PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Tornado F2 (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/571724-tornado-f2.html)

Shaft109 10th Dec 2015 21:32

Tornado F2
 
Following on from a previous thread about the F3 I'm curious about this forgotten aircraft.
Were they just trainers or actually capable jets?

I know a little potted history and the repair saga but want to know about their time in service that Wiki doesn't tell you.

O-P 10th Dec 2015 21:49

They weren't 'just trainers', then again, they weren't very capable either!

Apart from the backend and engines, there were numerous avionic differences (single IN etc)

Anyway, they served a purpose...well ish.

There was a quite well developed plan to make the F2s into weasels with ALARM, then came Airworks.

BEagle 10th Dec 2015 21:56

Only 18 of the gutless things were built and they were (fortunately) soon taken out of service. No working AI radar, unable to carry 8 missiles and with countless other faults, they were some of 't bungling Baron Waste o' Space's worst ever aircraft.

I recall an AAR trial with one carrying 4 tanks - we had to descend to around 10000 ft and turn with no more than about 20° AoB in order that the F2 could remain in contact in the turn...:rolleyes:

Courtney Mil 10th Dec 2015 22:05

Just to be clear, Shaft109, the airframes damaged in the Airwork saga were all F3, not F2, although F2 fuselages were used to replace the damaged ones.

As for the F2 itself, it was a bit of a donkey in my opinion. Why it was even bought into service before it was ready and fit for purpose has always been a very sore point - one that still leads to a great deal of scepticism regarding new aircraft being fielded, a specially as it seems to be the norm for the full, promised capability only seems to arrive shortly before end of service.

Shaft109 10th Dec 2015 22:14

F2
 
Sorry yes I knew the F2 were cannibalised to repair the damaged F3, was it easier than fitting the F3 gear into the F2 airframe if that makes sense?

Courtney Mil 10th Dec 2015 22:17

Well, that's pretty much what they did, Shaft. It was the F2 airframe they used. Or have I misunderstood?

O-P 10th Dec 2015 22:18

'Hippo' fit was not just restricted to the F2. It did give you the ferry capability to reach Cyprus (F3), or cross the Pond (E to W), without your truly wonderful services. The fit gave you an additional 7500ltrs of gas...that's about...well a lot! (Yes, there is a drag factor).

Shaft109 10th Dec 2015 22:25

Repair
 
Sorry will clarify - the way I understand it a number (12?) of F3 were damaged by incorrect repairs and so the stored F2 airframes were 'cut up' to get the required new structure centre section, patched in like a cut and shut to the F3.

Or did they gut the F2, bin the bits and engines and then take the F3 engines and kit and retro fit it to the earlier but largely untouched airframe?

Courtney Mil 10th Dec 2015 22:44

Ah, I'm with you now. It was only the centre section of the fuselage so it was an easier job than completely dismantling the entire aircraft and effectively rebuilding it. As it was, the centre sections required a fair amount of internal modification to make them compatible.

RAFEngO74to09 10th Dec 2015 23:29

Tornado F2 Parts To Repair Tornado F3
 
Hansard extract below from here:

House of Commons Hansard Written Answers for 11 Mar 1997 (pt 18)

" Airwork Ltd.

Mr. Sweeney: To ask the Secretary of State for Defence if he will make a statement on his Department's claim for compensation for damage caused to Tornado F3 aircraft by Airwork Ltd. [20069]

Mr. Arbuthnot: A negotiated settlement has been reached in respect of my Department's claim for structural damage to Tornado F3 aircraft while being modified by Airwork Ltd. during 1992-93. I am pleased to report that, of the 16 aircraft involved, 11 have been repaired and delivered back to the RAF and the remainder will be delivered progressively over the next few weeks, with the last due for delivery in May this year. One aircraft was lost in the crash off Blackpool in September 1996, the cause of which was not related to the modification programme on which Airwork had been engaged. The F3 aircraft were repaired by replacing the damaged centre fuselages with those from surplus F2 aircraft which had been earmarked for disposal. This was to ensure that the aircraft were returned to operational service as soon as possible.

In choosing to replace the centre fuselage, the aircraft have been given valuable additional fatigue life. The overall cost of this work has been around £20 million. Taking this improvement into account, together with the costs which might have been incurred had arbitration been pursued, we have agreed that the Bricom Group, which owned Airwork at the time of the damage, will pay £5 million to the Ministry of Defence in settlement of our claim. "

Al R 10th Dec 2015 23:52

Going off at a tangent, am I imagining that the GR5 fleet was grounded at the start of the 90s for similar rectification work?

Finningley Boy 11th Dec 2015 07:11


As for the F2 itself, it was a bit of a donkey in my opinion. Why it was even bought into service before it was ready and fit for purpose has always been a very sore point - one that still leads to a great deal of scepticism regarding new aircraft being fielded, a specially as it seems to be the norm for the full, promised capability only seems to arrive shortly before end of service.
One might say it re-invented the Gloster Javelin, now there was never quite ready Fighter! Right through its operational service from FAW1 to FAW9R.

FB:)

chevvron 11th Dec 2015 07:34


Originally Posted by BEagle (Post 9206958)
Only 18 of the gutless things were built and they were (fortunately) soon taken out of service. No working AI radar, unable to carry 8 missiles and with countless other faults, they were some of 't bungling Baron Waste o' Space's worst ever aircraft.

Attending ATC camp at Coningsby in '89, we were told the F2s didn't have ANY AI radar, just a lump of concrete to keep the CG correct. There were some USAF F15s there at the time and I watched an F2 try to emulate an F15 departure; he levelled off at about 2,000ft.

ORAC 11th Dec 2015 07:50


Attending ATC camp at Coningsby in '89, we were told the F2s didn't have ANY AI radar, just a lump of concrete to keep the CG correct.
Technically known as the BLUE CIRCLE radar...... ;)

Rhino power 11th Dec 2015 09:57


Originally Posted by chevvron (Post 9207283)
...I watched an F2 try to emulate an F15 departure; he levelled off at about 2,000ft.

Must've been an F.3 you watched, the F.2's were all gone from 229 OCU during 1987. I had a base visit in June of 1987 with my local ATC Sqn, 228 OCU had recently relocated to Leuchars (bugger, said I...), and we had a tour of the OCU hangar and it was full of newly delivered F.3's having post delivery inspections, along with those already on the OCU. We also had a tour of the 29 Sqn HAS site and they were all F.3's as well, although to be fair, 29 never operated the F.2 anyway, I don't recall seeing an F.2 on base at all...

-RP

Red Line Entry 11th Dec 2015 12:12

The flying ballast for the radar was never (at least from my experience) concrete. It was a thick metal disc that was both blue and circular - hence the Blue Circle epithet.

dougieb2 11th Dec 2015 14:11

http://i664.photobucket.com/albums/v...psb9j2hbv7.jpg


By way of a comparison here's one of my holiday snaps from that treasure in the med.

Bob Viking 11th Dec 2015 16:41

One quick question...
 
I'm no engineer but why wouldn't you park them with their wings folded to save space? Was it too much of a faff to power up and move the services?

Honest question, not a wind up.

BV:O

Stitchbitch 11th Dec 2015 16:48

BV not sure but I don't think they did, at least iirc the wings weren't swept when they were jammed in the hangar on a Friday afternoon - 56(R) - despite the aircraft being pushed in like they'd been playing a giant game of twister.

izod tester 11th Dec 2015 16:50

I was operating a desk when the Tornado entered service, but I would suggest that the CoG may have been a bit marginal on the ground with the wings fully swept.


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:25.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.