PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Meteor Accident Statistics (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/70987-meteor-accident-statistics.html)

luffers79 8th October 2006 13:06

Porky Munro.
 
Yes, I believe he was !

A2QFI 8th October 2006 16:15

"Porky" Munro
 
Porky was in RAFO (then SOAF) from about 1976 and started as Sqn Ldr (Ops) Flighters. He progressed to command Thumrait and then moved to take command of Masirah when SOAF's second Jag Sqn formed there. I was lucky enough to serve with him at both those bases. He was then promoted again and moved to HQ where he was Director of Operations. He suffered a severe stroke and retired back to UK where he had another 10 years of life during which he made a remarkable recovery thanks to the great support of his wife Gerry. I went to his funeral which was attended by many faces from the past and there was a Harrier fly-past, a fitting tribute to a man who had been on the Tripartite Trial Squadron flying 1127s or the very first military Harriers. A fine aviator, a firm and fair leader and a generous and frequent host for massive meals and loads of drinks in his various Oman residences.

rlsbutler 9th October 2006 10:53

AFS Strubby
 
Can we hear a bit more about AFS Strubby ?

When I came to it in late 1961, it seems to have been the rearguard for all the thousands of Meteor pilots that had gone onto other aircraft or into the night.

As a corollary to the old stories of taking one’s aircraft away for weekend, I could mention how easy it was to join such a unit. Its function was to get up to speed pilots leaving ground tours for a jet posting. I was long-legged enough to be Meteor qualified already. When I found that I was being put on a later Canberra course than I expected, one telephone call to Strubby did it !

Bliss to be more or less unsupervised. I took part only as a spectator in the horrendous dogfights the instructors enjoyed. Otherwise I self-briefed myself into an F8 whenever it had no more deserving customer. A good way to learn: I particularly remember learning very briskly from a jaunt around Lincolnshire under low cloud - recognising just in time the stout steel legs at the very base of the radar mast of Saxton Wold for which I had been quite unprepared.

Naturally, as a very new pilot I was impressed by and wary of the instructors. It was not that they were united by experience but rather that they were so different. Puddy Catt has been mentioned more than once. (Bill ?) Loverseed later became a founding Red Arrow. There was a quiet Sqn Ldr, perhaps the unit commander or perhaps a student but marked out by the ribbon of the George Medal. There was one instructor whose only secondary duty seemed to be to manage the evening appointments of his hairdresser daughter, disposing duty young officer stints to each of us in turn.

The unit display pilot was “Rory” Rorison, of whom I never heard again. An unprepossessing figure on the ground, resolutely unwilling to do his promotion exams so that he remained Fg Off perhaps for ever, his display seemed to be a matter of refining the distinction between concrete and aluminium. I never found out if he toned down his display for public consumption, which would not be in character, or if in fact Strubby wisely kept him to itself.

Wader2 9th October 2006 10:58


A good way to learn: I particularly remember learning very briskly from a jaunt around Lincolnshire under low cloud - recognising just in time the stout steel legs at the very base of the radar mast of Saxton Wold for which I had been quite unprepared.
More likely Stenigot, the Gee-station to the south-west of Louth, as Staxton Wold was north of the Humber.

rlsbutler 9th October 2006 11:06

Wader - agreed. I have gone on muddling these two locations ever since.

Art Field 9th October 2006 13:41

Ah Strubby, a Flight Lieutenant station in 61-62 when I did a refresher there. There was a Sqn Ldr Simpson as the boss but he lived out and nobody above Flt Lt lived in. Post night flying meals were often served by Red Coats from Butlins at Skeggy and the bar had somewhat flexible hours.

There was a four Meteor formation team with Rory, Bill, Dennis Edwards and one other who I am not sure about but it may have been F/O Saunders. Unfortunately the Meteor was still showing its nasty side and my instructor, F/S Jock Black was killed on an asymmetric check with a student.

Also at Strubby were some Hunters used by Wg Cdrs on the Flying College course. For some of them this was rather beyond their skills, it was not unusual to hear "Breaking, breaking, go", look up and see a single Hunter. Wait five minutes and three more shambled in from all directions.

brakedwell 9th October 2006 14:08


Originally Posted by rlsbutler (Post 2897854)
Can we hear a bit more about AFS Strubby ?

