PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Tornadoes to drop 'concrete bombs' (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/86382-tornadoes-drop-concrete-bombs.html)

GH 6th Apr 2003 07:16

Tornadoes to drop 'concrete bombs'
 
I looked closely at the date, but it says 4th April:


Tornado jets are poised to use yet another different weapon in the war against Iraq ... concrete bombs.

The jets, normally based at RAF Marham in Norfolk, have already used high-tech weaponry such as the "bunker busting" cruise missile Storm Shadow, which cost £750,000 apiece and can pierce several feet of concrete.

But now the crews operating over Iraq from the Ali Al Salem airbase in northern Kuwait are about to go to the opposite extreme and use "inert bombs".

These are basically blocks of concrete shaped as bombs and painted blue to identify them as non-explosive if they are discovered still intact after the war.
Full piece at BBC News

Now we know. It's not about oil... we want all that sand!

P.S. I remember the "Blue Circle" association of the Torando, but is this a late April Fool?

ORAC 6th Apr 2003 07:34

Well, as they always say, train how you intend to fight. ;)

Archimedes 6th Apr 2003 07:36

Don't think this is a new idea - there was talk of using concrete-filled PGMs a few years ago - I think in relation to Bosnia: land 1,000lb of concrete on a tank, and you'll make it difficult for it to pass its MOT, but won't hit nearby civvies or Culturally Unique National Treasures (a phrase that was abandoned about thirty seconds after it was coined...). The most recent references I've seen to this have been about using the training rounds or a deriviative glorying in the name of Minimum Collateral Damage Weapon.

BlueWolf 6th Apr 2003 07:50

There have been reports of them being used already by RAF and USAF ac enforcing the no-fly zones over Iraq (now extended to cover the entire country!), to take out radar sites and the like where there was a risk of collateral damage.

Half a ton of precision-guided concrete going at close to Mach 1 makes a fair mess of sensitive electronic gear!

Beeayeate 6th Apr 2003 08:05

So that dirty, white-dust producing factory coast-wards of St Athan was a muntions plant? Always suspicious of that place, Aberthaw wasn't it?

SASless 6th Apr 2003 08:47

Blue on Blue has taken a whole new definition here!

Memetic 6th Apr 2003 09:17

SASless
 
Perhaps Blue Circle on Blue?

BEagle 6th Apr 2003 14:01

Not a terribly new idea - didn't FAA Wyverns use concrete-headed rockets during the 1950s?

Hardly 'precision guided' back then! Perhaps 'precision-aimed', but the flight path of the rockets after release was, I gather, somewhat arbitrary.......

BlueWolf 6th Apr 2003 15:22

From the deeps of memory come a couple of other examples of "really dumb" weapons triumphing over high tech...

In WWII, NZ soldiers had some success in flushing German troops out of trenches and foxholes in the desert by throwing stones.
The theory, which apparently worked, was that if, at night or in poor light, something landed next to you with a thud, you got out of your hole quicksmart rather than wait to see if it was a grenade.
Why not simply throw a grenade I hear you ask? Probably because, true to British tradition, they weren't in as plentiful supply as they could have been....

During the Soviet incursion into Finland in the same conflict, the Finns managed to take out Russian tanks, using tree branches. The method of operation was to hide behind a tree until the said armour was up close and personal, and then dash out and jam a suitably-sized log into the tracks.
Nip back behind your tree while the tank comes to a grinding halt, and then pop out and shoot the first unfortunate crew member who gets out to see what's wrong.
The Russkies faced a grim choice; stay in your tank and freeze to death, or get out and get shot. The account I read did not mention any Finnish respect for hastily improvised white flags.

Beeayeate 6th Apr 2003 16:35

Yes Beags, it is not a new idea. Back in 60 at 2FTS, Syreston, there were for a while four Kuwaiti Air Force Jet Provost camel-scarers lodge with us. The Kuwati studes (Jaguar saloon drivers to a man) flew with concrete headed rockets under the wings. The destructive powers of even these un-guided weapons was shown by the inadvertant release of a full salvo by one of the studes on the flight-line - the trees and largish earth-heap on the other side of the airfield didn't stand a chance! The spent missiles are probably still on the bottom of the river Trent (for those that don't know Syertson, river runs along the back boundry).

tony draper 6th Apr 2003 16:58

I read about a idea put forward years ago about what were termed kinetic weapons, the suggestion was that large tool steel darts delivered at high speed by the SR71 could sink a carrier.
Might be a roll for the Concoure once they retire her.
Never understood why they retired the Blackbird but kept the U2 operational.

:confused:

Beeayeate 6th Apr 2003 17:24

Imagine the scene though - heat of battle, confusion, smoke, noise, and though the dust, debris and tracer comes a Blue Circle concrete mixer truck with yer typical, fag-smoking, truck driver leaning out the cab window - "' 'scuse me mate, I'm yer close air support. Where d'ya want it, eh? Come on squire, ain't got all day y'know, got two more fire-fights to do before me lunch!"

Jackonicko 6th Apr 2003 20:46

Wasn't there a case in WWII in which a German bomber came over and carefully (and with great accuracy) dropped a stick of wooden bombs on a British dummy airfield. Herman's little 'joke', as it were? I'm sure I read something about it somewhere.

CarltonBrowne the FO 7th Apr 2003 04:44

Of course, the use of concrete in the Tornado is nothing new.... better the bombs than the radar!

rivetjoint 7th Apr 2003 05:30

Maybe you need a concrete "radar" to guide concrete munitions!

ORAC 7th Apr 2003 05:51

Is this an option to being mortared? :O

witchdoctor 7th Apr 2003 21:54

How else do you expect to cement relations with the natives in a post-war Iraq?

rivetjoint 7th Apr 2003 22:35

By laying sound concrete foundations.

tony draper 7th Apr 2003 22:46

Beat your swords into rockeries huh?. :rolleyes:

ORAC 7th Apr 2003 23:15

Only to be used by hard core killers....


All times are GMT. The time now is 16:22.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.