PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Red Arrows - worth the effort now? (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/623681-red-arrows-worth-effort-now.html)

DON T 13th Aug 2019 19:58

I was quite surprised that Red 3 this season is a pilot with TUI flying B737 out of Cardiff. 😜

Tashengurt 13th Aug 2019 20:36

Saw them last year at Sunderland and I havd to say that after a lacklustre airshow with many aircraft way out to sea the reds display was excellent.
Watching them come in head first, rolling around each other for the Tornado was an amazing sight.
I do though, suspect their future is entirely determined by the life of their Hawks.

Nige321 13th Aug 2019 20:41


Originally Posted by DON T (Post 10544267)
I was quite surprised that Red 3 this season is a pilot with TUI flying B737 out of Cardiff. 😜

Was a pilot for TUI, he retired from the RAF at the end of last season, joined TUI, did a couple of months then returned for this year as Red 3 broke his leg... He'll be back on the ALiccante run in November...

lightbluefootprint 15th Aug 2019 11:08


Originally Posted by Avtur (Post 10544023)
Saw the Red Arrows in Halifax, NS on Sunday at the start of their North American tour. Not the full display, presumably due to the location, but nice to see them nevertheless. Was bemused however by the "support" peeps trying to market RAF engineering (and some bird marketing Wales). Not sure of the purpose behind that. Anyway, I hope they manage to drum up some post Brexit business, and have a safe and successful tour. The cynic in me did wonder how much this tour is costing the UK tax payer, and whether they will get a good return for their "investment", particularly as funding for the front line continues to be limited.

One of the Reds objectives is to promote British industry, so it's probably part of their annual budget from Whitehall as they do take occasional tours in an easterly direction too.

Roland Pulfrew 15th Aug 2019 14:56


Originally Posted by lightbluefootprint (Post 10545752)
One of the Reds objectives is to promote British industry, so it's probably part of their annual budget from Whitehall as they do take occasional tours in an easterly direction too.

One major, one minor, one 'at home' is the rotation. Majors were/are: Far East 2016, USA/Canada 2019; Minor was Middle East & Pakistan 2017; At Home was RAF 100 2018. Next year should see a 'minor' tour if the pattern follows tradition.

jumpseater 15th Aug 2019 16:23


Originally Posted by Roland Pulfrew (Post 10545936)
Next year should see a 'minor' tour if the pattern follows tradition.

Greece next year then....

Tashengurt 15th Aug 2019 22:05


Originally Posted by jumpseater (Post 10546003)


Greece next year then....

Well I laughed!

Lyneham Lad 16th Aug 2019 07:14


Greece next year then....

Well I laughed!
Indeed - although it took a few seconds... :)

FantomZorbin 16th Aug 2019 08:02


Greece next year then....
That is awful!!! … and you owe me a keyboard :D:D

Meester proach 17th Aug 2019 02:51

They are still great but I’d probably replace them with a typhoon 3 ship....so as a potential recruitment tool, you are actually looking at what you are aspire too.
Would that be cheaper or have I just spent even more ?

SATCOS WHIPPING BOY 2nd Dec 2019 13:04

...and here we go again with the "Reds to be scrapped" rumours. Isn't it a cyclical story, popping up every 5 years or so?

https://www.getsurrey.co.uk/news/uk-...Bwr9QT4Warcsn8

Finningley Boy 2nd Dec 2019 13:18


Originally Posted by typerated (Post 10522556)
Yes, it is a disgrace when people die on ops for lack of good kit and we fund this

None of these things have bearing on lack of kit, the people responsible for making decent kit provision an uphill battle are the treasury. Soldiers, Airmen and Matlos have died in no end of conflicts since well outside of living memory. I think the only time when the finer aspects of military life were suspended was during World War 2, but then nothing at all could be spared. Unless you were assigned to something like the War Office or Air Ministry film crew.

