PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Hawker Hunter Crash at Shoreham Airshow (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/566533-hawker-hunter-crash-shoreham-airshow.html)

Stitchbitch 23rd Dec 2015 08:48

Most shelf life has a certain amount of wiggle room built in, but I wouldn't like to put my trust in something designed to save my life that has l/x components fitted. That's a huge list of kit from flying clothing to fuel tanks and not just seat carts.

abgd 23rd Dec 2015 08:52

If you offered me a ride in a Hunter with no ejection seat whatsoever, I'd take it. I wouldn't be putting anybody else at risk. I don't see a big issue here in practical terms, and wouldn't extrapolate to a judgement of the rest of the maintenance from this single issue.

A and C 23rd Dec 2015 09:29

Stitchbitch
 
I don't think we are in disagreement, the kit should be in a position to do what is says on the tin.

But if you have a big change of operating conditions it is appropriate to review the time you keep an item in service. As I said above this review could reduce or extend service life as appropriate to the conditions.

Courtney Mil 23rd Dec 2015 09:45

Whilst it is true that the operating conditions for the components have changed, which MAY affect installed life, you will also note that the shelf life remains a limiting factor and I doubt storage conditions are significantly different. Moreover, as there are neither data nor a proper evaluation of installed life under the new operating condition it is not possible to calculate a new installed life.

I am commenting here purely on the practicalities of component life, NOT any process that is, or has been, in place.

MATELO 21st Jan 2016 13:47

Shoreham Airshow Cancelled for 2016.

Shoreham Airshow Cancelled After 2015 Disaster

Courtney Mil 1st Feb 2016 17:42

For all you self-professed accident experts.
 
The Air Accidents Investigation Branch will shortly be advertising for an Inspector of Air Accidents (Operations). Given the level of expertise here, I thought you might like to know.

Lonewolf_50 1st Feb 2016 19:18


Originally Posted by Courtney Mil (Post 9255773)
The Air Accidents Investigation Branch will shortly be advertising for an Inspector of Air Accidents (Operations). Given the level of expertise here, I thought you might like to know.

The sarcasm dripping from that post nearly melted my monitor. :D

ORAC 1st Feb 2016 19:42

Well I was the SFSO South Atlantic and Ops 1 at Stanley/MPA when the C130 collided with the Sea King, and had a very interesting and eventful couple of months.

But that was over 30 years ago........

Pontius Navigator 1st Feb 2016 21:00

I had occasion to contact the CAA about 20 years ago. My POC was an ex-Wellington Nav so 30 years is nothing.

Super VC-10 2nd Feb 2016 12:37

Breaking on BBC South East News -

The police investigation is being extended to include an incident at an airshow in Southport, Lancashire in 2014.

No further details atm, but one wonders whether the same pilot, aircraft or combination of both was involved.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-sussex-35473857

Cows getting bigger 2nd Feb 2016 13:16

Southport 2014. This one? (go to 2:10 onwards)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZHngQ8TmqU4

Above The Clouds 2nd Feb 2016 14:52

CGB

I think you mean this one.

https://youtu.be/RwhLSHpeiE8

Super VC-10 2nd Feb 2016 14:57

Watched that (GCB's video) twice and didn't see anything that made me wince or anything like that. BBC does not state which a/c involved, but TV promised more on tonight's bulletin, which I won't see due to a clash with something else. I will see the ITV local bulletin at 6pm though, so will report any developments from there.

Now to watch ATC's video.

Super VC-10 2nd Feb 2016 15:05

ATC's video does show the a/c getting a bit low, but I'd like to see a better shot of closeness to ground if possible. Was the same pilot involved here?

maliyahsdad2 2nd Feb 2016 15:07

Photo of the Jet provost at Southport 2014 as published in the Liverpool Echo. Don't know if this is the incident. http://i1.liverpoolecho.co.uk/incomi...JS46835858.jpg

- And another shot here!
http://www.wetcanvas.com/Community/i...psf9960610.jpg

Super VC-10 2nd Feb 2016 15:26

For those who are not aware, Wikipedia has an article.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_S..._Airshow_crash

Simplythebeast 2nd Feb 2016 15:29

Im sure there were many such manouvres at airshows all over the place. Sadly the days of a proper airshow in the UK look like they are over, reduced to flypasts.

Above The Clouds 2nd Feb 2016 15:55

This is other video on youtube, start watching around 9:50 and you will see the roll recovery from a different angle but this time relative to a public speaker on a pole at the airshow.

https://youtu.be/7yQmq8i0HG4

Sadly there are discussions on other forums and they seem to be implying it was the same pilot AH, although I will wait to hear that announced officially.

NavyNav2 2nd Feb 2016 16:12

ITV news site confirming same pilot involved in both incidents.
http://www.itv.com/news/2016-02-02/i...cond-incident/

H Peacock 2nd Feb 2016 17:28

The JP at Southport clearly infringed the display minima, both laterally (too close to the crowd) and vertically ( too close to the ground). But it would appear to have been the result of a poorly executed roll during which the nose was not held high enough. Once the nose got low it was always going to be quite a hairy escape manoeuvre!


All times are GMT. The time now is 06:48.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.