PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   France eyes up Boeing CH-47 purchase (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/623572-france-eyes-up-boeing-ch-47-purchase.html)

chopper2004 15th Jul 2019 23:10

France eyes up Boeing CH-47 purchase
 
The French are feasting their eyes on possible purchase of the Chinook, partly heavy lift and more so in support fo their Special Forces.

cheers

https://www.flightglobal.com/news/ar...sition-459660/

Asturias56 16th Jul 2019 07:23

About time - I guess it'll be the Russians next...................

SASless 16th Jul 2019 11:27

Queen of the Skies! Hooks will be flying when we are all gone!

sandiego89 16th Jul 2019 14:10

The Franco/German pooled fleet idea mentioned in the flightblobal article is interesting. CH-47 seems to be a good choice for many.

I am kind of surprised that a European solution for a true heavy helo came to nothing. Seems like it could have been a big winner for all involved- but then again it could have gone down the NH-90 route......

Lonewolf_50 16th Jul 2019 15:48

Chinook is like the C_130 IMO. It's one of those designs that is just really good, useful, and stands the test of time (with the occasional updgrade here and there).

NutLoose 16th Jul 2019 15:59

I supposed it will req RAF C-17's to transport them as well.

orca 16th Jul 2019 16:09

One can only imagine that a Euro Heavy Lift helo would have resulted in the usual Euro narrative of ‘excellence through collaboration’ with the equally usual Euro performance, time and cost indicators to the contrary.

Asturias56 16th Jul 2019 16:47

I guess most European countries have a limited use for heavy lift - there is a full road network everywhere and most of Europe can be driven across cross-country- its only when you go expeditionary or cross beaches you really need a lot of cargo heft.

Pontius Navigator 16th Jul 2019 20:24


Originally Posted by Asturias56 (Post 10520174)
I guess most European countries have a limited use for heavy lift - there is a full road network everywhere and most of Europe can be driven across cross-country- its only when you go expeditionary or cross beaches you really need a lot of cargo heft.

Unless some one drops the bridges.

Evalu8ter 16th Jul 2019 23:01

The abortive Euro Heavy Lift enabled the French and German governments to pump millions of Euros into Airbus to get the answer everyone knew from the start; the rest of Europe was already flying -47s, the -53K wasn’t far away, and a 3rd NATO heavy lift aircraft would therefore struggle to find a market outside the two originating nations and, ergo, be horrendously expensive to buy and operate (likely even more so than the -53K). Nice way of funnelling some money to Airbus though........

Asturias56 17th Jul 2019 07:46


Originally Posted by Pontius Navigator (Post 10520309)
Unless some one drops the bridges.

Cheaper to have truck mounted barges or bridges than a very expensive Heavy lift helicopter tho'............... and you'd have to drop an awful lot of bridges to really screw things up in W Europe

Arclite01 17th Jul 2019 08:52

Or someone drops the roads.................or the railways..............or the airfields

Airlift is only an element of any logistics grid.................


Arc

tdracer 17th Jul 2019 23:27


Originally Posted by Asturias56 (Post 10520591)
Cheaper to have truck mounted barges or bridges than a very expensive Heavy lift helicopter tho'............... and you'd have to drop an awful lot of bridges to really screw things up in W Europe

Certain natural disasters can do that quite effectively and quickly - for example a big earthquake or flood.

SASless 18th Jul 2019 01:30

I thought all it was needed to bring traffic to grinding halt was to declare a Bank Holiday!

Asturias56 18th Jul 2019 14:25

helicopters can be used to move a small amount of critical equipment - how many would it take to support a full armored division without any surface transport for example?

You need some - but for a lot of European countries that number is small

The Sultan 18th Jul 2019 15:39

Eva,

in what world is the 53K not far away?

Davef68 18th Jul 2019 16:03

Presumably their experience with the secondedRAF ones over the last few months have shown them the neccessity of the CH47. On that basis, can UKPLC get a introduction commission from Boeing for the sale? :-)

NutLoose 18th Jul 2019 17:29

What was their last heavyish lift, the Frelon?

PPRuNeUser0211 18th Jul 2019 17:51


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 10521993)
What was their last heavyish lift, the Frelon?

Believe so, though iirc frelon is in the 15T class, 4ish ton disposable I think, so Chinook is a whole other ball game.

Asturias56 18th Jul 2019 17:57

Probably their recent adventures in Africa have shown the need for longer range heavier lift for special forces etc


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:22.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.