PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Air 2 Air (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/672255-air-2-air.html)

son of brommers 3rd June 2026 10:37

Air 2 Air
 
Have been watching on ADS-B numerous tankers flying racetracks north of Norfolk over the last week, I couldn't help notice that as the receiver arrives in what appears to be close proximity to the tanker before connecting, the receiver stops broadcatsing on ADS-B and then pops back up once fueling is completed whilst the tanker keeps broadcasting.
Any ideas, is this normal practice or just an issue with 2 aircraft being so close together that ADS-B cannot recognise the 2 seperately?

sycamore 3rd June 2026 11:20

Normal practice...

Hot 'n' High 3rd June 2026 11:31


Originally Posted by son of brommers (Post 12096421)
.......... Any ideas, is this normal practice or just an issue with 2 aircraft being so close together that ADS-B cannot recognise the 2 seperately?

Certainly older equipment I looked after suffered from "garbling" when transponders/IFFs were in close proximity to one another and this IEEE paper seems to cover that aspect in ADS-B too. Thus it was (and probably still is) as per the post from sycamore to prevent such issues. :ok:

6foottanker 3rd June 2026 11:34

Stops the tanker TCAS from whinging at the crew. Normal ops.

son of brommers 3rd June 2026 12:25

Thanks all, makes perfect sense.

MechEngr 3rd June 2026 13:11


Originally Posted by Hot 'n' High (Post 12096465)
Certainly older equipment I looked after suffered from "garbling" when transponders/IFFs were in close proximity to one another and this IEEE paper seems to cover that aspect in ADS-B too. Thus it was (and probably still is) as per the post from sycamore to prevent such issues. :ok:

Garbling is when two messages are transmitted too closely in time, not due to spatial proximity. The density in that paper refers to the number of aircraft that can be heard, not the number of planes per cubic meter. This is similar to two people in the same room talking at the same time to a third person.

The mention of TCAS makes the most sense.

Hot 'n' High 3rd June 2026 13:59


Originally Posted by MechEngr (Post 12096565)
Garbling is when two messages are transmitted too closely in time, not due to spatial proximity. ................................. The mention of TCAS makes the most sense.

You may be correct (twas a long while ago I'm going back now) but I understood it was to do with overlapping (in space) of replies when they are displayed back on ATC Radar screens as well as the fact that the ground processor would be dealing with co-incident (in time) replies from a single interrogation when the a/c are very close - not that the ADS-B is triggered that way.

Have I mistakenly combined "garbling" with "superimposition" - with the first being a processing issue and the other being a display issue? :bored: TCAS issues does make sense as well! :ok:

beardy 3rd June 2026 18:03

I seem to recall that tanker and receivers were part of one formation with the tanker being the leader. One formation, one squawk that of the leader, the tanker.


All times are GMT. The time now is 06:00.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.