PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Patrouille Suisse F-5E down (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/640685-patrouille-suisse-f-5e-down.html)

STENDEC North 26th May 2021 10:39

Patrouille Suisse? F-5E down
 
https://sputniknews.com/europe/20210...r-jet-crashes/

Look like a midair.

STENDEC North 26th May 2021 11:14

https://aviation-safety.net/wikibase/263091

NutLoose 26th May 2021 11:59

From the aviation safety link


https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....ca411c4523.jpg


https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....8e2da7a063.jpg

https://www.20min.ch/story/kampfjet-...t-482515185952

atakacs 26th May 2021 12:21

Very dramatic images!

For what I understand it was not one of the aerobatic team.

STENDEC North 26th May 2021 12:44

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....ed950ec36.jpeg

STENDEC North 26th May 2021 12:46


Originally Posted by atakacs (Post 11051773)
Very dramatic images!

For what I understand it was not one of the aerobatic team.

Looks like it?

ApolloHeli 26th May 2021 13:36

It was apparently an adversary for an F/A-18 on a training flight



Background Noise 26th May 2021 13:44


Originally Posted by STENDEC North (Post 11051792)
Looks like it?

It does, but I think the point is that it may have been a team painted aircraft but it was not necessarily flown on a team sortie or by a team pilot. One of the references says it was (effectively) an 'aggressor' sortie.

Edit: Timing!

DuncanDoenitz 26th May 2021 13:44

Nice to see Suisse-7 (heli) and Suisse-8 (snowtrac) in the Team livery.

atakacs 26th May 2021 13:47


Originally Posted by DuncanDoenitz (Post 11051814)
Nice to see Suisse-7 (heli) and Suisse-8 (snowtrac) in the Team livery.

:)​​ good one
My understanding is that it was indeed a training flight unrelated to the aerobatic patrol.

Less Hair 26th May 2021 13:47

The aircraft of the swiss military aerobatic team have a day job to display enemy aircraft for training purposes. This was when the red colored aerobatic team aircraft crashed.

dead_pan 26th May 2021 14:21

The a/c looks remarkably intact! Did it ski-doo down the mountainside??

Those images could be screen grabs from a video.

STENDEC North 26th May 2021 15:29


Originally Posted by dead_pan (Post 11051830)
The a/c looks remarkably intact! Did it ski-doo down the mountainside??

Those images could be screen grabs from a video.

They are indeed images from the video, and it did have a relatively soft landing, then slid down the mountain.

NutLoose 26th May 2021 15:34


Originally Posted by STENDEC North (Post 11051851)
They are indeed images from the video, and it did have a relatively soft landing, then slid down the mountain.

It must have set of its homing beacon then.. ;)

Back door 26th May 2021 16:31

ejection
 

sandiego89 26th May 2021 16:36

What is the orange pod on the belly? Tow target pod?

Agree with the remarkably soft landing/slide.

unmanned_droid 26th May 2021 19:07

Just a fuel tank in high conspicuity colour.

tartare 26th May 2021 23:51

Where's the video?!

SATCOS WHIPPING BOY 27th May 2021 00:10


Originally Posted by tartare (Post 11052087)
Where's the video?!

I couldn't find a video as such but found the link below to the closest thing.

Looks like it may be images from a DSLR on high frame rate.

https://www.20min.ch/story/kampfjet-...t-482515185952

(Sorry, just seen same link in Back Door's post)

subsonicsubic 27th May 2021 04:01

Mountain Wave?
 

Originally Posted by SATCOS WHIPPING BOY (Post 11052096)
I couldn't find a video as such but found the link below to the closest thing.

Looks like it may be images from a DSLR on high frame rate.

https://www.20min.ch/story/kampfjet-...t-482515185952

(Sorry, just seen same link in Back Door's post)

Could this be the result of a mountain wave event?

Bob Viking 27th May 2021 07:47

subsonicsubic
 
I think you’re probably grasping at straws there. It’s not a game where you have to think up the most esoteric possible explanation to try to look clever.

For the record I would be truly astounded if mountain waves had anything to do with the crash.

Firstly, the weather looks completely clear (no hint of lenticular clouds, although I appreciate the narrow nature of the photos doesn’t rule it out). Secondly, a mountain wave is incredibly unlikely to cause a fast jet to suddenly stop flying.

Sorry if my reply appears to be a little blunt but I couldn’t help myself.

BV

Less Hair 27th May 2021 08:15

You guys see the flames coming from one or two engines?

Bob Viking 27th May 2021 08:21

Less Hair
 
Yes. I had noticed the flames. Hence my assertion that the crash most likely had absolutely nothing to do with mountain waves.

In my book it would be a little bit like suggesting a crash over the sea might have had something to do with jellyfish.

If I am proven wrong I will gladly come back on here and admit my error.

BV

langleybaston 27th May 2021 19:31

Mountain waves need long ridges, not sharp fangs.

For lenticular cloud to appear needs sufficient moisture and sufficient vertical amplitude of any wave.

I know nothing about accidents but a lot about mountain wave ........ William of Occam would suggest wave goodbye.

blind pew 27th May 2021 20:33

100% sure that mountain waves had nothing to do with it; not only from theories but from flying through and in them both with heavy and not so heavy metal, sailplanes and very occasionally paragliders.
Mountain Rotor is a different kettle of fish but wouldn’t break something like a fighter; again I flown into them sometimes out of necessity, but also accidentally and for « pleasure ».

Jack D 27th May 2021 21:10

Does this count as a kill for the F-18 ? The speculation about mountain waves etc. amuses .

phantomsphorever 28th May 2021 06:58


Originally Posted by Jack D (Post 11052650)
Does this count as a kill for the F-18 ? The speculation about mountain waves etc. amuses .

Kill is a Kill!

Aircraft came down like a rock with zero horizontal speed.
Very unusual for an F-5 - even with both engines flamed out you can keep it flying at 250 KIAS in a 10-12 degree dive.
Either there was a massive engine explosion that took out the hydraulics to the rear of the aircraft, or the pilot manouvered it into some kind of (very) nose high attitude and ran out of speed.
With the elevation at around 7000' at the crash site maybe not enough altitude/time to recover once the nose came back below the horizon?

"Mountain Waves" can definitely be ruled out :-) :-) :-)

Hot 'n' High 28th May 2021 14:19

Glad the pilot is safe, even if slightly stirred!

Originally Posted by Bob Viking (Post 11052245)
..... In my book it would be a little bit like suggesting a crash over the sea might have had something to do with jellyfish. ........

BV, I'd not be so quick to discount that were it to involve Mogwi ..........

Originally Posted by Mogwi (Post 11047308)
..... Speaking as someone who has seen the wake at over 10 miles on a calm day - oh, and seen 5' on the radalt. From time to time! ......

Happy daze! H 'n' H

atakacs 29th May 2021 13:16

Some pictures of the wreck recovery (they cut it in 3 parts and used a Puma to ferry).


https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....9ed39b692d.jpg
https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....08821faa68.jpg
https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....73895b73f5.jpg

phantomsphorever 29th May 2021 21:19

The Swiss F-5 fleet is apparently back in the air - so I guess we can rule out a technical problem :-)


All times are GMT. The time now is 19:36.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.