Not exactly Strubby, but in 1959 I did a Piston Refresher Course at it's other half - Manby. Never did know why I needed a piston refresher before being posted on to Twin Pioneers in the Gulf when, apart from my Hastings second pilot job, I was averaging 30 hours a month on the Squadron Chipmunks and Anson. An oppo was on the Canberra course at Strubby at the same time so I used to visit the mess regularly. I remember the Grimmy competitions and a one-eyed fish gutter from Grimsby, who was banned from the mess because whoever got to her first always won the kitty! Borrowing a Piston Provost for a weekend away was never a problem in those carefree days.

unclegeorge 11th March 2007 21:43

Meteor accidents
 
I am trying to find out more about my uncle, George Carthew, Pilot Officer, who was killed in a Meteor crash in August 1954, and is buried in Ilminster.
I don't really know how to search for information. Any ideas, guys?
Thanks

henry crun 12th March 2007 01:33

unclegeorge: Do you any other information , where the accident occurred, squadron or unit, etc ?

BEagle 12th March 2007 14:05

I would suspect that this would have been a 208 AFS, RAF Merryfield accident.

Ilminster or Ilton?

brakedwell 12th March 2007 17:04

There were four Meteor accidents in August 1954.
09/08/1954 WK936 Mk 8 245 Sqn Crashed into hangar on ground attack.
16/08/1954 WA966 Mk 8 CFE Lost control in cloud and spun in.
27/08/1954 WH458 Mk 8 RAFFC Lost control and spun in.
27/08/1954 WH190 Mk 7 206 AFS Lost control and spun in.

lawrek03 15th April 2007 21:52

I m interested in the 1956 incident involving 28 Sqn RAF Sek Kong - and am keen to contact Ces Crook. Can you help?

henry crun 15th April 2007 23:30

lawrek03: 28 had five major accidents in 1956, three Vampire and two Venom.

Can you be more specific on type of accident ?

GeoAC 22nd May 2007 20:34

Meatbox crashes
 
As a Fireman at Brawdy 75-79 I can remember seven+Hunters lost , but no Meteors. Although these gorgeous planes were only used for target towing and as an occasional weather kite, the only damage that I can remember these aircraft sustaining were 30mm shell holes in the fuselage(which then got the sticky tape treatment!) caused by some crosseyed would-be jockey!
The most popular ,by far, Pilot of these sorties was Flt Lt Catt , and looking back, it was no wonder the man carried a hip-flask and his pipe!

x10ge 22nd May 2007 21:49

Mike
The RAF LOST more meteors than the current inventory.
Sorry I read too much.
X10GE

BEagle 23rd May 2007 05:02

GeoAC - I share your opinion of Brawdy, having been a sutdent there in 1976. Lucky enough to get a handful of Meatbox back seat trips as well!

'Puddy' Catt was indeed a great character. There was a rumour going around that he'd popped his clogs a few years ago, but that was later found to be false. Hopefully he's still around the Brawdy area, with that booming voice ordering people to "Take beer!" with him in a local pub......

red3 28th May 2007 14:13

risbutler-

Could Rory Rorison be the Flg Off concerned in the great story I was told about the AOC's inspection at Strubby?

AOC meeting pilots in the crew-room, CO introduces said Fg Off...

AOC recognises him from last year, when he had commented on his failure to take the promotion exam, never mind pass it.

AOC: Hello ......., why are you still a Flying Officer?

Fg Off: Because we don't have sergeant pilots anymore, Sir! :ok:

Great story, should be on "wish I hadn't said that", I suppose.

'Wish I'd said it!

BEagle 29th May 2007 13:53

One of Martin Baker's very smart Meteor 7-and-a-halves just went past on the instrument approach to Brize. Great to see these venerable old jets still working for a living...:ok:

Flatus Veteranus 29th May 2007 19:42

Good news Beags. I thought the last flyable Meatbox did its final "phantom dive" a few years ago.

John Purdey 29th May 2007 21:41

Meteor accident statistics
 
Lawrek03 Please see your PMs. John Purdey


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:24.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.