PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   56 Sqn July (?) 1940 (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/613700-56-sqn-july-1940-a.html)

rcsa 24th Sep 2018 17:47

56 Sqn July (?) 1940
 
https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....a8cd1031b2.jpg

The Pilot on the far right is Peter Robinson, who joined 56 Sqn in late July 1940, and was killed on 17 June 1941. The picture belongs to a great friend, F/Sgt Robinson's nephew. I'm intrigued by the black/white underwing camo, which I thought was replaced by duck-egg blue straight after the Battle of France. I wondered if any of you wise wizards could confirm that this is 56 Sqn, and hazard a guess at when the photo was taken. It's possible that it is at an OCU prior to Squadron deployment.

Also, any other names to faces would be fascinating. Thanks for any help - and apologies if the picture is over-size; I'm not sure how to correct that...

MPN11 24th Sep 2018 18:06

According to Michael Bowyer's "Fighting Colours", the black/white started be phased out for fighters by end-May 40. However, he also notes that battle-damaged a/c could come back from repair still wearing B/W. It was apparently Feb 41 when the Black was to be removed [presumably at your leisure, there's a War on!!] except for Westland Whirlwinds. "Duck Egg" then took over for general use in UK.

If that photo is an OCU, anything could probably happen until someone had time/effort/equipment to repaint things.

sycamore 24th Sep 2018 18:39

Photo is reversed,,prop is going wrong way , and white underside should be on opposite side...for a Hurricane...

MPN11 24th Sep 2018 19:00


Originally Posted by sycamore (Post 10257365)
Photo is reversed,,prop is going wrong way , and white underside should be on opposite side...for a Hurricane...

Well spotted :ok:

Likewise Brevet on 2nd left.

The plt off's braid looks OK, though.

GeeRam 24th Sep 2018 19:26


Originally Posted by rcsa (Post 10257328)
https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....a8cd1031b2.jpg

The Pilot on the far right is Peter Robinson, who joined 56 Sqn in late July 1940, and was killed on 17 June 1941. The picture belongs to a great friend, F/Sgt Robinson's nephew. I'm intrigued by the black/white underwing camo, which I thought was replaced by duck-egg blue straight after the Battle of France. I wondered if any of you wise wizards could confirm that this is 56 Sqn, and hazard a guess at when the photo was taken.

Photo likely taken Dec 1940- March 1941, as the black/white undersides returned briefly for the winter of 40/41 (specifically between the dates of Nov 27th 1940 to April 7th 1941)
Perhaps the most famous aircraft to be seen back in the return of the black/white undersides during this time was Bob Stanford-Tuck's Hurricane DT-A of 257 Sqn.

rcsa 25th Sep 2018 09:55

Thank you, all. Very interesting and acute observations. Robinson's nephew said that the photo was taken just after his uncle was promoted to an officer, and that within weeks almost everyone in the photo was gone. According to Aircrew Remembered he was commissioned on 5 June, so I guess it's just possible this photo was taken with the last of the 'black and white' aircraft...

Davef68 25th Sep 2018 10:17

The black was re-introduced only on the wing undersides in late 1940

Rallye Driver 25th Sep 2018 14:37

The short pilot in the centre is Edward 'Jumbo' Gracie, who was B Flight commander. The Flight also had sky spinners rather than black ones. Geoffrey Page was also in B Flight. He joined the Squadron on 6 June and was shot down and badly burned on 12 August, but is not visible in the picture, which may help to tie down the timespan.

RD

sycamore 25th Sep 2018 18:11

There is someone hiding between 6-7 from left,as there is a hand/fingers holding the prop....

MPN11 25th Sep 2018 18:55

no. 6 just has long arms, and needs support.

Fareastdriver 25th Sep 2018 19:19

He must have long arms because from this side it's a left hand above a right shoulder.

MPN11 25th Sep 2018 19:55

An early example of Rabbit Ears, perhaps?

Well done, Watson.

Lordflasheart 25th Sep 2018 20:52


Photo is reversed,,prop is going wrong way

Likewise Brevet on 2nd left.
They all appear to be wearing the 1941 Pattern Mae West, which should have the oral inflation tube on the left breast. However, I have no idea when the '1941 Pattern' actually began replacing the '1932 Pattern.'

LFH

Edit - Disregard - Not 1941 Pattern after all. See GeeRam's post below

...........

GeeRam 26th Sep 2018 07:48


Originally Posted by Lordflasheart (Post 10258337)
They all appear to be wearing the 1941 Pattern Mae West, which should have the oral inflation tube on the left breast. However, I have no idea when the '1941 Pattern' actually began replacing the '1932 Pattern.'
.

'41 Patt wasn't introduced until July 1941, so I'm pretty sure they are all '32 Patt, bearing in mind that we already know the photo has been reversed.
Compare with this well known photo of a war weary Brian Lane taken during the BoB wearing a 32 Patt.

https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....73360036ff.jpg

sycamore 26th Sep 2018 10:12

MPN11, perhaps he`s a Nav...!

Lordflasheart 26th Sep 2018 11:14


'41 Patt wasn't introduced until July 1941, so I'm pretty sure they are all '32 Patt,
On closer examination, I do believe you're right, GeeRam. Thank you for the correction. LFH.

.........

radar101 26th Sep 2018 21:25

I kept the 56(R) Sqn Archives for a while up to 2011 when I retired. Yes the photo is back to front. The following is the best guess as to the personnel .

L to R Sgt PEM Robinson; Sgt P Hillwood; Plt Off J J Himr, Plt Off B J Wicks; Fg Off I B Westmacott; Sgt Myall; Flt Lt E J Gracie; Plt Off G G Bailey; Plt Off M Constable Maxwell; Plt Off Wyatt; Sgt Norman Doniger; “Tommy” Guest; Plt Off RFFG Malengreau; Plt Off F W Higginson; Sqn Ldr H M Pinfold (OC 56)

Taffy Higginson was commissioned on 24 Sep 1940, Jumbo Gracie was posted on 7 Jan 1941 so your window is late 1940. Innes Westmacott looks as if he has recovered from the burns received at the end of Aug and Malengreau joined the sqn on 8 Dec so my guess is mid/late Dec 1940.

Radar101

rcsa 27th Sep 2018 05:11

Thank, you, all - and Radar101, that's excellent information. A Christmas Day squadron photo, maybe...
I wonder why it was printed in reverse. The photo is a framed print, so I can't see if there's anything written on the back. But it seems contemporary. I guess the lads had other things to worry about than that someone in the gun-camera processing lab had misprinted their souvenir snap.

radar101 27th Sep 2018 10:28

The copy we had was printed the correct way round - as is the one in "What if the heaven's Fall" a memoire by Eric Clayton about his early days as a fitter with 56


All times are GMT. The time now is 16:24.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.