PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Sea Fury Down (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/640141-sea-fury-down.html)

Not_a_boffin 28th Apr 2021 15:19

Sea Fury Down
 
Pilot OK apparently. That won't buff out.


Asturias56 28th Apr 2021 15:23

been pretty wet over there today................

keith williams 28th Apr 2021 16:10

Three (crashes) out of three really is pretty bad!

They should get the message and stop flying them.


Tarnished 28th Apr 2021 16:13

Thread title is wrong - it never got up in the first place.

Taxi for Tarnished

tolip1 28th Apr 2021 16:25


Originally Posted by Tarnished (Post 11035445)
Thread title is wrong - it never got up in the first place.

Taxi for Tarnished

YEs it did, it was flying around - it was a forced landing.

GeeRam 28th Apr 2021 16:25


Originally Posted by Tarnished (Post 11035445)
Thread title is wrong - it never got up in the first place.

Taxi for Tarnished

I think it did......a little bit, as it appears to have got across the Yeo......

Message from someone I know that lives in the village....was
"I was outside when it took off, by the time it was over my house the old girl was coming down fast.
She went in at Limington, took out a few telegraph poles etc."

UV 28th Apr 2021 16:51

A clearer pic

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....854a70444.jpeg

DogTailRed2 28th Apr 2021 17:29

Damn. Airframe is a loss by the looks of it. I feel sorry for what is left of the RNHF. Three Sea Furies, Sea Vixen, Hawk all out of action. Fortunately with no loss of life.
The venerable old Swordfish still going though. I think ?

Rocket2 28th Apr 2021 17:30

It was doing some circuits & turning finals - my mate was sat waiting to cross the runway & saw her go down. Glad the pilot is Ok, well done sir!

RAFEngO74to09 28th Apr 2021 17:47

Only handed over to Navy Wings 2 days ago as a cost savings measure - that went well !

Charity Saves Historic Naval Aircraft on behalf of Nation (fleetairarmoa.org)


Sloppy Link 28th Apr 2021 18:30

And a Wasp 2011.... but that may have been privately owned.

meleagertoo 28th Apr 2021 18:44

After the recent Avenger accident in the US one has to wonder if time shouldn't be called on these aircraft with incredibly complex 80yr old engines that no-one can afford (even if the expertise exists) to overhaul properly - and the Centaurus is far more complicated than most and seems suffers from it as we have seen several times in ecent years.
Terrible shame.

alfaman 28th Apr 2021 19:14


Originally Posted by meleagertoo (Post 11035525)
After the recent Avenger accident in the US one has to wonder if time shouldn't be called on these aircraft with incredibly complex 80yr old engines that no-one can afford (even if the expertise exists) to overhaul properly - and the Centaurus is far more complicated than most and seems suffers from it as we have seen several times in ecent years.
Terrible shame.

Let's find out why they crashed first, eh? Might have been nothing to do with the airframe or engine, in which case they'd be grounded for nothing.

GeeRam 28th Apr 2021 19:25


Originally Posted by meleagertoo (Post 11035525)
After the recent Avenger accident in the US one has to wonder if time shouldn't be called on these aircraft with incredibly complex 80yr old engines that no-one can afford (even if the expertise exists) to overhaul properly

If what is coming out of that sorry saga is even half true, then cowboy operation is more apt than any inherent problem with keeping a 2600 in the air, which many others don't have a problem doing.


Originally Posted by meleagertoo (Post 11035525)
and the Centaurus is far more complicated than most and seems suffers from it as we have seen several times in ecent years.

As understood it many years ago, the problem with the Centaurus is lack of the correct type of oil. I remember reading an interview with the last person at RR that was resonsible for the Centaurus, and him quoting that he informed all operators of the type (this must be 30 odd years ago) that Shell (I think it was) were no longer going to make the oil, and all operators should get together and order a large batch from Shell otherwise when what is left is gone, that will be it. Shell were the only ones with the formula for the correct grade as designed by Bristol, and the only ones who could make it, but he lamented the fact that the operators couldn't get together and sort this out. From memory, this must be 15+ years now since it all ran out, and why more and more operators have converted them to US radial power. Its been no coincidence that more and more engine problems are being encountered by the few remaining Centaurus engine Sea Fury/Fury, that are likely running on a close but not close enough engine oil spec, with reduced TBO's as a precaution.
I thought I had bookmarked that article from years ago, but I can no longer find it.
​​​​​​​

Less Hair 28th Apr 2021 19:39

Good news they survived. It looks like being built like a tank.

There seems to be another airworthy sister Sea Fury twin seater at Meier Motors. Likely privately owned.
T.Mk20 ES3613 FAA VX302.
https://www.meiermotors.com/index.php/projekte/hawker-seafury-d-cace/hawker-seafury-restaurierung?showall=1&limitstart=
https://www.meiermotors.com/index.php/aircraft/hawker-seafury-d-cace/hawker-sea-fury-d-cace

treadigraph 28th Apr 2021 19:45

GeeRam, I've certainly heard that about the Centaurus and oil.

I don't doubt that the Sanders brothers will be able to restore the airframe in the US either for the present owners if money can be found, or for somebody who has it; I don't know if there is a shop in the UK with sufficient expertise, though Richard Grace is certainly busy with a Tempest or two. It's down but certainly not out but; while not good news for purists, for longevity a R3350 or R2800 would seem safer - though not guaranteed as WG655 proved last year.

Main thing is the crew are able to go home this evening.

DogTailRed2 28th Apr 2021 20:23


Originally Posted by GeeRam (Post 11035546)
If what is coming out of that sorry saga is even half true, then cowboy operation is more apt than any inherent problem with keeping a 2600 in the air, which many others don't have a problem doing.



As understood it many years ago, the problem with the Centaurus is lack of the correct type of oil. I remember reading an interview with the last person at RR that was resonsible for the Centaurus, and him quoting that he informed all operators of the type (this must be 30 odd years ago) that Shell (I think it was) were no longer going to make the oil, and all operators should get together and order a large batch from Shell otherwise when what is left is gone, that will be it. Shell were the only ones with the formula for the correct grade as designed by Bristol, and the only ones who could make it, but he lamented the fact that the operators couldn't get together and sort this out. From memory, this must be 15+ years now since it all ran out, and why more and more operators have converted them to US radial power. Its been no coincidence that more and more engine problems are being encountered by the few remaining Centaurus engine Sea Fury/Fury, that are likely running on a close but not close enough engine oil spec, with reduced TBO's as a precaution.
I thought I had bookmarked that article from years ago, but I can no longer find it.
​​​​​​​

Would the Napier Sabre suffer the same oil problem being a sleeve valve engine? At least one of these is planned to return to the sky at some point.

havick 28th Apr 2021 20:47

Wasn’t there a documentary about a sea fury where the museum pilot crashed it into the only tree in the paddock for miles?

Cat Techie 28th Apr 2021 21:20

The airframe I am told had just came out of winter maintenance last Friday. Civil registered and on a permit to fly. I am told by a friend that used to work at the maintenance establishment the frame was maintained at that this was the second major incident this frame has had after it came out from that operation. Coincidence? Time will tell.



langleybaston 28th Apr 2021 22:02

Sod it!

Beautiful aircraft.

As a lad in shorts I watched their cousins, the Tempests, over Sussex 1945 onwards. The prop fighter of my dreams [and a very pleasant Dinky Toy too!]

So sod it!


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:44.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.