs you do when you are trying to get a gig flying....
sheeesh get a life you blokes (or gals)!
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Alabama, then Wyoming, then Idaho and now staying with Kharon on Styx houseboat
Age: 61
Posts: 1,437
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hijack is a very strong word.
For the sake of peace I shall desist from sparring with the other person.
For the record I strongly support John, he has been landed a knockout punch and the powers at play in Canberra have no conscience or remorse for the untold pain and distress they have caused this bloke.
Hold your head up high John, at least you can go to sleep at night with a clean conscience, dignity and a measure of humanity about you. Hang in there.
For the sake of peace I shall desist from sparring with the other person.
For the record I strongly support John, he has been landed a knockout punch and the powers at play in Canberra have no conscience or remorse for the untold pain and distress they have caused this bloke.
Hold your head up high John, at least you can go to sleep at night with a clean conscience, dignity and a measure of humanity about you. Hang in there.
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Australia
Age: 51
Posts: 931
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Back on topic................................ (probably against the wishes of some)
The way the AAT operates (done some reading independant of this place, as I was interested).
The politicians could pass a law similar. A person unfit..(to walk the streets)
When it looks unfavourable in court, the cops could then take you to the AAT, not prove the case and have you locked up....for life using Mr Quadrio's experience as benchmark.
Might be a positive way to clear the streets of kiddie touchers, rapist, and the unwashed.....probably half the people in here also.
No-one would be safe.
Imagine that huh.
The way the AAT operates (done some reading independant of this place, as I was interested).
The politicians could pass a law similar. A person unfit..(to walk the streets)
When it looks unfavourable in court, the cops could then take you to the AAT, not prove the case and have you locked up....for life using Mr Quadrio's experience as benchmark.
Might be a positive way to clear the streets of kiddie touchers, rapist, and the unwashed.....probably half the people in here also.
No-one would be safe.
Imagine that huh.
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Wentworth
Age: 59
Posts: 212
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Mistake may have been a better word.
AAT is usually for matters where the outcome is not as critical as losing your profession.
I wonder if there are still other avenues he can use to get a speedier solution?
AAT is usually for matters where the outcome is not as critical as losing your profession.
I wonder if there are still other avenues he can use to get a speedier solution?
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: on the edge
Posts: 823
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Mistake may have been a better word.
The question is, should the AAT exist at all...?
In my opinion, the AAT only has jurisdiction if you consent to its jurisdiction. If you don't the only legal recourse available to the authorities is a court with a jury.
Of course, why let a bunch of time-honoured law get in the road of a legal prosecution...?
Magna Carta - clause 39
No free man shall be seized or imprisoned, or stripped of his rights or possessions, or outlawed or exiled, or deprived of his standing in any other way, nor will we proceed with force against him, or send others to do so, except by the lawful judgment of his equals or by the law of the land
No free man shall be seized or imprisoned, or stripped of his rights or possessions, or outlawed or exiled, or deprived of his standing in any other way, nor will we proceed with force against him, or send others to do so, except by the lawful judgment of his equals or by the law of the land
Of course, why let a bunch of time-honoured law get in the road of a legal prosecution...?
or is it part of the process one has to go through prior to appeal to a higher court?
Sure you can apply for legal aid and probably get it, but your level of legal representation drops off with what you can afford (or can't afford).
Maybe John could try the Commonwealth Ombudsman with letters of concern from members of the aviation industry i.e. 'all of us'!
AAT....
Can it be bypassed? Was there another way open to J Quadrio to ask to have his licence reinstated after the DPP decided not to proceed.? Why does one have to ask the AAT?
A court order? or an application to a Fed. Magistrates court?
The AAT ... like so many things that get coughed up to do one thing, has morphed into something else. More like a kangaroo court or starchamber.. certainly not a proper court with rules of evidence, and decisions beyond reasonable doubt.
Justice (sic) must be done and seen to be done. That certainly hasnt occured in this event. Far from it.... a life sentence.! Its bullsh*t!
Quadrio wins the DPP battle but the AAT evens the score by letting CASA win the war. In a most disgraceful way.
WTF are this country's bureaucracies developing into??
"Public"service as a fascist state? Some serious changes are needed here.
A court order? or an application to a Fed. Magistrates court?
The AAT ... like so many things that get coughed up to do one thing, has morphed into something else. More like a kangaroo court or starchamber.. certainly not a proper court with rules of evidence, and decisions beyond reasonable doubt.
Justice (sic) must be done and seen to be done. That certainly hasnt occured in this event. Far from it.... a life sentence.! Its bullsh*t!
Quadrio wins the DPP battle but the AAT evens the score by letting CASA win the war. In a most disgraceful way.
WTF are this country's bureaucracies developing into??
"Public"service as a fascist state? Some serious changes are needed here.
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Wentworth
Age: 59
Posts: 212
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The Commonwealth Ombudsman sounds a good start.
Which AAT - Qld?
What does the Ombudsman need to investigate?
What does the diagramme in AndyRR's #79 tell us?
Is 62 deg excessive?
Was that an appropriate angle for carrying tourists?
Was there another way to avoid the birds?
Does the video indicate that was the steepest angle?
I've seen a few people fail to excite Ombudsmen, who have a big workload, so can't spend the time conducting an FBI type forensic investigation.
On the other hand there are a lot of good brains on here, strategic, technical and legal, and if John agrees, could probably present a brief to the Ombudsman which would allow him to make a quick decision that a Department got out of line.
Which AAT - Qld?
What does the Ombudsman need to investigate?
What does the diagramme in AndyRR's #79 tell us?
Is 62 deg excessive?
Was that an appropriate angle for carrying tourists?
Was there another way to avoid the birds?
Does the video indicate that was the steepest angle?
I've seen a few people fail to excite Ombudsmen, who have a big workload, so can't spend the time conducting an FBI type forensic investigation.
On the other hand there are a lot of good brains on here, strategic, technical and legal, and if John agrees, could probably present a brief to the Ombudsman which would allow him to make a quick decision that a Department got out of line.
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: on the edge
Posts: 823
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Of course, why let a bunch of time-honoured law get in the road of a legal prosecution...?
It is available in modern legislation only to the extent that the particular soveriegn state has allowed.
Numerous attempts have been made by litigants, many of them representing themselves, to argue that local legislation that conflicts with or which seems to override Magna Carta is invalid. This argument seems to be based on the premise that the fundamental constitutional character of Magna Carta operates as if it were a constitutionally entrenched provision to which all local enactments are obliged to conform.
Read more here
The Icon of Liberty: The Status and Role of Magna Carta in Australian and New Zealand Law - [2000] MULR 34; (2000) 24 Melbourne University Law Review 866
Last edited by blackhand; 16th Nov 2011 at 20:16.
