PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   How much of being a fighter pilot do you believe is genetic? (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/618095-how-much-being-fighter-pilot-do-you-believe-genetic.html)

Brian 48nav 10th Feb 2019 13:41


Originally Posted by Pontius Navigator (Post 10383329)
Oh dear, Fighter pilot and Jaguar in the same sentence 😁

Had a word with the Off-spring yesterday, and he said ' Tell PN bloody cheek - Didn't you mention all my hours on Mirage 2000 and Gripen?' These ex-single seat guys can be a bit sensitive if they suspect a nav' is taking the p1ss!

langleybaston 10th Feb 2019 16:50

Handedness can be a disadvantage. Chief Forecasters at Bracknell CFO who were left handed were very unpopular because their work position was to the right of the Deputy and they perforce had to analyse, annotate and scribble on one chart. The ideal [I never saw it] was right hand Chief, Left hand Indian. Nobody had the whit to change seats.
Not to mention the totally colour blind chief, who, faced with colours red, blue and purple for fronts etc, routinely marked his crayons thus, only to have them b*ggered by a colleague with wrong labels.
As if the job were not impossible for lesser mortals anyway.

Pontius Navigator 10th Feb 2019 17:01


Originally Posted by Brian 48nav (Post 10385935)
Had a word with the Off-spring yesterday, and he said ' Tell PN bloody cheek - Didn't you mention all my hours on Mirage 2000 and Gripen?' These ex-single seat guys can be a bit sensitive if they suspect a nav' is taking the p1ss!

i stand by the facts. Sticking a 'winder on a Jag or Harrier does not a fighter make..

TLB 10th Feb 2019 19:09

"Mommy, when I grow up, I want to be a fighter pilot."
"You're going to have to make a choice son ... you can't do both"
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Contrary to popular opinion, the average fighter pilot is actually capable of feelings such as love, caring, tenderness and sharing. It's just that these feelings don't include anyone else :p

Lonewolf_50 10th Feb 2019 19:45


Originally Posted by quantify (Post 10384807)
That means there's no way for that individual to further learn and improve? How and why do you think this is, due to mental stress deterring performance or "not having the right stuff"?

I think that you might be forgetting the tax payer in this equation. If you can't learn it in the amount of time (to include the extra time flights when one hits a hicccup) then the tax payer is not required to indulge anyone in their dream of being a fast jet pilot. Each nation and each service has a methodology on identifying weak points and finding out if they are a temporary set back or a case of "can't handle further difficulty." This has all been learned the hard way: In Blood.

CoodaShooda 10th Feb 2019 20:52

As the father of a fighter pilot, I was going to say that genetics are unlikely to be an issue. :(

Then I reflected on his brother and sister's performances in the FA18 sim without prior flying experience and how his daughter gained her first sim-Mig kill at the age of five, compared with my PPL inspired sim disasters.

I am am forced to conclude that genetics could be involved but, in my case, it was recessive. :{

quantify 11th Feb 2019 22:09


Originally Posted by Lonewolf_50 (Post 10386231)
I think that you might be forgetting the tax payer in this equation. If you can't learn it in the amount of time (to include the extra time flights when one hits a hicccup) then the tax payer is not required to indulge anyone in their dream of being a fast jet pilot. Each nation and each service has a methodology on identifying weak points and finding out if they are a temporary set back or a case of "can't handle further difficulty." This has all been learned the hard way: In Blood.

Very true, imagine getting up to that stage and finding out you just can't handle anymore, would be quite frustrating.

quantify 11th Feb 2019 22:10


Originally Posted by CoodaShooda (Post 10386282)
As the father of a fighter pilot, I was going to say that genetics are unlikely to be an issue. :(

Then I reflected on his brother and sister's performances in the FA18 sim without prior flying experience and how his daughter gained her first sim-Mig kill at the age of five, compared with my PPL inspired sim disasters.

I am am forced to conclude that genetics could be involved but, in my case, it was recessive. :{

Wow, thanks for the insight, you must be a very proud father :)

LowObservable 11th Feb 2019 23:41

Back when G-Loc was both lethal and a bit of a mystery, I recall someone remarking that the ideal fighter pilot was a short female with large glutes, who smoked and grunted a lot.

Herod 12th Feb 2019 07:56


there needs to be more research on fighter pilots in general
I think I might know a couple of young ladies who would be happy to oblige ;)

A_Van 12th Feb 2019 09:49

IMHO, ORAC made a wise comment above under post #58.

In critical situations, with extreme motivation and tonns of perspiration
those who may not be genetically ideal may be the best of the best.

IIRC, the average age of the British pilots ("The Few") who defended the country against "Goering aces" in 1940 was about 20. And I assume there was no thorough and timely psycho-medical selection at that time. But they won.


Even in sport, where genetics really matters, there are many examples of that kind. E.g., there is African dominance in medium and long-distance running now. Looks understandable taking into account the anthropometry of Ethiopian and Kenyan guys (thin like sticks, etc). But interesting that only 3 or 4 outperformed British Seb Coe during last 35+ years since he set his fantastic record on 800 m back in early 80's. Or Russian Vladimir Kutz in 50's - he looked more like a boxer or power lifter, but thanks to outstanding training finally became a world and Olympic champ.

NutLoose 12th Feb 2019 10:02


Originally Posted by Herod (Post 10384644)
So was I.

Don't be so sure. A pilot I respected greatly was on the Queen's Flight. Sadly he is no longer with us, but at the commemoration service, a Gp Capt was there, representing the Duke. Neither he nor the Duke suffered fools gladly, so I wouldn't be surprised if Phillip is a pretty good rotary driver, within the constraints of his official duties.

Well at least in a Landrover :)


All times are GMT. The time now is 22:41.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.