PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Mi17 - they build them tough! (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/581877-mi17-they-build-them-tough.html)

Tiger Tales 21st Jul 2016 14:35

Mi17 - they build them tough!
 
This photo is allegedly of a Syrian AF Mi17 that was hit by a manpad and the crew managed to get it back to base safely!!
https://scontent-vie1-1.xx.fbcdn.net...6c&oe=582AF56E

Source is from a Farcebook page unfortunately
https://www.facebook.com/IAFSu30/pho...type=3&theater

NutLoose 21st Jul 2016 16:04

It'll buff out, it reminds me of the French Jag that took one and got home. AAA I believe

http://bdd.deltareflex.com/cns_affiche.php?image=7147

http://sylvaingourheu.piwigo.com/_da...56cb994-me.jpg

ORAC 21st Jul 2016 18:02

Who needs wings when you have body lift......

(Yes, the ones on the left are photoshopped, but the story is true)

http://forum.keypublishing.com/attac...1&d=1359511498

NutLoose 21st Jul 2016 19:22

Even McD didn't believe it when they got the call, once a new wing was nailed on it was back up and running in weeks.

Just This Once... 22nd Jul 2016 07:09

Does not look like a manpad strike to me.

Tourist 22nd Jul 2016 07:58

You can see where the projectile hit coming in from the stbd quarter towards the exhaust.

Just This Once... 22nd Jul 2016 19:51

Indeed, the marks are quite clear and are what I based my thoughts on.

Lonewolf_50 22nd Jul 2016 20:15

Just This Once:
Are you suggesting RPG hit it, not MANPAD?

Wageslave 22nd Jul 2016 20:39

I think he's suggesting a canon shell hit by the sound of it. At least, a single one-piece projectile.

???

Just This Once... 22nd Jul 2016 21:56


Originally Posted by Lonewolf_50 (Post 9448834)
Just This Once:
Are you suggesting RPG hit it, not MANPAD?

It could be, certainly fin stabilised. The grazed entry wound does not have the slight rippling you get with a slowish RPG hit on an aircraft skin (although the fire and poor camera angle may be disguing them) but the exit holes are about right for an unexploded RPG, amongst other things. Outside of a random problem I would expect an S5 or larger to go bang in the geometry/structure above, but something like an RPG7 would not. There are no 'whiskers' around the entry point (often seen with glancing S5/S8 hits) either.

Anyway, whatever it was I am sure the crew are grateful that it didn't go bang. Soft skin and a grazing impact probably nicked the fuse off the nose of the projectile.


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:01.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.