PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Judge Bans F-15s from Urban Training in Idaho (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/636022-judge-bans-f-15s-urban-training-idaho.html)

GlobalNav 6th Dec 2020 21:57


Originally Posted by racedo (Post 10941844)
In which case as you accept Military is under civilian control. You also accept the rights of Citizens to challenge individual actions are allowed by the law. Therefore your desire for the court to just dismiss their action without hearing of it, seems to have you completely out of step with the law.

A court dismisses a case if it is without foundation, otherwise it hears a case and makes a judgement on the case beforehand. Sadly you don't believe in their right to even bring a case becasue it is the military.

Yes, I support the rule of law. So go ahead and sue. But I don’t have a lot of respect for those who place their comfort above the national interest.

tdracer 6th Dec 2020 22:07

The USAF base at Mountain Home has been there for a long, long time (since WW II).
How long have those seven people complaining lived there? Is this just another case of someone buying a home near a source of noise without doing due diligence, then bitching about the noise?

Waypoint Short 6th Dec 2020 22:12


Originally Posted by GlobalNav (Post 10940449)
So, Idahoan’s may lose some sleep as jets fly 20,000 ft above them while training to do a difficult mission.

Read the article. Those flights will take place between 10,000 to 18,000 ft.
The rest of your comments are worthless when you begin with twisting the facts.

OK465 6th Dec 2020 22:13

gums,

I think military flying, particularly fighter aviation, is a little more self-serving than you're representing there with the a$$ risking comment.

What would you have rather done?

(These Strike Eagle dudes aren't going to resign 'cause they can't work over Boise. :})

GN,

What a trooper, willing to sacrifice other's comfort for your conceptual greater good. What is the national interest?

TD,


The USAF base at Mountain Home has been there for a long, long time (since WW II).
How long have those seven people complaining lived there?

Is this just another case of someone buying a home near a source of noise without doing due diligence, then bitching about the noise?
The seven people live in Boise.


MarcK 6th Dec 2020 22:20


Originally Posted by tdracer (Post 10941920)
The USAF base at Mountain Home has been there for a long, long time (since WW II).
How long have those seven people complaining lived there? Is this just another case of someone buying a home near a source of noise without doing due diligence, then bitching about the noise?

Santa Monica Airport was founded in 1923. Reid Hillview airport was founded in 1937. Meigs Field was build in 1948. Crissy Field in 1913. What is your point?

tdracer 7th Dec 2020 00:34


Originally Posted by OK465 (Post 10941923)
The seven people live in Boise.

And Mountain Home based aircraft have never flow over Boise before?

Reminds me a bit of the city of Olympia banning the USS Olympia submarine from visiting its port because it's nuclear powered...

tdracer 7th Dec 2020 00:39


Originally Posted by MarcK (Post 10941926)
Santa Monica Airport was founded in 1923. Reid Hillview airport was founded in 1937. Meigs Field was build in 1948. Crissy Field in 1913. What is your point?

Do you really need to ask? Lots of people complain about the noise from Paine Field - that doesn't mean it should be shut down either. And yes, many of the chronic complainers that bought million dollar homes overlooking Puget Sound that happened to be near the airport moved here from - that's right - California.

megan 7th Dec 2020 00:54


How long have those seven people complaining lived there? Is this just another case of someone buying a home near a source of noise without doing due diligence, then bitching about the noise?
It's an odd thing about airports TD, they often as not were originally built in the boondocks and over the years found themselves surrounded by residential communities brought about by greedy developers and lack of zoning by the authorities. That may in part have been influence by the folk who worked at the airport and wanting to reside close to work, subsequent purchasers just didn't do their homework. It seems odd that I don't hear complaints about railways from the noise adverse, having lived near one as a lad I know how noisy they can be, not that it worried me or anyone I knew. One such airport that was in isolated countryside came to the attention of developers with an open day advertised for a Saturday. Being a military ab initio jet training base the CO issued instructions that all students and instructors were to report for duty on the day and do nothing except circuit training. At first, before they found out the reason, studs/instructors were perplexed because they never worked weekends.

With the F-15 not coming below 10,000 I really don't think noise would be an issue. I live one kilometer from the local threshold with F-15, F-16, F-18, Rafael, SU-30, Gripen, MV-22 depending on the time of year, and a panoply of airline, GA and military transports passing by, jet in afterburner interrupts the TV for a short time, but so what, the wife on the other hand, could it not last longer? :E No curfew either, though the fighters don't operate at unreasonable hours, nor an anti airport group campaigning, perhaps the community has memories of having more ordinance dropped on it than Pearl Harbor, and being the gateway for the countries first international flight.

OK465 7th Dec 2020 01:27

from TD,


And Mountain Home based aircraft have never flow over Boise before?
Anybody can fly over Boise using approved, existing procedures in the NAS.

from the article,


plus plain-clothed soldiers on the ground to simulate urban combat
This sounds like fun. The point is USAF evidently didn't complete the process to meet current requirements (whether you're pro or con) to use Boise airspace 10-18000' and neighborhoods (or Main Street :eek:) to conduct this training.

If they get the approval, I'd provide coffee for the ninjas. Or beer.

Yes, I see now, this is exactly like nuke submarine ops.

MarcK 7th Dec 2020 02:52

Only slightly off topic: Abandoned & Little-Known Airfields is a wonderful documentation of many, many airfields that used to exist and are no more. I'm amazed at the number of airfields on the San Francisco Peninsula and across the bay, some of which were operational when I moved here. Wanting to shut down airports is an activity with some history. An airport I trained at, the University of Virginia Airport, was objected to because "Mr. Jefferson did not allow for an airport or a school of flight in the University's 1812 charter."

radar101 7th Dec 2020 08:06


subsequent purchasers just didn't do their homework
In "Bomber County" in the last few years we have had incomers complaining, not just of aircraft noise but of farmers' cockerels waking early and Church bells ringing (only been there for 800 years) etc. If you live in a city you need to do due diligence before moving to the country.

Me, I'm so blase I only look up to see what is flying if I hear one or more merlin engines (4 is best).


Stitchbitch 7th Dec 2020 18:56


Originally Posted by radar101 (Post 10942102)
Me, I'm so blase I only look up to see what is flying if I hear one or more merlin engines (4 is best).

Six is better, but 10 Merlins, two Griffons and two P&Ws is devine.


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:40.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.