PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   New Year's Honours - 2016 (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/572514-new-years-honours-2016-a.html)

NutLoose 1st Jan 2016 23:29

the trouble is in the military the system appears rigged to award those that are in a position to nominate those awards, true you get the odd one that is not an officer or of higher rank, but one see's those as a token effort.

Tankertrashnav 1st Jan 2016 23:37

When I was at university reading Russian I did a dissertation on Russian and Soviet orders as part of my degree.

The Soviet system of awards which evolved from the old Czarist Russian ranks of nobility made our own system look positively niggardly, as medals were awarded on every conceivable occasion including appropriately enough the Order of Motherhood which awarded medals in 6 grades for producing children for the Motherland!

Recipients of medals received more than just a bit of tin and a ribbon. Holders of the Order of Lenin, for example, were accorded the right to go straight to the front of a queue wherever it may be. As long queues were a daily part of Soviet life this was quite a useful perk. Heroes of the Soviet Union and Soviet Labour not only received a solid gold medal, but were granted a "time share" in a dacha (holiday home) usually at a Black Sea resort, with free train travel there and back.

Interesting that a system where everybody was supposed to be equal enthusiastically built up an honours system in which everybody was certainly not equal. I haven't kept up with the post 1992 Russian orders system, but I wouldn't be surprised if it followed the lines of its Soviet predecessor

BEagle 2nd Jan 2016 07:47

Russians? Pah - mere amateurs in the gong-grabbing stakes:

One wonders quite what perks this lot now have!


Does one of them really have a gong dangling from his willy?

CoffmanStarter 2nd Jan 2016 08:16

Perhaps it's to recognise 'Length of Service' :E

4mastacker 2nd Jan 2016 08:28

is that General Wun Hung-Lo?

CoffmanStarter 2nd Jan 2016 08:33

Might also be General Ti Gong Kok ...

BEagle 2nd Jan 2016 09:02

Comrade General Gong on Dong?

JAVELINBOY 2nd Jan 2016 09:17

Looks more like the Moscow Chapter of their version of Pearly Kings

Vendee 2nd Jan 2016 09:17


the trouble is in the military the system appears rigged to award those that are in a position to nominate those awards
Spot on Nutty and to be fair, the same applies to the civil system too. Its just human nature. People in power tend to favour the people closest to them. I know that in the civil system, anyone can "nominate" someone for an honour but its still the people at the top of the tree who have the final say. At the end of the day, the top awards seem to go to the people at the top of the system.

Heathrow Harry 2nd Jan 2016 09:36

To be fair Beagle if your mid ranking US officer wore the actual medals they are awarded (as our friends in N Korea do) rather than than just the ribbon they'd need a pickup truck to carry them around

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped...%28USAF%29.jpg

brakedwell 8th Jan 2016 09:23


...and in the public sector (military included) manifestly fails to penalise failure. On that note, I see the head of HMRC got another award.
The woman is a serial failure!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lin_Ho...d_incompetence

air pig 8th Jan 2016 09:39

One award of a CBE went to an ex army reservist surgeon who spent 6 months as a trauma surgeon at Bastion. He managed an Ebola hospital in Sierra Leone for 4 months and then soon after went to Nepal for the earthquake. As well as fighting the waste of space that is the WHO he was also heavily clinically involved in patient care.


The medics honoured for their response to the Ebola crisis also include Dr Timothy Brooks, head of the rare and imported pathogens laboratory at Public Health England (CBE), and Professor Christopher Bulstrode, Emeritus Professor at Green Templeton College, Oxford (OBE).
Chris is a very humble person and a gentleman. One of the better awards I think.

skua 8th Jan 2016 10:45

As to be expected, Private Eye this week puts a very sharp spear through many of those getting this year's gongs, including that wombat from the HMRC. Depressing reading.

air pig 8th Jan 2016 10:50

Skua:

Sir, you malign a fine creature, unless you wanted to fire the recipient out of a wombat.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L6_Wombat

skua 8th Jan 2016 10:52

Indeed :-)

MOSTAFA 8th Jan 2016 12:55

Heathrow Harry, to be even fairer your picture emphasing your comment about mid ranging American officers is of a 4* General. As high as it goes here in the UK.

Union Jack 8th Jan 2016 14:25

Heathrow Harry, to be even fairer your picture emphasing your comment about mid ranging American officers is of a 4* General.

To be even fairer still, the photograph features the very notable General Curtis LeMay - and a British DFC in addition to his US one, and so many others. No surprise there.

As high as it goes here in the UK.

Although five star promotions "lapsed" in 1995, Royal Family promotions such as The Prince of Wales excepted, there have been a trio of such promotions to honorary five star rank for former CDSs since, namely Charles Guthrie in 2012 and Mike Boyce and Jock Stirrup in 2014.

Jack

Heathrow Harry 8th Jan 2016 14:34

I was looking for this picture TBH - General Cheeseburger

http://www.polarimagazine.com/wp-con...1/11/Kenny.jpg
http://www.pprune.org/data:image/jpe...USZDNcuXLUk//Z

MOSTAFA 8th Jan 2016 15:13

Union Jack

5* is now only a ceremonial appointment only and I think that's probably the same with the US nowadays as well?

Union Jack 8th Jan 2016 19:22

No big whoop as far as I'm concerned, Mostafa, ceremonial or not, but still five stars - unless of course you wish to tell F...., sorry, Lord Guthrie otherwise.:D

With one notable exception, I believe that the cousins have kept the lid on five star promotions, or appointments if you so prefer, since 1945.

Jack


All times are GMT. The time now is 14:48.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.