FB

BVRAAM 2nd Dec 2019 13:26

For the miserable lot who think the Reds are a waste of time, I hope this picture changes your mind.

If they can inspire the next generation, they've served their purpose. This young lad had his childhood made.

Feet together, Red 9... ;)

https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/624/cp...ncopyright.jpg

GeeRam 2nd Dec 2019 14:03

And in that article it also mentioned the RAF Regt might be for the chop.....and

..."The Paras and Marines could be combined into one unit"..... :ooh:
That's like asking the catholic and protestant churches to merge into one!

Asturias56 2nd Dec 2019 14:38

Just junk one of them - keep the RM for choice - they are the senior regiment

beardy 2nd Dec 2019 14:42


Originally Posted by BVRAAM (Post 10630965)
For the miserable lot who think the Reds are a waste of time, I hope this picture changes your mind.

If they can inspire the next generation, they've served their purpose. This young lad had his childhood made.

Feet together, Red 9... ;)

https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/624/cp...ncopyright.jpg

Inspiring. But time is not the point being raised, money is.

BVRAAM 2nd Dec 2019 14:53


Originally Posted by beardy (Post 10631010)
Inspiring. But time is not the point being raised, money is.


If something generates vastly more resources than it uses, wouldn't you say that's a sensible investment?

pr00ne 2nd Dec 2019 15:20


Originally Posted by Finningley Boy (Post 10630961)
None of these things have bearing on lack of kit, the people responsible for making decent kit provision an uphill battle are the treasury. Soldiers, Airmen and Matlos have died in no end of conflicts since well outside of living memory. I think the only time when the finer aspects of military life were suspended was during World War 2, but then nothing at all could be spared. Unless you were assigned to something like the War Office or Air Ministry film crew.

FB

Finningley Boy,

Not letting you get away with that!

Afghanistan and Iraq campaigns were funded from Government Reserve plus a plethora of Urgent Operational Requirements that also did not come out of the MoD budget, so any kit issues around body armour, protected vehicles etc are down to the military not thinking they were required or needed or making them available where they were needed and they already existed.

beardy 2nd Dec 2019 15:58


Originally Posted by BVRAAM (Post 10631020)
If something generates vastly more resources than it uses, wouldn't you say that's a sensible investment?

I would possibly depending on their relative values, but it's not what you said.

tucumseh 2nd Dec 2019 17:16


Originally Posted by pr00ne (Post 10631034)
[B]

Afghanistan and Iraq campaigns were funded from Government Reserve plus a plethora of Urgent Operational Requirements that also did not come out of the MoD budget,

As ever, matters are not that simple. The immediate funding was provided from outwith MoD, but it could be said the Treasury claw some back every year. It is around 19 years since there's been a real world equipment budget increase; and the next one falls short as well. Plus, there are the 'hidden' cuts, such as the creation of QinetiQ and closure of 3rd line workshops - the former was effectively one of the biggest ever cuts in the equipment budget.

To take one example, at the time Herrick kicked off, the Infantry's flagship programme was costed at over £4Bn and approval granted 2 years previously to proceed. The primary aim was to reduce casualties, in a 3-phase programme ending in 2015. In short order, the budget was chopped to around £700M, and the programme extended and diluted to such a degree it is now unrecognisable.

If you don't ask, you don't get. Far far worse, in the Treasury's eyes, is asking, getting, and then saying you don't want it after spending pots of money. For example, Snatch replacement, cancelled in around 2003 despite the Army having made an exemplary case in the mid-90s that it was FAU and had to be replaced. Same with Nimrod MR2 secure comms. All kit bought and on the shelf, and some genius says we don't want it, and the brand new kit scrapped. That was only about £100M at today's prices, but it all adds up to astronomical waste and missed opportunities. To compensate for the lost funding, we see regular rumours like the Red Arrows being chopped. Better that the Services do the job properly in the first place. (None of what I've said had anything remotely to do with procurers).


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:37.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.